系统范围综述:乳腺保乳手术术中切缘分析中标本乳腺X线摄影的实践差异及人工智能在优化诊断准确性中的作用
本系统范围综述检索4个数据库,最终纳入40项研究,评估乳腺保乳手术标本乳腺X线摄影用于术中切缘分析的方法学差异及人工智能作用。39/40项研究未使用人工智能,标本乳腺X线摄影技术(包括拍摄体位数量和位置)差异广泛,诊断准确性敏感度19%–91.7%、特异度25%–100%。仅1项研究将人工智能用于标本乳腺X线摄影判读,作者提出人工智能可优化判读并减少不必要差异的框架。
要点
- 标本乳腺X线摄影用于保乳手术术中切缘分析时,拍摄体位数量和位置存在广泛技术差异。
- 日常临床中判读标本乳腺X线摄影的专科医生以放射科医生(16/39,41%)和外科医生(13/39,33%)为主。
- 研究中判读专科与常规临床实践不同者占15/39(38%),诊断准确性敏感度19%–91.7%、特异度25%–100%。
核心结论
- 标本乳腺X线摄影用于术中切缘分析的技术存在显著差异,诊断准确性相应悬殊。
- 仅1项研究将人工智能应用于标本乳腺X线摄影判读,作者提出人工智能可优化判读、减少不必要差异并优化诊断准确性的框架。
研究设计与样本
- 系统范围综述,检索Embase、Pubmed、Cochrane和Web of Science数据库。
- 初检1242项唯一研究,最终纳入40项;纳入标准为标本乳腺X线摄影用于保乳手术切缘分析并报告与病理切缘状态比较的诊断准确性。
- 39/40项研究未使用人工智能判读,其中4项研究比较2种相关技术,共形成43个非人工智能研究组进行分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 诊断准确性以病理切缘状态为参考标准,研究间敏感度范围19%–91.7%,特异度范围25%–100%。
- 常规临床实践中判读标本乳腺X线摄影的专科:外科医生13/39项研究(33%)、放射科医生16/39项研究(41%)、外科医生和放射科医生3/39项研究(8%)、未说明7/39项研究(18%)。
- 研究中判读专科与常规临床实践不同者15/39项研究(38%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Specimen Mammography (SM) is commonly used in Breast Conserving Surgery (BCS) for intraoperative margin analysis. A systematic scoping review was conducted to identify sources of methodological variation in Specimen Mammography Interpretation (SMI) and assess the role of Artificial Intelligence (AI) techniques to optimise Diagnostic Accuracy (DA).
METHODS: Embase, Pubmed, Cochrane and web of science databases were searched. Studies were included if SM was used for margin analysis for BCS with reported DA compared with pathological margin status and data extracted.
RESULTS: 1242 unique studies were identified, of which 40 were included. 39/40 studies did not utilise AI for SMI, with 4 studies comparing 2 relevant techniques, giving 43 non-AI study arms for analysis. There was wide variation in SM techniques, including number of views and location of SM. Specialist performing SMI in usual clinical practice was surgeon (13/39 studies;33 %), radiologist(s) (16/39;41 %), surgeon and radiologist (3/39;8 %) or not stated (7/39;18 %) which differed from the study specialist in 15/39 (38 %) of studies. Diagnostic accuracy in studies ranged from sensitivity 19-91.7 % and specificity 25-100 %.
CONCLUSIONS: There is marked variation in current techniques used for SM for intraoperative margin analysis with correspondingly disparate DA. Only 1 study applied AI to SMI, and we identify how AI could optimise SMI and a template for future work to apply AI techniques to SMI, reduce unwarranted variation and optimise DA.
引用
- Hubbard TJE, Shams O, Gardner B, et al. A systematic scoping review exploring variation in practice in specimen mammography for Intraoperative Margin Analysis in Breast Conserving Surgery and the role of artificial intelligence in optimising diagnostic accuracy. Eur J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 39393216. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111777
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。