协作在产前先天性心脏病诊断中的作用:母胎医学专科医生与儿科心脏病学家的表现比较
本研究以出生后心脏检查为参考标准,回顾性比较母胎医学专科医生与儿科心脏病学家对胎儿先天性心脏病的诊断准确性;两者准确性高且各分类无统计学显著差异,但儿科心脏病学家在误诊可能显著影响新生儿照护的病例中似乎表现更优,作者认为疑似胎儿先心病尤其复杂病例仍需与儿科心脏病学家协作。
要点
- 母胎医学专科医生与儿科心脏病学家产前诊断先心病的各分类准确性无统计学显著差异(P=.375-.832)。
- 母胎医学专科医生诊断准确性最高为法洛四联症94.4%(95%CI 72.7-99.9%),最低为右房异构71.4%(95%CI 29-96.3%)与室间隔缺损型肺动脉闭锁57.1%(95%CI 18.4-90.1%)。
- 儿科心脏病学家在误诊可能显著影响新生儿照护和结局的病例中似乎表现更优,疑似胎儿先心病尤其复杂病例仍需与其协作。
核心结论
- 母胎医学专科医生与儿科心脏病学家在产前先天性心脏病诊断中表现出高且可比的准确性。
- 尽管儿科心脏病学家在误诊可能显著影响新生儿照护和结局的病例中似乎表现更优,母胎医学专科医生可对所有妊娠有效进行胎儿先天性心脏病的一线筛查。
- 疑似胎儿先天性心脏病时,尤其复杂病例,与儿科心脏病学家协作仍然必不可少。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析,地点为泰国曼谷Siriraj医院,纳入125例由母胎医学专科医生诊断、随后由儿科心脏病学家评估的胎儿先天性心脏病妊娠。
- 将母胎医学专科医生或儿科心脏病学家的产前先天性心脏病诊断与出生后经超声心动图、心脏手术/导管检查或尸检获得的诊断进行比较。
- 诊断准确性分为三类:(A) 正确诊断,(B) 不影响临床管理或结局的微小差异,(C) 影响预后或治疗的重大差异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 母胎医学专科医生超声诊断准确性:A类73.6%、B类16%、C类10.4%。
- 儿科心脏病学家胎儿超声心动图诊断准确性:A类72%、B类20%、C类8%。
- 母胎医学专科医生与儿科心脏病学家各分类间差异均无统计学显著差异(P=.375-.832)。
- 母胎医学专科医生准确性最高为法洛四联症94.4%(95%CI 72.7-99.9%),最低为右房异构71.4%(95%CI 29-96.3%)和室间隔缺损型肺动脉闭锁57.1%(95%CI 18.4-90.1%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 母胎医学专科医生可对所有妊娠有效进行胎儿先天性心脏病的一线筛查。
- 疑似胎儿先天性心脏病时,尤其复杂病例,与儿科心脏病学家协作仍然必不可少。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study compared the accuracy of prenatal congenital heart disease (CHD) diagnosed by maternal-fetal medicine specialists (MFMs) and pediatric cardiologists (PCs), using postnatal cardiac findings as the reference standard.
METHODS: This retrospective analysis at Siriraj Hospital, Bangkok, Thailand, involved 125 pregnancies with fetal CHD diagnosed by MFMs and evaluated by PCs later. Prenatal CHD diagnoses by either MFM or PC were compared with postnatal diagnoses obtained through echocardiography, cardiac surgery/catheterization, or autopsy. Diagnostic accuracy was classified as (A) correct diagnosis, (B) minor differences not impacting clinical management or outcomes, or (C) major differences affecting prognosis or treatment.
RESULTS: Cardiac sonography by MFM achieved diagnostic accuracies of 73.6% (A), 16% (B), and 10.4% (C), while fetal echocardiography by PC resulted in accuracies of 72% (A), 20% (B), and 8% (C). No statistically significant differences were found between MFM and PC in each category (P = .375-.832). The MFMs' accuracy was highest for tetralogy of Fallot (94.4%; 95% CI, 72.7-99.9%) and lowest for right atrial isomerism (71.4%; 95% CI, 29-96.3%) and pulmonary atresia with ventricular septal defect (57.1%; 95% CI, 18.4-90.1%).
CONCLUSIONS: MFMs and PCs demonstrated high and comparable accuracy in prenatal CHD diagnosis. Although PCs tended to outperform MFMs in cases where misdiagnosis could significantly impact neonatal care and outcomes, MFMs can effectively perform primary screening for fetal CHD in all pregnancies. Collaboration with PCs remains essential when fetal CHD is suspected, particularly in complex cases.
引用
- Anuwutnavin S, Kuichanuan M, Sompagdee N, et al. The Role of Collaboration in Prenatal Congenital Heart Disease Diagnosis: A Comparison of Maternal-Fetal Medicine Specialist and Pediatric Cardiologist Performance. J Ultrasound Med. 2024. PMID: 39425632. doi:10.1002/jum.16606
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。