文献速递神经MR

痴呆中的自动容积软件:对神经放射科医生是帮助还是妨碍?

Automated Volumetric Software in Dementia: Help or Hindrance to the Neuroradiologist?
PubMed 文献 · AJNR Am J Neuroradiol · 2024-11-07

研究比较了22例阿尔茨海默病、17例额颞叶痴呆和21例认知健康受试者的T1加权MRI,四位神经放射科医生分别在有和无容积报告的情况下诊断,结果显示容积报告未显著提高总体诊断准确率,事后分析提示报告可能使认知健康受试者被误判为神经退行性疾病。

要点

  • 容积报告未显著提高神经放射科医生诊断AD或FTD的总体准确率。
  • 事后分析显示容积报告使AD诊断准确率提高(OR=2.77),但使认知健康诊断准确率降低(OR=0.25)。
  • AD和FTD患者的海马残余体积较认知健康者更小,AD平均差-1.8,FTD平均差-1.2。

核心结论

  • 在该有限样本中,脑容积报告未能提高神经放射科医生视觉评估诊断AD或FTD的准确率;事后分析提示报告可能使读者在认知健康成人中错误地偏向神经退行性诊断。

研究设计与样本

  • 从电子健康记录和行为神经病学诊所识别22例AD、17例FTD和21例认知健康患者,四位神经放射科医生在有和无容积报告的情况下评估T1加权解剖MRI。

关键影像表现/征象

  • AD和FTD患者的海马残余体积较认知健康者更小,AD平均差-1.8(多重比较校正-2.8至-0.8,P<.001),FTD平均差-1.2(多重比较校正-2.2至-0.1,P=.02)。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 结局指标为神经退行性疾病与正常老化诊断的正确比例(「粗略准确率」)以及AD与FTD诊断的正确比例(「精确准确率」)。
  • 精确正确诊断比例:有报告 vs 无报告,AD为0.52 vs 0.38,FTD为0.49 vs 0.32,认知健康为0.75 vs 0.89。
  • 粗略正确诊断比例:有报告 vs 无报告,AD组为0.59 vs 0.41,FTD组为0.66 vs 0.63。
  • 事后组内分析提示报告使AD诊断准确率提高(OR=2.77),使认知健康诊断准确率降低(OR=0.25)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者结论指出,在该有限样本中,脑容积报告未提高神经放射科医生视觉评估诊断AD或FTD的准确率。
  • 作者事后分析提示,报告可能使读者在认知健康成人中错误地偏向神经退行性诊断。

局限性

  • 原文结论指出该研究为有限样本。
  • 事后分析提示报告可能使读者在认知健康成人中错误地偏向神经退行性诊断。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Brain atrophy occurs in the late stage of dementia, yet structural MRI is widely used in the work-up. Atrophy patterns can suggest a diagnosis of Alzheimer disease (AD) or frontotemporal dementia (FTD) but are difficult to assess visually. We hypothesized that the availability of a quantitative volumetric brain MRI report would increase neuroradiologists' accuracy in diagnosing AD, FTD, or healthy controls compared with visual assessment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-two patients with AD, 17 with FTD, and 21 cognitively healthy patients were identified from the electronic health systems record and a behavioral neurology clinic. Four neuroradiologists evaluated T1-weighted anatomic MRI studies with and without a volumetric report. Outcome measures were the proportion of correct diagnoses of neurodegenerative disease versus normal aging ("rough accuracy") and AD versus FTD ("exact accuracy"). Generalized linear mixed models were fit to assess whether the use of a volumetric report was associated with higher accuracy, accounting for random effects of within-rater and within-subject variability. Post hoc within-group analysis was performed with multiple comparisons correction. Residualized volumes were tested for an association with the diagnosis using ANOVA.

RESULTS: There was no statistically significant effect of the report on overall correct diagnoses. The proportion of "exact" correct diagnoses was higher with the report versus without the report for AD (0.52 versus 0.38) and FTD (0.49 versus 0.32) and lower for cognitively healthy (0.75 versus 0.89). The proportion of "rough" correct diagnoses of neurodegenerative disease was higher with the report than without the report within the AD group (0.59 versus 0.41), and it was similar within the FTD group (0.66 versus 0.63). Post hoc within-group analysis suggested that the report increased the accuracy in AD (OR = 2.77) and decreased the accuracy in cognitively healthy (OR = 0.25). Residualized hippocampal volumes were smaller in AD (mean difference -1.8; multiple comparisons correction, -2.8 to -0.8; P < .001) and FTD (mean difference -1.2; multiple comparisons correction, -2.2 to -0.1; P = .02) compared with cognitively healthy.

CONCLUSIONS: The availability of a brain volumetric report did not improve neuroradiologists' accuracy over visual assessment in diagnosing AD or FTD in this limited sample. Post hoc analysis suggested that the report may have biased readers incorrectly toward a diagnosis of neurodegeneration in cognitively healthy adults.

来源:AJNR Am J Neuroradiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Tanabe J, Lim MF, Dash S, et al. Automated Volumetric Software in Dementia: Help or Hindrance to the Neuroradiologist? AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2024. PMID: 39362700. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8406

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。