通过共识调查对CT图像质量特征的相对重要性进行排序
本研究对腹部、心脏、急诊、骨肌、神经、儿科、胸部放射学及医学物理学的亚专科放射科医生和医学物理师进行前瞻性问卷调查,要求对10项CT图像质量特征的相对重要性进行评分并计算归一化均值、优先排序及组内一致性。结果显示多数亚专科组内一致性中等至优秀,除骨肌外各放射亚专科均认为运动伪影最重要,各亚专科对噪声幅度的相对重要性存在分歧,图像质量偏好因临床任务和解剖亚专科而异。
要点
- 除骨肌放射学外,所有放射亚专科均将运动列为最重要的图像质量特征。
- 各亚专科一致认为轴向锐度和对比度仅具有中等重要性。
- 心脏放射学认为光晕伪影高度重要,骨肌放射学认为噪声纹理高度重要。
核心结论
- 图像质量偏好因各解剖放射亚专科的临床任务和挑战而异,CT图像分析、定量质量指标开发及协议优化和相关政策举措应针对放射亚专科。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性问卷调查,对象为亚专科放射科医生和医学物理师,先发送给在ACR和RSNA担任志愿者领导角色的亚专科放射科医生,之后采用滚雪球抽样;调查亚专科为腹部、心脏、急诊、骨肌、神经、儿科、胸部放射学及医学物理;对个体评分进行归一化以计算各亚专科内各特征的均值归一化评分和优先排序,并计算亚专科内图像质量特征的组内相关系数及每个特征跨亚专科的方差分析。
关键影像表现/征象
- 大多数亚专科具有中等至优秀的组内一致性。
- 除骨肌放射学外,每个放射亚专科均将运动列为最重要的图像质量特征。
- 各亚专科一致认为轴向锐度和对比度仅具有中等重要性。
- 各亚专科对噪声幅度的相对重要性存在分歧。
- 光晕伪影对心脏放射科医生高度重要,噪声纹理对骨肌放射科医生高度重要。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study sought to determine consensus opinions from subspecialty radiologists and imaging physicists on the relative importance of image quality features in CT.
METHODS: A prospective survey of subspecialty radiologists and medical physicists was conducted to collect consensus opinions on the relative importance of 10 image quality features: axial sharpness, blooming, contrast, longitudinal sharpness, low-contrast axial sharpness, metal artifact, motion, noise magnitude, noise texture, and streaking. The survey was first sent to subspecialty radiologists in volunteer leadership roles in the ACR and RSNA, thereafter relying on snowball sampling. Surveyed subspecialties were abdominal, cardiac, emergency, musculoskeletal, neuroradiology, pediatric, and thoracic radiology and medical physics. Individual respondents' ratings were normalized for calculation of mean normalized ratings and priority rankings for each feature within subspecialties. Also calculated were intraclass correlation coefficients across image quality features within subspecialties and analysis of variance across subspecialties within each feature.
RESULTS: Most subspecialties had moderate to excellent intraclass agreement. For every radiology subspecialty except musculoskeletal, motion was the most important image quality feature. There was agreement across subspecialties that axial sharpness and contrast are only moderately important. There was disagreement across subspecialties on the relative importance of noise magnitude. Blooming was highly important to cardiac radiologists, and noise texture was highly important to musculoskeletal radiologists.
CONCLUSION: Image quality preferences differ based on clinical tasks and challenges in each anatomical radiology subspecialty. CT image analysis and development of quantitative measures of quality and protocol optimization-and related policy initiatives-should be specific to radiology subspecialty.
引用
- Gress DA, Samei E, Frush DP, et al. Ranking the Relative Importance of Image Quality Features in CT by Consensus Survey. J Am Coll Radiol. 2024. PMID: 39427722. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2024.10.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。