影像组学研究质量:对89篇综述中1574篇独特出版物的全面分析
该研究通过检索PubMed(截至2024年4月14日),纳入89篇使用影像组学质量评分(RQS)评估影像组学研究的系统或非系统综述,并从中提取1574篇独特论文进行综合分析。结果显示RQS百分比中位数为31%(IQR 25%,第25-75百分位14-39%),发表年份(2014-2023年)与RQS百分比呈正相关(Kendall's tau=0.908,p<0.001),不同放射学子领域间质量差异显著(p<0.001),32%的出版物缺乏独立验证集。结论认为影像组学研究质量总体较低但随时间改善,并识别出需针对性改进的关键领域。
要点
- 影像组学研究总体RQS百分比中位数为31%,质量普遍较低但2014-2023年呈改善趋势。
- 32%的出版物缺乏独立验证集,内部验证(54%)远多于外部验证(14%)。
- 不同放射学子领域及验证方法间影像组学研究质量存在显著差异(p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 根据RQS评估,影像组学研究质量较低但正在改善,不同放射学子领域间存在显著差异,并识别出需针对性改进的关键领域。
研究设计与样本
- 文献分析研究,检索PubMed(最后检索日期2024年4月14日),纳入89篇使用RQS评估影像组学研究的系统或非系统综述,最终分析其中1574篇独特论文(在线发表于1999年至2023年)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 采用影像组学质量评分(RQS)评估,纳入论文的RQS百分比中位数为31%,IQR为25%(第25-75百分位14-39%);发表年份(2014-2023年)与RQS百分比正相关,Kendall's tau=0.908(p<0.001);32%的出版物缺乏独立验证集,内部验证占54%,外部验证占14%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: This study aims to comprehensively evaluate the quality of radiomics research by examining unique papers from reviews using the radiomics quality score (RQS).
METHODS: A literature search was conducted in PubMed (last search date: April 14, 2024). Systematic or non-systematic reviews using the RQS to evaluate radiomic studies were potentially included. Exclusion was applied at two levels: first, at the review level, and second, at the study level (i.e., for the individual articles previously evaluated within the reviews). Score-wise and item-wise analyses were performed, along with trend, multivariable, and subgroup analyses based on baseline study characteristics and validation methods.
RESULTS: A total of 1574 unique papers (published online between 1999 and 2023) from 89 reviews were included in the final analysis. The median RQS percentage was 31% with an IQR of 25% (25th-75th percentiles, 14-39%). A positive correlation between median RQS percentage and publication year (2014-2023) was found, with Kendall's tau coefficient of 0.908 (p < 0.001), suggesting an improvement in quality over time. The quality of radiomics publications significantly varied according to different subfields of radiology (p < 0.001). Around one-third of the publications (32%) lacked a separate validation set. Papers with internal validation (54%) dominated those with external validation (14%). Higher-quality validation practices were significantly associated with better RQS percentage scores, independent of the validation's effect on the final score. Item-wise analysis revealed significant shortcomings in several areas.
CONCLUSION: Radiomics research quality is low but improving according to RQS. Significant variation exists across radiology subfields. Critical areas were identified for targeted improvement.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: Our study shows that the quality of radiomics research is generally low but improving over time, with item-wise analysis highlighting critical areas needing improvement. It also reveals that the quality of radiomics research differs across subfields and validation methods.
KEY POINTS: Overall quality of radiomics research remains low and highly variable, although a significant positive trend suggests an improvement in quality over time. Considerable variations exist in the quality of radiomics publications across different subfields of radiology and validation types. The item-wise analysis highlights several critical areas requiring attention, emphasizing the need for targeted improvements.
引用
- Kocak B, Keles A, Kose F, et al. Quality of radiomics research: comprehensive analysis of 1574 unique publications from 89 reviews. Eur Radiol. 2024. PMID: 39237770. doi:10.1007/s00330-024-11057-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。