面向神经放射科医生的行业付款分布与差异
研究基于2016至2021年Open Payments数据库识别3019名神经放射科医生,48%至少收到一笔行业付款,付款高度集中于收入最高的5%医生(占付款笔数42%、金额84%)。疫情期间收到付款的医生数和付款笔数均下降,但专利许可费同期增加抵消了金额下降。
要点
- 48%(1440/3019)的神经放射科医生在2016至2021年间至少收到一笔行业付款。
- 收入最高的5%神经放射科医生获得42%(9133/21,967)的付款笔数和84%($14,284,120/$17,010,546)的付款金额。
- 礼品是最常见的付款类型(60%,13,285/21,967),但仅占付款金额的4.1%($689,859/$17,010,546)。
核心结论
- 行业对神经放射科医生的付款高度集中于收入最高的5%收款者;COVID-19疫情期间付款笔数下降,但付款金额被同期增加的专利许可费所抵消;需在后续年份进一步研究疫情后行业付款趋势变化是否持续。
研究设计与样本
- 研究论文;采用基于工作相对价值单位和Neiman影像服务类型分类的既往验证方法识别神经放射科医生,从美国医疗保险和医疗补助服务中心Open Payments数据库获取2016至2021年行业付款数据,付款分为咨询费、教育、礼品、医疗用品、研究、专利许可费/所有权和演讲费7类,计算描述性统计。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 共识别3019名神经放射科医生;2016至2021年间48%(1440/3019)至少收到一笔行业付款,总付款笔数21,967笔。
- 每年收到付款的神经放射科医生中,每位医生平均收到5.49–7.42笔付款,中位数为2笔,付款分布呈强右偏。
- 礼品为最常见付款类型(60%,13,285/21,967),但仅占付款金额的4.1%($689,859/$17,010,546);演讲费贡献最大付款金额(36%,$6,127,484/$17,010,546)。
- 收入最高的5%神经放射科医生获得42%(9133/21,967)的付款笔数,占付款总金额的84%($14,284,120/$17,010,546)。
- 疫情前(2016-2019)每年平均671名神经放射科医生收到行业付款,疫情后(2020-2021)降至411名(P = .030);付款总笔数从疫情前每年4177笔降至疫情后每年2631笔(P = .011)。
局限性
- 需在后续年份进一步研究以确定疫情后行业付款趋势变化是否持续。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Physician-industry relationships can be useful for driving innovation and technologic progress, though little is known about the scale or impact of industry involvement in neuroradiology. The purpose of this study was to assess the trends and distributions of industry payments to neuroradiologists.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Neuroradiologists were identified using a previously-validated method based on Work Relative Value Units and Neiman Imaging Types of Service classification. Data on payments from industry were obtained from the Open Payments database from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, from 2016 to 2021. Payments were grouped into 7 categories, including consulting fees, education, gifts, medical supplies, research, royalties/ownership, and speaker fees. Descriptive statistics were calculated.
RESULTS: A total of 3019 neuroradiologists were identified in this study. Between 2016 and 2021, 48% (1440/3019) received at least 1 payment from industry, amounting to a total number of 21,967 payments. Each year, among those receiving payments from industry, each unique neuroradiologist received between a mean of 5.49-7.42 payments and a median of 2 payments, indicating a strong rightward skew to the distribution of payments. Gifts were the most frequent payment type made (60%, 13,285/21,967) but accounted for only 4.1% ($689,859/$17,010,546) of payment value. The greatest aggregate payment value came from speaker fees, which made up 36% ($6,127,484/$17,010,546) of the total payment value. The top 5% highest paid neuroradiologists received 42% (9133/21,967) of payments, which accounted for 84% ($14,284,120/$17,010,546) of the total dollar value. Since the start of the coronavirus 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, the number of neuroradiologists receiving industry payments decreased from a mean of 671 neuroradiologists per year prepandemic (2016-2019) to 411 in the postpandemic (2020-2021) era (P = .030). The total number of payments to neuroradiologists decreased from 4177 per year prepandemic versus 2631 per year postpandemic (P = .011).
CONCLUSIONS: Industry payments to neuroradiologists are highly concentrated among top earners, particularly among the top 5% of payment recipients. The number of payments decreased during the COVID-19 pandemic, though the dollar value of payments was offset by coincidental increases in royalty payments. Further investigation is needed in subsequent years to determine if the postpandemic changes in industry payment trends continue.
引用
- Lee C, Khunte M, Tegtmeyer K, et al. Distribution and Disparities of Industry Payments to Neuroradiologists. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2024. PMID: 39266256. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8404
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。