评估新提出的散发性克雅氏病MRI诊断标准
本研究在澳大利亚背景下检验新提出的散发性克雅氏病MRI诊断标准的诊断效能,并与传统标准及另外两套严格标准比较。65例确诊sCJD患者与63例年龄性别匹配对照的MRI由两名盲法神经放射科医生独立评估。新标准敏感度92.3%、特异度85.7%,与传统标准敏感度92.3%、特异度87.3%相近,其他标准敏感度过低。
要点
- 新MRI标准敏感度92.3%、特异度85.7%,与传统标准敏感度92.3%、特异度87.3%相近。
- 新标准要求DWI高信号累及7个脑区中至少1个,传统标准要求≥2个皮质区或尾状核+壳核。
- 传统与新标准组内相关系数均显示中等可靠性,保留额叶比较时略优。
核心结论
- 新提出的MRI标准敏感度92.3%与原始报道的90-95%相当,也等同于传统MRI诊断标准的92.3%。
- 传统标准特异度87.3%与新标准85.7%相近,新标准特异度低于既往报道。
- 传统与新标准的阴性预测值和阳性预测值也非常相似,其他评估的MRI标准敏感度过低不适用于临床。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入65例确诊散发性克雅氏病病例,与63例年龄和性别匹配的对照比较。
- 所有MRI由一名对克雅氏病判读非常有经验的盲法神经放射科医生按不同MRI标准集评估,另由一名对sCJD影像表现经验较少的盲法神经放射科医生独立评估其中71例MRI。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 传统MRI标准要求FLAIR或DWI在2个或以上皮质区域(不包括额叶)或尾状核和壳核均出现高信号改变。
- 新提出标准要求DWI高信号改变仅累及7个离散脑区(额叶、顶叶、枕叶或颞叶皮质以及尾状核、壳核或丘脑)中的1个或以上。
- 新标准敏感度92.3%,传统标准敏感度92.3%;新标准特异度85.7%,传统标准特异度87.3%。
- 新标准敏感度与原始报道的90-95%相当,特异度低于既往报道。
- 传统与新标准的阴性预测值和阳性预测值非常相似,其他MRI标准敏感度过低不适用于临床。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (sCJD) is a frequent differential diagnostic consideration in patients with rapidly progressive dementia (RPD). Fortunately, in the last 2 decades there has been substantial cumulative improvements in sCJD biomarkers, particularly those based on imaging and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) interrogation. Brain MRI is a very frequently employed investigation in patients with RPD, often utilized quite early in the evaluation and thereby offering a potentially key role in prompting initial concerns for sCJD. Extant conventional MRI criteria for sCJD diagnosis are relatively stringent, requiring fluid attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR) or diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) high signal changes in 2 or more cortical regions (excluding frontal) or in both the caudate and putamen. Challenging these conventional criteria, a recent publication described improved sensitivity and unchanged specificity if MRI criteria were arguably less rigorous, requiring DWI high signal changes in only 1 or more of 7 discrete brain regions: frontal, parietal, occipital or temporal cortices, as well as the caudate, putamen or thalamus. The aim of the current study was to test the diagnostic performance of this proposed change in MRI criteria in the Australian context and compare it with conventional criteria, as well as 2 other stringent sets of criteria, predicting that a similar improved sensitivity with unchanged specificity would be observed when the proposed criteria were utilized. Sixty-five definite sCJD cases were compared with 63 age- and sex-matched controls. Radiological review of all MRIs applying the different sets of MRI criteria was undertaken by a blinded neuroradiologist, very experienced in CJD interpretation, with independent assessment of 71 MRIs performed by a second blinded neuroradiologist less experienced in sCJD imaging findings. Our study found the sensitivity of the recently proposed MRI criteria (92.3%) to be comparable to that originally reported (90-95%) and also equivalent to the conventional MRI diagnostic criteria (92.3%), while the specificities were also quite similar between the conventional MRI criteria (87.3%) and proposed criteria (85.7%), with the latter lower than previously reported. Negative predictive values and positive predictive values were also very similar between the conventional and proposed MRI criteria. Other MRI criteria assessed were associated with unacceptably low sensitivity for clinical use. Inter-rater reliability as assessed by intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC) revealed moderate reliability for the conventional and proposed MRI criteria, modestly better in the former and when the frontal lobe was retained versus excluded in comparisons.
引用
- Barber D, Trost N, Stehmann C, et al. Assessing the newly proposed MRI criteria for diagnosing sporadic Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease. Neuroradiology. 2024. PMID: 39136713. doi:10.1007/s00234-024-03440-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。