系统综述:肌肉骨骼锥形束CT与其他诊断影像模式有效辐射剂量的比较
该系统综述纳入21项研究,比较肌肉骨骼锥形束CT(CBCT)与多层螺旋CT(MSCT)、传统X线摄影(DR)的辐射剂量,其中19项研究结论为CBCT较MSCT辐射剂量降低,降低倍数范围为1.71至50,平均为12;CBCT与DR比较的研究显示DR平均剂量降低4.55。作者指出比较不同技术辐射剂量的研究需要方法学一致性。
要点
- 多数研究证实肌肉骨骼CBCT的有效辐射剂量低于MSCT,降低倍数范围为1.71至50,平均为12。
- CBCT与DR比较的研究显示DR平均剂量降低4.55,但CBCT有潜力提供与DR等效的辐射剂量。
- 比较不同技术辐射剂量的研究方法学尚不一致,需多学科协作以确保结果的一致性。
核心结论
- 大多数研究证实CBCT的辐射剂量低于MSCT(低于其一半),但纳入DR作为对照的研究较少,且证实CBCT平均有效剂量高于DR,CBCT有潜力提供等效辐射剂量。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,通过数据库检索和在线文献工具筛选文献,两名独立评价者进行全文筛选、第三名评价者解决分歧,使用定制工具提取数据,共纳入21项研究。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 19项研究结论为CBCT较MSCT辐射剂量降低,降低倍数范围为1.71至50,平均为12。
- CBCT与DR比较的研究显示DR平均剂量降低4.55。
局限性
- 本综述强调比较不同技术辐射剂量的研究需要方法学一致性。
- 潜在解决方案超出本综述范围,可能需要多学科方法以确保连贯的结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Cone-Beam CT (CBCT) is well established in orofacial diagnostic imaging and is currently expanding into musculoskeletal applications. This systematic review sought to update the knowledge base on radiation dose comparisons between imaging modalities in MSK imaging and consider how research studies have reported dose measures.
METHODS: This review utilised a database search and an online literature tool. Studies with potential relevance were screened then before full text review, each performed by two independent reviewers, with a third independent reviewer available for conflicts. Data was extracted using a bespoke tool created within the literature tool.
RESULTS: 21 studies were included in the review which compared CBCT with MSCT (13), conventional radiography (1), or both (7). 19 studies concluded that CBCT provided a reduced radiation dose when compared with MSCT: the factor of reduction ranging from 1.71 to 50 with an average of 12. Studies comparing CBCT to DR found DR to have an average dose reduction of 4.55.
CONCLUSIONS: The claims that CBCT produces a lower radiation dose than MSCT is borne out with most studies confirming doses less than half that of MSCT. Fewer studies include DR as a comparator but confirm that CBCT results in a higher effective dose on average, with scope for CBCT to provide an equivalent radiation dose. This review highlighted a need for consistency in methodology when conducting studies which compare radiation dose across different technologies. Potential solutions lie outside the scope of this review, likely requiring multi-discipline approach to ensure a cohesive outcome.
引用
- Mason K, Iball G, Hinchcliffe D, et al. A systematic review comparing the effective radiation dose of musculoskeletal cone beam computed tomography to other diagnostic imaging modalities. Eur J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38964225. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111558
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。