乳腺MRI肿块与非肿块强化病变:不同经验阅片者应用Kaiser评分与改良Kaiser评分+的比较
本研究分析630个乳腺MRI病变(458个肿块、172个非肿块强化),由3名不同年资放射科医生分别用BI-RADS和Kaiser评分诊断。Kaiser评分对低年资阅片者提升敏感度最明显,加入ADC的改良Kaiser评分+可提高所有阅片者特异度但敏感度略降;非肿块强化病变的评分标准仍需改进。
要点
- Kaiser评分对低年资阅片者提升敏感度最明显,尤其肿块病变。
- ADC>1.4×10-3 mm2/s时Kaiser评分减4分改为Kaiser评分+,可提高特异度。
- 非肿块强化病变的BI-RADS与Kaiser评分诊断效能均低于肿块。
核心结论
- Kaiser评分较BI-RADS的优势对低年资阅片者最明显,主要提升敏感度;Kaiser评分+可提高所有阅片者特异度但敏感度略降;非肿块强化病变的Kaiser评分与Kaiser评分+标准需进一步改进。
研究设计与样本
- 共分析630个乳腺MRI病变,其中恶性393个、良性237个,肿块458个、非肿块强化172个;3名放射科医生分别具有3年、6年和13年经验;596例有弥散加权成像并测量表观扩散系数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以BI-RADS≥4B和Kaiser评分≥5为恶性截断值,Kaiser评分对阅片者1和2在肿块及非肿块强化组的敏感度均显著更高。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对ADC>1.4×10-3 mm2/s的病变,Kaiser评分减4分作为改良Kaiser评分+,可提高所有阅片者AUC和准确率,特异度更高但敏感度略降。
局限性
- 非肿块强化病变的Kaiser评分与Kaiser评分+标准可能需更好地定义。
- 非肿块强化病变的Kaiser评分与Kaiser评分+标准需进一步改进。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare the diagnostic performance of three readers using BI-RADS and Kaiser score (KS) based on mass and non-mass enhancement (NME) lesions.
METHODS: A total of 630 lesions, 393 malignant and 237 benign, 458 mass and 172 NME, were analyzed. Three radiologists with 3 years, 6 years, and 13 years of experience made diagnoses. 596 cases had diffusion-weighted imaging, and the apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) was measured. For lesions with ADC > 1.4 × 10-3 mm2/s, the KS was reduced by 4 as the modified KS +, and the benefit was assessed.
RESULTS: When using BI-RADS, AUC was 0.878, 0.915, and 0.941 for mass, and 0.771, 0.838, 0.902 for NME for Reader-1, 2, and 3, respectively, better for mass than for NME. The diagnostic accuracy of KS was improved compared to BI-RADS for less experienced readers. For Reader-1, AUC was increased from 0.878 to 0.916 for mass (p = 0.005) and from 0.771 to 0.822 for NME (p = 0.124). Based on the cut-off value of BI-RADS ≥ 4B and KS ≥ 5 as malignant, the sensitivity of KS by Readers-1 and -2 was significantly higher for both Mass and NME. When ADC was considered to change to modified KS +, the AUC and the accuracy for all three readers were improved, showing higher specificity with slightly degraded sensitivity.
CONCLUSION: The benefit of KS compared to BI-RADS was most noticeable for the less experienced readers in improving sensitivity. Compared to KS, KS + can improve specificity for all three readers. For NME, the KS and KS + criteria need to be further improved.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: KS provides an intuitive method for diagnosing lesions on breast MRI. BI-RADS and KS face greater difficulties in evaluating NME compared to mass lesions. Adding ADC to the KS can improve specificity with slightly degraded sensitivity.
KEY POINTS: KS provides an intuitive method for interpreting breast lesions on MRI, most helpful for novice readers. KS, compared to BI-RADS, improved sensitivity in both mass and NME groups for less experienced readers. NME lesions were considered during the development of the KS flowchart, but may need to be better defined.
引用
- Zhou J, Liu H, Miao H, et al. Breast lesions on MRI in mass and non-mass enhancement: Kaiser score and modified Kaiser score + for readers of variable experience. Eur Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38990324. doi:10.1007/s00330-024-10922-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。