优化放射学教育:通过测试集进行学习间隔在提升乳腺筛查阅片者诊断能力中的作用
本研究纳入54名放射科医生和101名放射科受训者,于2019至2023年间完成基于乳腺X线摄影测试集(每套60例,含20例癌症和40例正常)的首次阅片。结果显示,放射科医生在测试集间隔较长时特异性与JAFROC FOM改善呈正相关,间隔4至10天改善最明显;受训者在间隔31至90天时病例敏感度、病变敏感度、ROC AUC和JAFROC FOM进步显著。结论认为优化测试集间隔有助于巩固记忆和诊断决策能力。
要点
- 放射科医生在测试集间隔4至10天时各项指标改善最明显。
- 受训者在测试集间隔31至90天时病例敏感度、病变敏感度、ROC AUC和JAFROC FOM进步显著。
- 间隔超过90天与放射科医生病例敏感度提升5.15%、病变敏感度提升6.55%、ROC AUC提升3.05%和JAFROC FOM提升6.3%相关。
核心结论
- 放射科医生在测试集间隔较长时表现更优,而受训者在较短间隔下表现熟练;优化阅片练习间隔可能有助于巩固记忆和诊断决策能力。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入54名放射科医生和101名放射科受训者,2019至2023年间分别完成207次和458次首次阅片,使用9套乳腺X线摄影测试集,每套60例(20例癌症、40例正常),回顾性来源于BreastScreen Australia,参考标准为真实数据,采用BIRADS词典评估。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 放射科医生间隔与特异性及JAFROC FOM改善呈显著正相关(P < 0.05);间隔超过90天与病例敏感度提升5.15%、病变敏感度提升6.55%、ROC AUC提升3.05%、JAFROC FOM提升6.3%相关;受训者间隔31至90天时病例敏感度提升6.15%、病变敏感度提升11.6%、ROC AUC提升3.5%、JAFROC FOM提升4.35%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为通过优化阅片和练习放射学概念的间隔,乳腺X线摄影阅片者可增强记忆保持和诊断决策能力。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Integrating learning spacing in medicine has shown promise in enhancing knowledge retention and diagnostic proficiency. While studies demonstrate the effectiveness of spaced learning in various fields, limited research exists on its application in radiological training. This study aims to investigate the impact of intervals in spaced training on radiologists' and trainees' diagnostic performance via mammogram test sets.
METHODS: 54 radiologists and 101 radiology trainees completed 207 and 458 first-time readings of 9 mammogram test sets between 2019 and 2023. Each test set comprised of 60 mammograms (20 cancer and 40 normal), sourced retrospectively from BreastScreen Australia. Each radiologist evaluated mammograms using the BIRADS lexicon. Readers' performance was compared with truth data and evaluated in terms of specificity, case sensitivity, lesion sensitivity, ROC AUC and JAFROC FOM. The progress of readers' performances in following test sets after the first one was analyzed using Wilcoxon Signed Rank test. The association of participants' performances and the intervals among test sets' completions was investigated using Pearson's test.
RESULTS: Significant positive correlations were found between intervals and radiologists' improvement in specificity and JAFROC FOM (P < 0.05). The separation of 4 to 10 days showed the most improvement among radiologists across all metrics, while intervals exceeding 90 days related to highest increase in case sensitivity (5.15%), lesion sensitivity (6.55%), ROC AUC (3.05%) and JAFROC FOM (6.3%). Trainees completing test sets in one day showed positive correlations with their ROC AUC (R=0.45; P = 0.008) and JAFROC FOM (R=0.43; P = 0.02), while those taking a longer time to complete showed negative impacts on case sensitivity (P = 0.009) and ROC AUC (P = 0.02). Remarkable progress in trainees was found in case sensitivity (6.15%), lesion sensitivity (11.6%), ROC AUC (3.5%) and JAFROC FOM (4.35%) with test set intervals of 31-90 days.
CONCLUSIONS: Radiologists demonstrated superior performance when the training test sets were spaced over longer intervals, whereas trainees exhibited proficiency with shorter time separations. By optimizing the spacing of reviewing and practicing radiological concepts, mammogram readers can bolster memory retention and diagnostic decision-making skills.
引用
- Trieu PDY, Abu Awwad D, Barron ML, et al. Optimizing Radiological Education: The Role of Learning Spacing via Test sets in Enhancing Diagnostic Proficiency in Breast Screening Readers. Acad Radiol. 2024. PMID: 39048496. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2024.06.039
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。