影响肱骨小头剥脱性骨软骨炎病变治疗决策的MRI特征:一项基于德尔菲法的专家共识
本研究采用经典三轮德尔菲法,邀请33名肱骨小头剥脱性骨软骨炎(OCD)专家对33项MRI特征在临床决策中的重要性进行共识调查。17名专家完成全部三轮,其中17项MRI特征达成重要性共识,并分别就病变稳定性及非手术治疗愈合潜能的MRI特征清单达成共识(共识率88%–100%)。该共识将作为评估者间信度研究的基础,以开发基于临床经验的标准化MRI评估工具。
要点
- 33项MRI特征中17项被专家共识认为对肱骨小头OCD临床决策重要。
- 专家就提示稳定病变(100%共识)和不稳定病变(100%共识)的MRI特征清单达成共识。
- 专家就提示非手术治疗愈合潜能高(94%共识)和低(88%共识)的MRI特征清单达成共识。
核心结论
- 三轮德尔菲法就肱骨小头OCD临床决策相关的MRI特征达成共识,将用于评估者间信度评估并作为开发标准化MRI评估工具的基础。
研究设计与样本
- 共识声明,采用经典三轮德尔菲问卷调查;邀请33名肱骨小头OCD专家,20名同意参与,17名(52%)完成全部三轮;对33项MRI特征的重要性进行共识评估,共识阈值预先设定为≥66%。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 33项MRI特征中17项达成重要共识,用于临床决策。
- 对决策重要的MRI特征简明清单共识率94%。
- 提示稳定病变的MRI特征清单共识率100%。
- 提示非手术治疗有愈合潜能的MRI特征清单共识率94%。
- 提示不稳定病变的MRI特征清单共识率100%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 专家共识认为17项MRI特征对肱骨小头OCD临床决策重要。
- 专家共识认为部分MRI特征提示病变稳定,部分提示不稳定。
- 专家共识认为部分MRI特征提示非手术治疗愈合潜能高,部分提示低。
局限性
- 33名受邀专家中20名同意参与,17名(52%)完成全部三轮。
- 本研究结果将作为评估者间信度评估的基础,尚未进行信度验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Most healthcare providers utilize magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to assist in diagnosing and treating osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) of the capitellum. However, consensus on imaging features that portend clinically relevant information in the care of these lesions has not been determined.
PURPOSE: To conduct a survey on the MRI features of a capitellar OCD that are salient for clinical decision-making using a classic Delphi protocol.
STUDY DESIGN: A consensus statement.
METHODS: Invitations to participate were sent to 33 healthcare providers identified as capitellar OCD experts. A classic 3-round survey method was used to gather agreement and consensus on the level of importance for clinical decision-making on 33 MRI features. A concise list of features that guide decision-making on the stability of an OCD lesion and the ability of an OCD lesion to heal with nonoperative care was also identified. Agreement and consensus were determined a priori as ≥66%.
RESULTS: Of the 33 identified experts, 20 agreed to participate, and 17 (52%) completed all 3 rounds. Of the 33 MRI features evaluated, 17 reached agreement as important for clinical decision-making by the experts. Consensus was reached for a concise list of MRI features that were significant to decision-making (94%), suggestive of a stable lesion (100%), had the potential to heal with nonoperative treatment (94%), were suggestive of an unstable lesion (100%), and had low potential to heal with nonoperative treatment (88%).
CONCLUSION: This 3-round Delphi process produced consensus on clinically relevant MRI features that contribute to clinical decision-making for capitellar OCD. The results of this study will be used as the basis for an interrater reliability assessment of the identified salient features, creating the foundation for developing a reliable MRI assessment tool rooted in clinical experiences. The development of a standardized assessment of capitellar OCD is intended to improve clinical practice and patient outcomes.
引用
- Kostyun RO, Nguyen JC, Chhabra B, et al. MRI Features That Contribute to Decision-Making for Treatment of Capitellar OCD Lesions: An Expert Consensus Using the Delphi Method. Orthop J Sports Med. 2024. PMID: 38845610. doi:10.1177/23259671241252813
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。