上肢外科医生对影像检查的建议与影像适用性指南不一致
研究汇总15部上肢先进影像检查指南,并邀请108名上肢外科医生对11个常见上肢疾病场景判断是否需要MRI或CT,比较两者一致性。结果显示指南多认为MRI或CT有用,而多数外科医生认为无用,两者无相关性(ρ=0.28;p=0.40),外科医生间一致性仅为轻微(kappa=0.17;95%CI 0.023-0.32)。作者认为现有指南似乎过于宽松,临床实用性有限。
要点
- 上肢先进影像适用性指南多认为MRI或CT有用,但多数外科医生认为无用。
- 外科医生建议与指南推荐无相关性(ρ=0.28;p=0.40)。
- 外科医生之间对影像建议的一致性仅为轻微(kappa=0.17;95%CI 0.023-0.32)。
核心结论
- 现有上肢影像适用性指南似乎过于宽松,对上肢外科医生临床实用性似乎有限,且外科医生间对先进影像的建议存在明显差异(不可靠)。
研究设计与样本
- 研究汇总15部上肢先进影像检查指南,并邀请科学变异组(SOVG)成员(n=108)完成11个常见上肢疾病场景的问卷,询问是否推荐MRI或CT,采用Fisher精确检验比较指南推荐与外科医生建议,采用Fleiss kappa评估观察者间一致性,证据等级为II级(诊断性)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 指南推荐与外科医生建议无相关性(ρ=0.28;p=0.40)。
- 外科医生间对影像建议的一致性为轻微(kappa=0.17;95%CI 0.023-0.32)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Utilization of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) increases annually, raising concerns about overuse. Imaging appropriateness guidelines have the potential to standardize decisions regarding imaging based on best evidence, which might reduce unhelpful or potentially misleading imaging. We studied expert use of advanced imaging for musculoskeletal illness compared to published appropriateness recommendations.
METHODS: First, 15 imaging guidelines with recommendations for advanced imaging of the upper extremity were collated. Next, members of the Science of Variation Group (SOVG) were invited to participate in a survey of 11 patient scenarios of common upper extremity illnesses and asked whether they would recommend MRI or CT. Guideline recommendations for imaging were compared with surgeon recommendations using Fisher's exact tests. We used Fleiss' kappa to measure the interobserver agreement among surgeons.
RESULTS: For the 11 scenarios, most imaging appropriateness guidelines suggested that MRI or CT is useful, while most surgeons (n = 108) felt it was not. There was no correlation between surgeons and guidelines recommendations for imaging (ρ = 0.28; p = 0.40). There was slight agreement among surgeons regarding imaging recommendations (kappa: 0.17; 95% confidence interval: 0.023-0.32).
CONCLUSION: The available imaging appropriateness guidelines appear to be too permissive and therefore seem to have limited clinical utility for upper extremity surgeons. The notable surgeon-to-surgeon variation (unreliability) in recommendations for advanced imaging in this and other studies suggests a role for strategies to ensure that patient decisions about imaging are consistent with their values (what matters most to them) and not unduly influenced by patient misconceptions about imaging or by surgeon beliefs and habits.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: II, diagnostic.
引用
- Ramachandran SS, Ring D, Crijns TJ, et al. Upper Extremity Surgeon Recommendations for Imaging Do Not Correspond with Imaging Appropriateness Guidelines. J Hand Microsurg. 2024. PMID: 38854369. doi:10.1055/s-0042-1758670
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。