Tanner-Whitehouse手部X线骨龄评估的观察者间变异性和可重复性
24名放射科医生经Tanner-Whitehouse分类培训后,用20张1至18岁儿童手部X线片评估骨发育,4名一致性差者被排除。剩余20人重复阅片,以两名资深专家平均评估为参考标准。桡尺短指系统Kendall's W=0.833、腕骨系统Kendall's W=0.944,均一致性极好;头状骨D级变异最大,7块腕骨G级一致性率均低于0.6。
要点
- 桡尺短指系统Kendall's W=0.833,腕骨系统Kendall's W=0.944,均一致性极好。
- 头状骨平均一致性率和评分最低,其D分级总体一致性率最低。
- 7块腕骨G分级一致性率均低于0.6,T-W3法判读常不一致。
核心结论
- 头状骨D级变异最大,使用Tanner-Whitehouse第3版(T-W3)判定骨龄常不一致;作者认为更全面的描述(聚焦不准确骨骼或分级)及对T-W3方法的修改将显著推进骨龄评估。
研究设计与样本
- 24名放射科医生接受T-W骨发育分类培训,用20张1至18岁儿童手部X线片评估骨发育一致性;4名一致性差者被排除,剩余20人重复阅片,以两名资深专家平均评估为参考标准;计算一致性率、评分和Kendall's W评估准确性和一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 桡尺短指(RUS)系统Kendall's W=0.833,腕骨(C)系统Kendall's W=0.944,均一致性极好;RUS系统评分优于C系统;2个月骨龄评估练习后第二次评分比第一次更一致和准确;头状骨平均一致性率和评分最低,其D分类总体一致性率最低;7块腕骨G分类一致性率均低于0.6。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为更全面的描述(聚焦不准确骨骼或分级)及对T-W3方法的修改将显著推进骨龄评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To determine which bones and which grades had the highest inter-rater variability when employing the Tanner-Whitehouse (T-W) method.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twenty-four radiologists were recruited and trained in the T-W classification of skeletal development. The consistency and skill of the radiologists in determining bone development status were assessed using 20 pediatric hand radiographs of children aged 1 to 18 years old. Four radiologists had a poor concordance rate and were excluded. The remaining 20 radiologists undertook a repeat reading of the radiographs, and their results were analyzed by comparing them with the mean assessment of two senior experts as the reference standard. Concordance rate, scoring, and Kendall's W were calculated to evaluate accuracy and consistency.
RESULTS: Both the radius, ulna, and short finger (RUS) system (Kendall's W = 0.833) and the carpal (C) system (Kendall's W = 0.944) had excellent consistency, with the RUS system outperforming the C system in terms of scores. The repeatability analysis showed that the second rating test, performed after 2 months of further bone age assessment (BAA) practice, was more consistent and accurate than the first. The capitate had the lowest average concordance rate and scoring, as well as the lowest overall concordance rate for its D classification. Moreover, the G classifications of the seven carpal bones all had a concordance rate less than 0.6. The bones with lower Kendall's W were likewise those with lower scores and concordance rates.
CONCLUSION: The D grade of the capitate showed the highest variation, and the use of the Tanner-Whitehouse 3rd edition (T-W3) to determine bone age (BA) was frequently inconsistent. A more comprehensive description with a focus on inaccuracy bones or ratings and a modification to the T-W3 approach would significantly advance BAA.
引用
- Geng J, Zhang W, Ge Y, et al. Inter-rater variability and repeatability in the assessment of the Tanner-Whitehouse classification of hand radiographs for the estimation of bone age. Skeletal Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38695874. doi:10.1007/s00256-024-04664-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。