三次扫描优于两次随访:一种自动发现肿瘤患者横断面随访中遗漏和错误识别病变的方法
本研究评估了一种基于可疑模式(孤立病变和非连续病变变化)的解读修订工作流,用于在三次及以上连续扫描中识别肿瘤患者纵向研究里遗漏和错误识别的病变。对67例患者研究(2295个转移性病变,涉及肺、肝、脑)的人工修订发现120个遗漏病变和20个错误识别病变;自动修订在51/67(76%)的研究中减少了55个计算遗漏病变和164个计算错误识别病变。结论认为自动分析三次及以上连续容积扫描有助于发现遗漏和错误识别病变,可能改善肿瘤病变时间变化的评估。
要点
- 对三次及以上连续扫描的病变标注进行修订,可发现遗漏和错误识别病变。
- 人工修订在31/67(46%)的研究中发现120个遗漏病变和20个错误识别病变。
- 自动修订在51/67(76%)的研究中减少55个计算遗漏病变和164个计算错误识别病变。
核心结论
- 自动分析三次及以上连续容积扫描有助于发现遗漏和错误识别的病变,并可能改善肿瘤病变时间变化的评估。
研究设计与样本
- 评估解读修订工作流的研究,纳入67例患者研究、2295个转移性病变,包括肺(19例患者,83次CT扫描,1178个病变)、肝(18例患者,77次CECT扫描,800个病变)和脑(30例患者,102次T1W-Gad MRI扫描,317个病变);人工修订由一名资深放射科医生和一名资深神经外科医生完成,计算机修订使用先前训练的nnU-Net计算病变标注后由基于AI的方法自动修订。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 人工修订在31/67(46%)的研究中发现120个遗漏病变和20个错误识别病变。
- 自动修订在51/67(76%)的研究中减少55个计算遗漏病变和164个计算错误识别病变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Missed and misidentified neoplastic lesions in longitudinal studies of oncology patients are pervasive and may affect the evaluation of the disease status. Two newly identified patterns of lesion changes, lone lesions and non-consecutive lesion changes, may help radiologists to detect these lesions. This study evaluated a new interpretation revision workflow of lesion annotations in three or more consecutive scans based on these suspicious patterns.
METHODS: The interpretation revision workflow was evaluated on manual and computed lesion annotations in longitudinal oncology patient studies. For the manual revision, a senior radiologist and a senior neurosurgeon (the readers) manually annotated the lesions in each scan and later revised their annotations to identify missed and misidentified lesions with the workflow using the automatically detected patterns. For the computerized revision, lesion annotations were first computed with a previously trained nnU-Net and were then automatically revised with an AI-based method that automates the workflow readers' decisions. The evaluation included 67 patient studies with 2295 metastatic lesions in lung (19 patients, 83 CT scans, 1178 lesions), liver (18 patients, 77 CECT scans, 800 lesions) and brain (30 patients, 102 T1W-Gad MRI scans, 317 lesions).
RESULTS: Revision of the manual lesion annotations revealed 120 missed lesions and 20 misidentified lesions in 31 out of 67 (46%) studies. The automatic revision reduced the number of computed missed lesions by 55 and computed misidentified lesions by 164 in 51 out of 67 (76%) studies.
CONCLUSION: Automatic analysis of three or more consecutive volumetric scans helps find missed and misidentified lesions and may improve the evaluation of temporal changes of oncological lesions.
引用
- Joskowicz L, Di Veroli B, Lederman R, et al. Three scans are better than two for follow-up: An automatic method for finding missed and misidentified lesions in cross-sectional follow-up of oncology patients. Eur J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38810439. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111530
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。