质子密度磁共振血管成像诊断未破裂颅内动脉瘤:与高分辨率时间飞跃法磁共振血管成像的比较
回顾性纳入109例患者141个经CTA或MRA难以定性的病灶,以DSA为金标准比较质子密度MRA与高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA的诊断效能。质子密度MRA(0.253 mm³体素)的敏感度87.2%-91.0%、特异度93.7%-96.8%、准确率90.8%-92.9%,均显著高于高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA,读者间一致性近乎完美。
要点
- 对CTA或MRA定性困难的颅内病灶,质子密度MRA诊断动脉瘤的准确率90.8%-92.9%,显著高于高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA的63.8%-69.5%。
- 质子密度MRA读者间kappa值0.820-0.938,高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA仅0.447-0.510。
- 质子密度MRA(0.253 mm³体素)诊断准确率与0.23 mm³体素重建相当。
核心结论
- 在常规CTA或MRA初查定性困难的患者中,质子密度MRA诊断颅内动脉瘤的准确率优于高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA,且读者间一致性近乎完美。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析,纳入2020年8月至2022年7月同时行质子密度MRA和高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA的患者109例(平均年龄57.4±11.0岁,男女比11:98),共141个经既往常规CTA或MRA判定为定性困难的病灶;由3名经验丰富的神经放射科医生独立阅片,以神经介入医生依据数字减影血管造影确立的金标准作参照;质子密度MRA和高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA重建体素分别为0.253 mm³和0.23 mm³。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以数字减影血管造影为金标准,141个病灶中78个(55.3%,来自69例患者)确诊为动脉瘤;质子密度MRA(0.253 mm³体素)按病灶分析敏感度87.2%-91.0%、特异度93.7%-96.8%、准确率90.8%-92.9%,高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA敏感度66.7%-70.5%、特异度58.7%-68.3%、准确率63.8%-69.5%(P≤0.003);按患者分析质子密度MRA(0.253 mm³体素)的特异度和准确率均显著优于高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA(P≤0.013);质子密度MRA(0.23 mm³体素)诊断准确率超过高分辨率时间飞跃法MRA,与质子密度MRA(0.253 mm³体素)相当。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对常规CTA或MRA初查定性困难的颅内病灶,可加行质子密度MRA(0.253 mm³或0.23 mm³体素重建)以辅助鉴别动脉瘤与正常变异,其读者间一致性较高(kappa 0.820-0.938)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Differentiating intracranial aneurysms from normal variants using CT angiography (CTA) or MR angiography (MRA) poses significant challenges. This study aimed to evaluate the efficacy of proton-density MRA (PD-MRA) compared to high-resolution time-of-flight MRA (HR-MRA) in diagnosing aneurysms among patients with indeterminate findings on conventional CTA or MRA.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective analysis, we included patients who underwent both PD-MRA and HR-MRA from August 2020 to July 2022 to assess lesions deemed indeterminate on prior conventional CTA or MRA examinations. Three experienced neuroradiologists independently reviewed the lesions using HR-MRA and PD-MRA with reconstructed voxel sizes of 0.253 mm3 or 0.23 mm3, respectively. A neurointerventionist established the gold standard with digital subtraction angiography. We compared the performance of HR-MRA, PD-MRA (0.253-mm3 voxel), and PD-MRA (0.23-mm3 voxel) in diagnosing aneurysms, both per lesion and per patient. The Fleiss kappa statistic was used to calculate inter-reader agreement.
RESULTS: The study involved 109 patients (average age 57.4 ± 11.0 years; male:female ratio, 11:98) with 141 indeterminate lesions. Of these, 78 lesions (55.3%) in 69 patients were confirmed as aneurysms by the reference standard. PD-MRA (0.253-mm3 voxel) exhibited significantly higher per-lesion diagnostic performance compared to HR-MRA across all three readers: sensitivity ranged from 87.2%-91.0% versus 66.7%-70.5%; specificity from 93.7%-96.8% versus 58.7%-68.3%; and accuracy from 90.8%-92.9% versus 63.8%-69.5% (P ≤ 0.003). Furthermore, PD-MRA (0.253-mm3 voxel) demonstrated significantly superior per-patient specificity and accuracy compared to HR-MRA across all evaluators (P ≤ 0.013). The diagnostic accuracy of PD-MRA (0.23-mm3 voxel) surpassed that of HR-MRA and was comparable to PD-MRA (0.253-mm3 voxel). The kappa values for inter-reader agreements were significantly higher in PD-MRA (0.820-0.938) than in HR-MRA (0.447-0.510).
CONCLUSION: PD-MRA outperformed HR-MRA in diagnostic accuracy and demonstrated almost perfect inter-reader consistency in identifying intracranial aneurysms among patients with lesions initially indeterminate on CTA or MRA.
引用
- Suh PS, Jung SC, Moon HH, et al. Diagnosis of Unruptured Intracranial Aneurysms Using Proton-Density Magnetic Resonance Angiography: A Comparison With High-Resolution Time-of-Flight Magnetic Resonance Angiography. Korean J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38807339. doi:10.3348/kjr.2023.1241
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。