国际皮肤影像协作组指定诊断(ISIC-DX):用于病变诊断标注的共识术语
国际皮肤影像协作组采用改良德尔菲共识法,对从教科书、出版物和现有诊断编码中提取的皮肤肿瘤诊断术语及其层级映射进行专家共识。18名专家完成全部轮次,379个术语中356个(94%)在第一轮达成共识,最终共识为362个术语映射至3个超级类别和41个细胞/组织分化类别。原文指出需进一步研究评估该词表的实用性和完整性。
要点
- 最终共识包含362个术语,映射至3个超级类别和41个细胞/组织分化类别。
- 初始379个术语中356个(94%)在第一轮达成共识。
- 未达初始共识的术语包括良性类别11/226(5%)、恶性类别6/140(4%)和不确定类别6/13(46%)。
核心结论
- 已创建、达成共识并公开皮肤肿瘤分类词表及其层级映射;原文指出需进一步研究评估该词表的实用性和完整性。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲共识法;从国际皮肤影像协作组(ISIC)邀请专家,18名专家完成全部轮次;诊断术语提取自教科书、出版物和现有诊断编码,并经层级映射和附加修饰词及同义词;共识阈值初始轮次为>75%,最终轮次为>50%。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 共识阈值:初始轮次>75%,最终轮次>50%。
- 379个术语中356个(94%)在第一轮达成共识。
- 良性类别226个术语中11个(5%)未达初始共识;恶性类别140个术语中6个(4%)未达初始共识;不确定类别13个术语中6个(46%)未达初始共识。
- 最终共识包含362个术语,映射至3个超级类别和41个细胞/组织分化类别。
局限性
- 原文指出需进一步研究评估该词表的实用性和完整性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: A common terminology for diagnosis is critically important for clinical communication, education, research and artificial intelligence. Prevailing lexicons are limited in fully representing skin neoplasms.
OBJECTIVES: To achieve expert consensus on diagnostic terms for skin neoplasms and their hierarchical mapping.
METHODS: Diagnostic terms were extracted from textbooks, publications and extant diagnostic codes. Terms were hierarchically mapped to super-categories (e.g. 'benign') and cellular/tissue-differentiation categories (e.g. 'melanocytic'), and appended with pertinent-modifiers and synonyms. These terms were evaluated using a modified-Delphi consensus approach. Experts from the International-Skin-Imaging-Collaboration (ISIC) were surveyed on agreement with terms and their hierarchical mapping; they could suggest modifying, deleting or adding terms. Consensus threshold was >75% for the initial rounds and >50% for the final round.
RESULTS: Eighteen experts completed all Delphi rounds. Of 379 terms, 356 (94%) reached consensus in round one. Eleven of 226 (5%) benign-category terms, 6/140 (4%) malignant-category terms and 6/13 (46%) indeterminate-category terms did not reach initial agreement. Following three rounds, final consensus consisted of 362 terms mapped to 3 super-categories and 41 cellular/tissue-differentiation categories.
CONCLUSIONS: We have created, agreed upon, and made public a taxonomy for skin neoplasms and their hierarchical mapping. Further study will be needed to evaluate the utility and completeness of the lexicon.
引用
- Scope A, Liopyris K, Weber J, et al. International Skin Imaging Collaboration-Designated Diagnoses (ISIC-DX): Consensus terminology for lesion diagnostic labeling. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2024. PMID: 38733254. doi:10.1111/jdv.20055
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。