SUSAN去噪与ComBat协调对恶性脑肿瘤机器学习模型性能的影响
本研究纳入493例胶质母细胞瘤、颅内转移性疾病和原发性中枢神经系统淋巴瘤病例,评估SUSAN去噪与ComBat协调对多分类机器学习模型性能的影响。结果显示外部测试集上多数最佳模型使用BIP+SUSAN去噪衍生特征,两种预处理步骤带来轻微但总体一致的性能提升,作者认为可能有助于多机构场景下的模型泛化性。
要点
- 外部测试集上多数顶尖模型使用BIP联合SUSAN去噪衍生特征。
- SUSAN去噪与ComBat协调使外部测试集模型性能轻微但总体一致提升。
- 仅基于T1增强图像的模型与多参数MRI模型性能相当。
核心结论
- SUSAN去噪与ComBat协调等图像预处理步骤在多机构场景下可能更有助于提升模型泛化性。
- 外部测试集上多数顶尖模型使用BIP+SUSAN去噪衍生特征,两种预处理带来轻微但总体一致的性能提升。
- 仅基于T1增强图像的模型与基于多参数MRI的模型性能相当。
研究设计与样本
- 共493例(内部数据集410例、外部数据集83例),包括胶质母细胞瘤、颅内转移性疾病和原发性中枢神经系统淋巴瘤。
- 所有病例经半自动3D分割后行基线图像处理(BIP),包括重采样、重对齐、共配准、颅骨剥离和图像归一化。
- BIP后生成含SUSAN去噪与不含SUSAN去噪两套数据,提取影像组学特征并做批次校正,形成4套数据:BIP、BIP+SUSAN去噪、BIP+ComBat、BIP+SUSAN去噪+ComBat协调。
- 采用6种特征选择技术与6种机器学习模型组合,在4种掩模-序列组合及1至3个(多参数)MRI序列衍生特征上评估模型性能。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为SUSAN去噪与ComBat协调等图像预处理步骤在多机构场景下可能更有助于提升模型泛化性。
- 本研究显示仅基于T1增强图像的模型与基于多参数MRI的模型性能相当。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Feature variability in radiomics studies due to technical and magnet strength parameters is well-known and may be addressed through various preprocessing methods. However, very few studies have evaluated the downstream impact of variable preprocessing on model classification performance in a multiclass setting. We sought to evaluate the impact of Smallest Univalue Segment Assimilating Nucleus (SUSAN) denoising and Combining Batches harmonization on model classification performance.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A total of 493 cases (410 internal and 83 external data sets) of glioblastoma, intracranial metastatic disease, and primary CNS lymphoma underwent semiautomated 3D-segmentation post-baseline image processing (BIP) consisting of resampling, realignment, coregistration, skull-stripping, and image normalization. Post-BIP, 2 sets were generated, one with and another without SUSAN denoising. Radiomics features were extracted from both data sets and batch-corrected to produce 4 data sets: (a) BIP, (b) BIP with SUSAN denoising, (c) BIP with Combining Batches, and (d) BIP with both SUSAN denoising and Combining Batches harmonization. Performance was then summarized for models using a combination of 6 feature-selection techniques and 6 machine learning models across 4 mask-sequence combinations with features derived from 1 to 3 (multiparametric) MRI sequences.
RESULTS: Most top-performing models on the external test set used BIP+SUSAN denoising-derived features. Overall, the use of SUSAN denoising and Combining Batches harmonization led to a slight but generally consistent improvement in model performance on the external test set.
CONCLUSIONS: The use of image-preprocessing steps such as SUSAN denoising and Combining Batches harmonization may be more useful in a multi-institutional setting to improve model generalizability. Models derived from only T1 contrast-enhanced images showed comparable performance to models derived from multiparametric MRI.
引用
- Bathla G, Soni N, Mark IT, et al. Impact of SUSAN Denoising and ComBat Harmonization on Machine Learning Model Performance for Malignant Brain Neoplasms. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2024. PMID: 38604733. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8280
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。