项目与地理偏好信号传递了什么信号?对诊断放射学与整合介入放射学住院医师申请者的调查
该调查向两所不同地理位置学术医学中心的282名诊断放射学与整合介入放射学申请者发放匿名问卷,了解其对ERAS补充申请中项目偏好信号(最多6个)和地理信号(最多3个)的看法。105人回复(37.2%),多数对项目信号持正面态度,地理因素是选择信号项目的最重要决定因素;收到4-6个信号项目面试邀请者比收到1-3个者更倾向于正面看待项目信号(p=0.01)。
要点
- 多数申请者对项目偏好信号持正面态度:以1分为最负面、5分为最正面,36%(37/103)选择4分。
- 收到4-6个信号项目面试邀请的申请者比收到1-3个者更倾向于正面看待项目信号(p=0.01)。
- 地理因素是申请者选择向哪些项目发送信号时最重要的决定因素(57%,58/101)。
核心结论
- 项目与地理信号是ERAS住院医师申请流程中相对较新的功能,其对匹配结果的影响仍有待明确。
- 研究结果显示多数申请者对信号持正面看法,并认为信号增加了其获得理想匹配的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 对两所位于不同地理位置的学术医学中心共282名诊断放射学与整合介入放射学申请者发放匿名问卷调查。
- 调查内容为申请者参与项目偏好信号(最多6个)和地理信号(最多3个)的情况及其对申请流程影响的看法。
- 共105名申请者回复,回复率37.2%(105/282)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 多数申请者从信号项目获得4个面试邀请(26%,27/102)。
- 对项目信号感受以1分为最负面、5分为最正面,选择4分者比例最高(36%,37/103)。
- 收到4-6个信号项目面试邀请者比收到1-3个者更可能对项目信号持正面态度(p=0.01)。
- 地理因素是申请者决定向哪些项目发送信号时最重要的因素(57%,58/101)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文指出项目与地理信号是ERAS住院医师申请流程中相对较新的功能,其对匹配结果的影响仍有待明确。
- 原文指出研究结果为申请者主观感受,且作者称其与当前文献一致,但未报告其他局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: As part of the 2022-2023 Diagnostic/Interventional Radiology residency application process, applicants could participate in the ERAS supplemental application, including sending up to six preference signals and three geographic signals. Our goal was to survey Diagnostic Radiology and Integrated Interventional Radiology applicants at two large academic institutions in different geographic locations regarding their perceived impact of program and geographic preference signaling on the application process.
METHODS: An anonymous survey was sent to 282 applicants between two academic medical centers asking about their participation in program and geographic preference signaling as well as their perception on its impact on the application process.
RESULTS: 105 applicants responded to the survey (37.2% [105/282]). Most applicants (26% [27/102]) received four interviews from signaled programs. When prompted to best describe their sentiments with respect to program signaling (one being most negative and five being most positive), the plurality of applicants reported a positive sentiment of four (36% [37/103]). Applicants that received four to six interviews from signaled programs were significantly more likely to feel positively towards program signaling than those that received one to three interviews (p = 0.01). Geography was the most important deciding factor on which programs to signal for applicants (57% [58/101]).
DISCUSSION: Our survey results demonstrate that most applicants felt positively towards program signaling and it increased their odds of receiving interviews from preferred programs, which is consistent with the current literature.
CONCLUSION: Program and geographic signaling are relatively new features of the ERAS residency application process and therefore, their effects on the match outcome are still in question. However, our study results indicate that they are perceived positively by most applicants and that they boost their chances in finding their ideal match.
引用
- Park A, Smith EB, Ho C, et al. What Do Program and Geographic Preference Signals Signal? A Survey of Diagnostic Radiology and Integrated Interventional Radiology Residency Applicants. Acad Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38493029. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2024.01.044
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。