胸部超声与胸部X线检测肋骨骨折的性能比较:以计算机断层扫描为参考标准
前瞻性纳入59例钝性胸部创伤后临床怀疑肋骨骨折且具备后前位/前后位X线和胸部CT的患者,计划由单一操作者行胸部超声,CT和X线回顾性评估。CT、超声和X线分别诊断136、122、42处肋骨骨折,涉及56、54、27例患者。超声检测肋骨骨折的敏感度为100%、特异度为89.7%,X线分别为40%、30.9%;超声检测单处肋骨骨折的准确率为94.9%,X线为35.4%(P < .001)。结论认为,以CT为参考标准,超声在检测肋骨骨折方面似乎优于X线。
要点
- 超声检测肋骨骨折敏感度100%、特异度89.7%,X线分别为40%、30.9%。
- 超声检测单处肋骨骨折准确率94.9%,X线35.4%(P < .001)。
- 上肋骨折在超声上最常被漏诊。
核心结论
- 以CT为参考标准,超声在检测肋骨骨折方面似乎优于X线。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入2.5年期间连续59例临床怀疑肋骨骨折的钝性胸部创伤患者,计划由单一操作者行胸部超声;CT和X线回顾性评估;比较采用Mann-Whitney U检验和Fisher精确检验。
关键影像表现/征象
- CT诊断为136处肋骨骨折(56例患者),超声诊断122处(54例患者),X线诊断42处(27例患者)。
- 大多数骨折累及第4至第9肋。
- 上肋骨折在超声上最常被漏诊。
- 胸廓/脊柱骨折和血胸是最常见的合并伤。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 超声检测肋骨骨折的敏感度为100%、特异度为89.7%。
- X线检测肋骨骨折的敏感度为40%、特异度为30.9%。
- 超声检测单处肋骨骨折的准确率为94.9%,X线为35.4%(P < .001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 所有影像检查均评估皮质肋骨骨折并记录位置,肋软骨部分未评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Although there is growing evidence that ultrasonography is superior to X-ray for rib fractures' detection, X-ray is still indicated as the most appropriate method. This has partially been attributed to a lack of studies using an appropriate reference modality. We aimed to compare the diagnostic accuracy of ultrasonography and X-ray in the detection of rib fractures, considering CT as the reference standard.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Within a 2.5-year period, all consecutive patients with clinically suspected rib fracture(s) following blunt chest trauma and available posteroanterior/anteroposterior X-ray and thoracic CT were prospectively studied and planned to undergo thoracic ultrasonography, by a single operator. All imaging examinations were evaluated for cortical rib fracture(s), and their location was recorded. The cartilaginous rib portions were not assessed. CTs and X-rays were evaluated retrospectively. Concomitant thoracic/extra-thoracic injuries were assessed on CT. Comparisons were performed with the Mann-Whitney U test and Fisher's exact test.
RESULTS: Fifty-nine patients (32 males, 27 females; mean age, 53.1 ± 16.6 years) were included. CT, ultrasonography, and X-ray (40 posteroanterior/19 anteroposterior views) diagnosed 136/122/42 rib fractures in 56/54/27 patients, respectively. Ultrasonography and X-ray had sensitivity of 100%/40% and specificity of 89.7%/30.9% for rib fractures' detection. Ultrasound accuracy was 94.9% compared to 35.4% for X-rays (P < .001) in detecting individual rib fractures. Most fractures involved the 4th-9th ribs. Upper rib fractures were most commonly overlooked on ultrasonography. Thoracic cage/spine fractures and haemothorax represented the most common concomitant injuries.
CONCLUSION: Ultrasonography appeared to be superior to X-ray for the detection of rib fractures with regard to a reference CT.
引用
- Vassalou EE, Perysinakis I, Klontzas ME, et al. Performance of thoracic ultrasonography compared with chest radiography for the detection of rib fractures using computed tomography as a reference standard. Skeletal Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38499892. doi:10.1007/s00256-024-04658-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。