评估神经放射学中人工智能与机器学习研究的兴起与演变
该文献计量学分析检索《美国神经放射学杂志》自1980年1月1日创刊至2022年12月3日发表的原创研究,共纳入182篇AI/ML相关文章;其中79%为非整合类(类型1共53篇、类型2共90篇),21%为终端应用类(类型3共39篇),发文量近5年约增长5倍,主要由非整合类文章驱动;仅少数类型2文章涉及偏倚(22%)与可解释性(16%)。
要点
- AI/ML文章近5年约增长5倍,但终端应用类仅占21%(39/182)。
- 类型2文章中仅22%涉及偏倚、16%涉及可解释性。
- 作者认为改进方向包括提升类型2文章质量,即外部验证。
核心结论
- 神经放射学中AI/ML论文快速增加,但仅少部分增长归因于终端应用。
- 作者指出需改进的方面包括提升类型2文章质量(即外部验证),并处理偏倚与可解释性问题。
- 作者认为这些结果可为作者、编辑、临床医生与政策制定者提供见解,以推动神经放射学中实用AI/ML解决方案的整合。
研究设计与样本
- 文献计量学分析,检索《美国神经放射学杂志》自1980年1月1日创刊至2022年12月3日的原创研究文章。
- 检索词包括machine learning、artificial intelligence、radiomics、deep learning、neural network、generative adversarial network、object detection、natural language processing。
- 由2名独立审阅者筛选文章,并分为统计建模(类型1)、AI/ML开发(类型2)与终端用户应用(类型3);类型1与类型2均为无直接临床整合的开发性研究工作,类型3为最接近AI/ML整合进日常实践的替代指标。
- 为更好理解限制类型3文章发表的因素,分析了类型2文章,因其应代表通向类型3的前期工作。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 共识别182篇文章,79%为非整合类(类型1 n=53,类型2 n=90),21%(n=39)为类型3。
- 过去5年发表文章总数约增长5倍,主要由非整合类文章驱动。
- 少数类型2文章涉及偏倚(22%)与可解释性(16%)。
- 这些文章主要由放射科医生主导(63%),其中多数(60%)拥有额外研究生学位。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为改进方向包括提升类型2文章质量,即外部验证,并处理偏倚与可解释性问题。
- 作者认为这些结果可为作者、编辑、临床医生与政策制定者提供见解,以推动神经放射学中实用AI/ML解决方案的整合。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Interest in artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) has been growing in neuroradiology, but there is limited knowledge on how this interest has manifested into research and specifically, its qualities and characteristics. This study aims to characterize the emergence and evolution of AI/ML articles within neuroradiology and provide a comprehensive overview of the trends, challenges, and future directions of the field.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We performed a bibliometric analysis of the American Journal of Neuroradiology; the journal was queried for original research articles published since inception (January 1, 1980) to December 3, 2022 that contained any of the following key terms: "machine learning," "artificial intelligence," "radiomics," "deep learning," "neural network," "generative adversarial network," "object detection," or "natural language processing." Articles were screened by 2 independent reviewers, and categorized into statistical modeling (type 1), AI/ML development (type 2), both representing developmental research work but without a direct clinical integration, or end-user application (type 3), which is the closest surrogate of potential AI/ML integration into day-to-day practice. To better understand the limiting factors to type 3 articles being published, we analyzed type 2 articles as they should represent the precursor work leading to type 3.
RESULTS: A total of 182 articles were identified with 79% being nonintegration focused (type 1 n = 53, type 2 n = 90) and 21% (n = 39) being type 3. The total number of articles published grew roughly 5-fold in the last 5 years, with the nonintegration focused articles mainly driving this growth. Additionally, a minority of type 2 articles addressed bias (22%) and explainability (16%). These articles were primarily led by radiologists (63%), with most (60%) having additional postgraduate degrees.
CONCLUSIONS: AI/ML publications have been rapidly increasing in neuroradiology with only a minority of this growth being attributable to end-user application. Areas identified for improvement include enhancing the quality of type 2 articles, namely external validation, and addressing both bias and explainability. These results ultimately provide authors, editors, clinicians, and policymakers important insights to promote a shift toward integrating practical AI/ML solutions in neuroradiology.
引用
- Boutet A, Haile SS, Yang AZ, et al. Assessing the Emergence and Evolution of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning Research in Neuroradiology. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2024. PMID: 38521092. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8252
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。