影中何物?形式分析:艺术史方法提升住院医师乳腺X线与胸部X线阅片技能
该先验后测研究让住院医师在4次艺术史形式分析课程前后,对10张乳腺X线和10张胸部X线进行描述与诊断。参与者平均在30%的乳腺X线图像上改善描述、31%上改善诊断;胸部X线分别平均37%和52%改善。14名完成调查者中多数认可该方法可用于影像解读,8人自报识别异常和构建描述词有进步。
要点
- 艺术史形式分析课程后,住院医师在部分乳腺X线和胸片上的图像描述与诊断得到改善。
- 参与者平均在30%乳腺X线图像上改善描述、31%上改善诊断。
- 参与者平均在37%胸片图像上改善描述、52%上改善诊断。
核心结论
- 该先导研究提示,艺术史家所用的形式分析可能改善影像学习者的感知和描述相关影像异常的能力,进而可能带来更准确的影像鉴别诊断。
- 形式分析过程训练眼睛检测和归类图像的基础结构。
- 该方法提供了一种专门设计用于改善放射学教育中基本视觉技能的替代性艺术干预。
研究设计与样本
- 先验后测研究设计,共20名住院医师参与,使用预先选定的10张乳腺X线和10张胸部X线,共20例匿名患者病例。
- 前测后接受4次形式分析艺术史课程,形式元素包括线条、明暗、阴影、比例和平衡。
- 后测使用与前测相同的一组图像,完成后参与者填写书面调查。
关键影像表现/征象
- 原文未报告具体影像征象。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 参与者平均在30%的乳腺X线图像上改善图像描述,在31%的乳腺X线图像上改善图像诊断。
- 参与者平均在37%的胸部X线图像上改善图像描述,在52%的胸部X线图像上改善图像诊断。
- 20名参与者中14名(70%)完成了研究后调查;几乎所有受访者认可形式分析可应用于影像解读。
- 14名参与者中8名(57%)自报在识别异常和构建描述词方面有改善。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,艺术史家所用的形式分析可能改善放射学学习者感知和描述相关影像异常的能力,进而可能带来更准确的影像鉴别诊断。
- 作者认为,形式分析过程训练眼睛检测和归类图像的基础结构。
- 作者认为,该方法提供了专门设计用于改善放射学教育中基本视觉技能的替代性艺术干预。
局限性
- 原文称该研究为先导研究(pilot study)。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To assess the feasibility of using an art history tool of formal analysis in resident education for interpretations of mammography and chest radiographs METHODS: In a pre-post study design, residents were shown pre-selected 10 mammograms and 10 chest radiographs for a total of 20 unique anonymized patient cases. After the pretest, residents attended four formal analysis art history lessons. The formal elements included line, light, dark, shade, proportion and balance. The post-tests were administered utilizing the same set of images given during the pre-test. After the completion of the pre- and post-tests, the participants filled out a written survey.
RESULTS: On average, participants improved their image descriptions for a mean of 30% of the total number of mammographic images they evaluated, and similarly they improved their image diagnoses for a mean of 31% of the mammographic images. On average, participants improved their image descriptions for a mean of 37% of the total number of chest radiographs they evaluated, while improving their image diagnoses for a mean of 52% of the chest X-rays. Of the 20 participants, 14 (70%) completed the post study survey. Almost all of the respondents endorsed agreement in understanding the application of formal analysis to radiologic interpretation. Eight out of 14 (57%) participants self-reported improvement in identifying abnormalities and contriving descriptors.
CONCLUSION: This pilot study shows that formal art analysis used by art historians may improve radiologic learners' ability to perceive and describe relevant radiologic abnormalities which in turn would lead to a more accurate radiologic differential diagnosis. The formal analysis process trains the eye to detect and categorize the underlying structure of images. This method provides an alternative arts intervention specifically designed to improve fundamental visual skills in radiology education.
引用
- Choe AI, Conaty S, Ha J, et al. What's in the Shadows? Formal Analysis: Art History Method to Improve Interpretation Skills for Mammography and Chest Radiographs in Resident Education. Acad Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38401984. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2023.10.063
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。