文献速递腹部MR

使用两种不同多动脉期技术的钆塞酸增强肝脏MRI研究中的患者内和观察者间图像质量分析

Intra-patient and inter-observer image quality analysis in liver MRI study with gadoxetic acid using two different multi-arterial phase techniques.
PubMed 文献 · Br J Radiol · 2024-01-01

154例前瞻性入组患者12个月内两次接受钆塞酸增强肝脏MRI,分别采用CAIPIRINHA-VIBE与TWIST-VIBE多动脉期算法。CAIPIRINHA-VIBE各参数评分更优但噪声评分更高,且37%未能完成三期动脉期;TWIST-VIBE全部成功获得三期动脉期,但Gibbs伪影和呼吸运动伪影评分最差。屏气时间是唯一影响多动脉期技术成功的参数。

要点

  • CAIPIRINHA-VIBE除噪声评分更高外,其余各参数评分均优于TWIST-VIBE。
  • TWIST-VIBE全部患者成功获得三期动脉期;CAIPIRINHA-VIBE有37%失败(11%仅一期、26%仅两期)。
  • 屏气时间是唯一影响多动脉期技术成功的参数;屏气好者TWIST-VIBE更可取,否则CAIPIRINHA-VIBE更合适。

核心结论

  • CAIPIRINHA-VIBE图像始终可诊断,但37%未能完成三期动脉期;TWIST-VIBE全部患者成功获得三期动脉期。
  • 屏气时间是唯一能影响CAIPIRINHA-VIBE与TWIST-VIBE算法初步选择的参数。
  • 作者认为,若预期患者屏气良好,TWIST-VIBE更可取;否则CAIPIRINHA-VIBE更合适。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性入组154例患者,12个月内两次接受临床钆塞酸增强肝脏MRI,分别使用CAIPIRINHA-VIBE与TWIST-VIBE两种多动脉期算法。
  • 记录每例患者的屏气时间、体重指数、性别和年龄。
  • 由两名放射科医生独立评估无对比剂期和动脉期,量化Gibbs伪影、噪声、呼吸运动伪影和总体图像质量。
  • Gibbs伪影和噪声的有无采用McNemar检验比较,呼吸运动伪影和图像质量评分采用Wilcoxon符号秩检验比较,观察者间一致性采用Cohen kappa统计评估。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 与TWIST-VIBE相比,CAIPIRINHA-VIBE图像除噪声评分更高外,其余各参数评分均更好。
  • TWIST-VIBE图像Gibbs伪影和呼吸运动伪影评分最差,但噪声评分更低。
  • CAIPIRINHA-VIBE有37%未能完成三期动脉期:11%仅获得一期动脉期,26%获得两期。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 屏气时间是唯一影响多动脉期技术成功的参数,可据此初步选择CAIPIRINHA-VIBE或TWIST-VIBE算法。
  • 若预期患者屏气良好,作者认为TWIST-VIBE更可取;否则CAIPIRINHA-VIBE更合适。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: To evaluate intra-patient and interobserver agreement in patients who underwent liver MRI with gadoxetic acid using two different multi-arterial phase (AP) techniques.

METHODS: A total of 154 prospectively enrolled patients underwent clinical gadoxetic acid-enhanced liver MRI twice within 12 months, using two different multi-arterial algorithms: CAIPIRINHA-VIBE and TWIST-VIBE. For every patient, breath-holding time, body mass index, sex, age were recorded. The phase without contrast media and the APs were independently evaluated by two radiologists who quantified Gibbs artefacts, noise, respiratory motion artefacts, and general image quality. Presence or absence of Gibbs artefacts and noise was compared by the McNemar's test. Respiratory motion artefacts and image quality scores were compared using Wilcoxon signed rank test. Interobserver agreement was assessed by Cohen kappa statistics.

RESULTS: Compared with TWIST-VIBE, CAIPIRINHA-VIBE images had better scores for every parameter except higher noise score. Triple APs were always acquired with TWIST-VIBE but failed in 37% using CAIPIRINHA-VIBE: 11% have only one AP, 26% have two. Breath-holding time was the only parameter that influenced the success of multi-arterial techniques. TWIST-VIBE images had worst score for Gibbs and respiratory motion artefacts but lower noise score.

CONCLUSION: CAIPIRINHA-VIBE images were always diagnostic, but with a failure of triple-AP in 37%. TWIST-VIBE was successful in obtaining three APs in all patients. Breath-holding time is the only parameter which can influence the preliminary choice between CAIPIRINHA-VIBE and TWIST-VIBE algorithm.

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: If the patient is expected to perform good breath-holds, TWIST-VIBE is preferable; otherwise, CAIPIRINHA-VIBE is more appropriate.

来源:Br J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Castagnoli F, Faletti R, Inchingolo R, et al. Intra-patient and inter-observer image quality analysis in liver MRI study with gadoxetic acid using two different multi-arterial phase techniques. Br J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38400772. doi:10.1093/bjr/tqae045

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。