商用两点与多回波Dixon MRI定量肝脏、椎旁肌肉和椎体骨髓脂肪准确性的比较
研究纳入100名健康白人(50名女性),采用两点Dixon和多回波Dixon序列行腹部MRI,计算肝脏、椎旁肌肉和椎体骨髓的脂肪分数(FF)、质子密度脂肪分数(PDFF)和T2*值。肝脏和椎旁肌肉的FF与PDFF相关性高且相对偏差不显著,但骨髓的相对偏差显著(女性38.13%,男性27.62%)。结论指出两点Dixon在骨髓脂肪估计中存在系统误差,主要源于器官特异性T2*时间,线性模型校正可减少差异,T2*的性别差异应考虑。
要点
- 两点Dixon与多回波Dixon在肝脏和椎旁肌肉脂肪定量中相关性高且偏差不显著。
- 骨髓脂肪分数在两点Dixon中存在显著系统偏差,女性38.13%、男性27.62%。
- 骨髓T2*时间显著短于椎旁肌肉和肝脏,器官特异性T2*是偏差主要来源。
核心结论
- 肝脏和椎旁肌肉两点Dixon与多回波Dixon无显著差异,但骨髓脂肪估计存在系统误差,主要源于器官特异性T2*时间;线性模型校正可减少差异,大规模队列研究可考虑使用,T2*的性别差异应考虑。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入100名健康白人(50名女性),行腹部MRI,采用商用两点Dixon和多回波Dixon序列,计算肝脏、椎旁肌肉(Th8-L5)和椎体骨髓的FF、PDFF及T2*值,用线性相关和Bland-Altman图评估一致性和系统偏差。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 肝脏FF与PDFF相关性:女性r=0.98,男性r=0.96;椎旁肌肉:女性r=0.92,男性r=0.93;骨髓:女性r=0.97,男性r=0.95。
- 肝脏FF与PDFF相对偏差:女性18.92%,男性13.32%,不显著;椎旁肌肉:女性1.96%,男性11.62%,不显著;骨髓:女性38.13%,男性27.62%,显著。
- T2*时间:骨髓女性8.72 ms、男性7.26 ms;椎旁肌肉女性13.45 ms、男性13.62 ms;肝脏女性29.47 ms、男性26.35 ms;骨髓显著短于椎旁肌肉和肝脏。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 应用两点Dixon评估骨髓脂肪含量时需考虑其系统误差,尤其女性偏差更大(38.13% vs 男性27.62%)。
- 线性模型校正可减少两点Dixon与多回波Dixon的差异,在大规模流行病学队列研究中可能提供附加价值。
- T2*时间的性别差异应在脂肪定量解读中予以考虑。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Excess fat accumulation contributes significantly to metabolic dysfunction and diseases. This study aims to systematically compare the accuracy of commercially available Dixon techniques for quantification of fat fraction in liver, skeletal musculature, and vertebral bone marrow (BM) of healthy individuals, investigating biases and sex-specific influences.
METHOD: 100 healthy White individuals (50 women) underwent abdominal MRI using two-point and multi-echo Dixon sequences. Fat fraction (FF), proton density fat fraction (PDFF) and T2* values were calculated for liver, paravertebral muscles (PVM) and vertebral BM (Th8-L5). Agreement and systematic deviations were assessed using linear correlation and Bland-Altman plots.
RESULTS: High correlations between FF and PDFF were observed in liver (r = 0.98 for women; r = 0.96 for men), PVM (r = 0.92 for women; r = 0.93 for men) and BM (r = 0.97 for women; r = 0.95 for men). Relative deviations between FF and PDFF in liver (18.92 % for women; 13.32 % for men) and PVM (1.96 % for women; 11.62 % for men) were not significant. Relative deviations in BM were significant (38.13 % for women; 27.62 % for men). Bias correction using linear models reduced discrepancies. T2* times were significantly shorter in BM (8.72 ms for women; 7.26 ms for men) compared to PVM (13.45 ms for women; 13.62 ms for men) and liver (29.47 ms for women; 26.35 ms for men).
CONCLUSION: While no significant differences were observed for liver and PVM, systematic errors in BM FF estimation using two-point Dixon imaging were observed. These discrepancies - mainly resulting from organ-specific T2* times - have to be considered when applying two-point Dixon approaches for assessment of fat content. As suitable correction tools, linear models could provide added value in large-scale epidemiological cohort studies. Sex-specific differences in T2* should be considered.
引用
- Haueise T, Schick F, Stefan N, et al. Comparison of the accuracy of commercial two-point and multi-echo Dixon MRI for quantification of fat in liver, paravertebral muscles, and vertebral bone marrow. Eur J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38325186. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111359
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。