位置不当的鼻胃喂养管:医学生能否安全识别
该研究评估四年级和五年级医学生在胸片上判断鼻胃管位置的能力,并测试一种在线交互学习工具的效果。结果显示仅4.8%的五年级和3.1%的四年级学生能全部正确识别,51.8%和47.2%的学生将至少一根位置不当的鼻胃管误判为可安全喂养,学习工具后正确率显著提高(P<.001)。作者认为喂养鼻胃管使用前应正式报告。
要点
- 医学生识别鼻胃管位置的能力不足,仅少数能全部正确判断。
- 约半数学生将至少一根位置不当的鼻胃管误判为可安全喂养。
- 在线交互学习工具可显著提高医学生判断鼻胃管位置的能力。
核心结论
- 医学生判断鼻胃管是否在胃内的能力仍不理想,即使接触超过60张胸片;喂养鼻胃管使用前应正式报告。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入四年级(MB4)和五年级(MB5)医学生,先观看20张胸片(14根位置正确、6根位置不当),MB5为干预组接受在线交互学习工具,MB4为对照组;一周后两组再观看20张胸片。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 249名MB5学生中仅12名(4.8%)全部正确识别鼻胃管位置,161名MB4学生中仅5名(3.1%)全部正确。
- 将1根或以上位置不当鼻胃管误判为「可安全喂养」的学生:MB5组129名(51.8%),MB4组76名(47.2%)。
- 接触学习工具后,58%的学生全部胸片判断正确,28%的学生将1根或以上位置不当鼻胃管判断错误,改善显著(P<.001)。
- 在1108次机会中仅1次未能识别鼻胃管位于肺内(「never event」)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为喂养鼻胃管使用前应正式报告。
- 学生在判断鼻胃管尖端是否充分进入胃内方面存在困难。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Nasogastric tube (NGT) placement is listed against Clinical Imaging in the upcoming Medical Licensing Assessment-compulsory for every graduating UK medical student from 2025. This study aims to establish the ability of medical students to correctly identify the position of an NGT on Chest X-ray (CXR) and to evaluate a learning tool to improve student outcome in this area.
METHODS: Fourth-year (MB4) and fifth-year (MB5) medical students were invited to view 20 CXRs with 14 correctly sited and 6 mal-positioned NGT. MB5 students (Intervention) were exposed to an online interactive learning tool, with MB4 students kept as control. One week later, both groups of students were invited to view 20 more CXRs for NGT placement.
RESULTS: Only 12 (4.8%) of 249 MB5 students and 5 (3.1%) of 161 MB4 students correctly identified all the NGTs on CXRs. The number of students misidentifying 1 or more mal-positioned NGT as "safe to feed" was 129 (51.8%) for MB5 and 76 (47.2%) for MB4 students. This improved significantly (P < .001) following exposure to the learning tool with 58% scoring all CXRs correctly, while 28% scored 1 or more mal-positioned NGT incorrectly. Students struggled to determine if the NGT tip had adequately passed into the stomach. However, they failed to identify an NG tube in the lung ("never event") in just one out of 1,108 opportunities.
CONCLUSION: Medical students' ability to determine if the NGT was in the stomach remains suboptimal despite exposure to over 60 CXRs. Feeding NGT should be formally reported before use.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: This is the first attempt at quantifying graduating medical students', and by inference junior doctors', competence in safely identifying misplaced nasogastric feeding tubes. An online, experiential learning resource significantly improved their ability.
引用
- Chew C, O'Dwyer PJ, Young D, et al. Mal-positioned nasogastric feeding tubes: are medical students safe to identify them? Br J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38335146. doi:10.1093/bjr/tqae007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。