指南与共识腹部技术与安全US

放射科医师学会超声共识会议关于偶发胆囊息肉管理建议:10名放射科医师间的阅片者一致性

Society of Radiologists in Ultrasound Consensus Conference Recommendations for Incidental Gallbladder Polyp Management: Interreader Agreement Among 10 Radiologists.
指南 / 共识 · AJR Am J Roentgenol · 2024-02-14

本研究纳入105例超声发现胆囊息肉并接受胆囊切除术的患者,由10名腹部放射科医师依据2022年SRU共识建议独立评估息肉风险分类和手术咨询建议。风险分类的阅片者间一致性为显著(k=0.710),手术咨询建议的一致性为显著(k=0.795),但不同医师对同一息肉的风险分类和建议存在变异。

要点

  • 依据SRU建议进行胆囊息肉风险分类,10名腹部放射科医师间一致性为显著(k=0.710)。
  • 手术咨询建议的阅片者间一致性为显著(k=0.795),经验较少者几乎完全一致(k=0.811)。
  • 不同医师将息肉分类为极低风险的比例范围为32%至72%,建议手术咨询的比例范围为4%至22%。

核心结论

  • 10名腹部放射科医师依据SRU建议对胆囊息肉进行风险分类和手术咨询建议时表现出显著一致性,但同时也存在阅片者间变异。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究纳入2003年1月1日至2021年1月1日期间接受胆囊切除术的105例患者(75例女性,30例男性;中位年龄51岁),由10名腹部放射科医师独立审阅超声检查,依据SRU建议为每例患者的一个息肉分配风险类别并给出手术咨询建议;5名医师经验少于5年,5名医师经验不少于5年;息肉经病理分类为非肿瘤性或肿瘤性。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 风险分类的阅片者间一致性:所有阅片者k=0.710,经验较少者k=0.705,经验较多者k=0.692。
  • 手术咨询建议的阅片者间一致性:所有阅片者k=0.795,经验较多者k=0.740,经验较少者k=0.811。
  • 在10名阅片者中,将息肉分类为极低风险、低风险和不确定风险的中位阅片者人数分别为5.0(IQR,2.0-8.0)、4.0(IQR,2.0-7.0)和0.0(IQR,0.0-0.0)。
  • 不同阅片者将息肉分类为极低风险的比例范围为32%至72%,低风险为24%至65%,不确定风险为0%至8%;建议手术咨询的比例范围为4%至22%。
  • 105个息肉中,102个为非肿瘤性,3个为肿瘤性(均为良性);根据阅片者最常见的评估,非肿瘤性息肉中极低风险53个、低风险48个、不确定风险1个,建议手术咨询16个。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文报告了阅片者间存在变异区域。
  • 原文指出研究结果提示有改进空间。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND. The 2022 Society of Radiologists in Ultrasound (SRU) consensus conference recommendations for small gallbladder polyps support management that is less aggressive than earlier approaches and may help standardize evaluation of polyps by radiologists. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of the present study was to assess the interreader agreement of radiologists in applying SRU recommendations for management of incidental gallbladder polyps on ultrasound. METHODS. This retrospective study included 105 patients (75 women and 30 men; median age, 51 years) with a gallbladder polyp on ultrasound (without features highly suspicious for invasive or malignant tumor) who underwent cholecystectomy between January 1, 2003, and January 1, 2021. Ten abdominal radiologists independently reviewed ultrasound examinations and, using the SRU recommendations, assessed one polyp per patient to assign risk category (extremely low risk, low risk, or indeterminate risk) and make a possible recommendation for surgical consultation. Five radiologists were considered less experienced (< 5 years of experience), and five were considered more experienced (≥ 5 years of experience). Interreader agreement was evaluated. Polyps were classified pathologically as nonneoplastic or neoplastic. RESULTS. For risk category assignments, interreader agreement was substantial among all readers (k = 0.710), less-experienced readers (k = 0.705), and more-experienced readers (k = 0.692). For surgical consultation recommendations, inter-reader agreement was substantial among all readers (k = 0.795) and more-experienced readers (k = 0.740) and was almost perfect among less-experienced readers (k = 0.811). Of 10 readers, a median of 5.0 (IQR, 2.0-8.0), 4.0 (IQR, 2.0-7.0), and 0.0 (IQR, 0.0-0.0) readers classified polyps as extremely low risk, low risk, and indeterminate risk, respectively. Across readers, the percentage of polyps classified as extremely low risk ranged from 32% to 72%; as low risk, from 24% to 65%; and as indeterminate risk, from 0% to 8%. Of 10 readers, a median of zero change to 0 (IQR, 0.0-1.0) readers recommended surgical consultation; the percentage of polyps receiving a recommendation for surgical consultation ranged from 4% to 22%. Of a total of 105 polyps, 102 were nonneo-plastic and three were neoplastic (all benign). Based on readers' most common assessments for nonneoplastic polyps, the risk category was extremely low risk for 53 polyps, low risk for 48 polyps, and indeterminate risk for one polyp; surgical consultation was recommended for 16 polyps. CONCLUSION. Ten abdominal radiologists showed substantial agreement for polyp risk categorizations and surgical consultation recommendations, although areas of reader variability were identified. CLINICAL IMPACT. The findings support the overall reproducibility of the SRU recommendations, while indicating opportunity for improvement.

来源:AJR Am J Roentgenol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Anderson MA, Mercaldo S, Cao J, et al. Society of Radiologists in Ultrasound Consensus Conference Recommendations for Incidental Gallbladder Polyp Management: Interreader Agreement Among 10 Radiologists. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2024. PMID: 38353447. doi:10.2214/AJR.23.30720

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。