利用有效直径电子密度估算CT扫描的体型特异性剂量估算值(SSDE)
回顾性纳入350例不同体型患者,在6种CT体部扫描方案下比较基于组织电子密度校正的有效直径(Deffρe)与常规有效直径(Deff)对水等效直径(Dw)的估算差异。胸部方案中Deff,LAT+APρe与Deff,LATρe的平均绝对百分比差异为3%–7%,优于Deff的9%–15%;其他体部方案中Deff差异为2%–4%。作者认为无法评估Dw时,Deff,LATρe仅可考虑用于胸部方案作为替代方法,Deff可用于所有部位但胸部方案需应用校正因子。
要点
- 胸部CT方案中,基于电子密度校正的有效直径方法(Deff,LAT+APρe、Deff,LATρe)对Dw的估算优于常规Deff。
- 其他体部方案中,常规Deff对Dw的估算差异为2%–4%,低于Deffρe方法。
- 作者认为无法评估Dw时,Deff,LATρe仅可考虑用于胸部方案作为替代方法。
核心结论
- 无法评估Dw时,Deff,LATρe方法仅可考虑用于胸部方案作为替代方法。
- Deff方法也可用于所有部位,但胸部方案需应用校正因子以避免患者剂量显著低估或高估。
研究设计与样本
- 经IRB批准,从医院回顾性收集350例不同体型患者。
- 评估6种CT体部方案:胸部增强、胸部高分辨率CT(HRCT)平扫、腹盆部增强、腹盆部平扫、胸腹盆部增强、盆腔平扫。
- 采用本院开发的MATLAB代码,在患者图像中间CT层面评估常规有效直径(Deff)、校正横径与前后径的Deffρe(Deff,LAT+APρe)、仅校正横径的Deffρe(Deff,LATρe)以及Dw。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 胸部方案中,Deff,LAT+APρe与Deff,LATρe对所有体型患者的平均绝对百分比差异(PD)为3%–7%,Deff为9%–15%。
- 其他体部方案中,Deff对Dw的平均绝对PD为2%–4%,低于Deff,LAT+APρe与Deff,LATρe方法。
- 胸部方案中Deff与其他方法间差异有统计学意义;其他扫描方案中各方法间无显著差异。
- 同时校正LAT和AP两个维度并未提高Deffρe方法的准确性,多数方案中Deff,LAT+APρe的差异范围大于仅校正LAT维度的Deff,LATρe。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 无法评估Dw时,Deff,LATρe方法仅可考虑用于胸部方案作为替代方法。
- Deff方法也可用于所有部位,但胸部方案需应用校正因子以避免患者剂量显著低估或高估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: An assessment of the effective diameter of a patient's body using electron densities of tissues inside the scan area (Deffρe) was proposed to overcome challenges associated with the estimation of water-equivalent diameter (Dw), which is used for size-specific dose estimate (SSDE). The aims of this study were to (1) investigate the Deffρe method in two different forms using a wide range of patient sizes and scanning protocols, and (2) compare between four methods used to estimate the patient size for SSDE.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Under IRB approval, a total of 350 patients of varying sizes have been collected retrospectively from the Hospital. The Dw values were assessed over six different CT body protocols: (1) chest with contrast media, (2) chest High-Resolution Computed Tomography (HRCT) without contrast media, (3) abdomen-pelvis with contrast media, (4) abdomen-pelvis without contrast media, (5) chest-abdomen-pelvis with contrast media, and (6) pelvis without contrast media. A MATLAB-based code was developed in-house to assess the size of each patient using the conventional effective diameter method (Deff), Deffρe by correcting either both the lateral (LAT) and anterior-posterior (AP) dimensions (Deff,LAT+APρe) or LAT only (Deff,LATρe), and Dw at the mid-CT slice of the patient images.
RESULTS: The results of Deff,LAT+APρe and Deff,LATρe provided a better estimation for the chest protocols with the averages of absolute percentage difference (PD) values in the range of 3 - 7 % for all patient sizes as compared to the Dw method, whereas the averages of PD values for the Deff method were 9 - 15 %. However, Deff gave a better estimation for Dw values for the other body protocols, with differences of 2 - 4 %, which were lower than those obtained with the Deff,LAT+APρe and Deff,LATρe methods. For the chest protocols, statistically significant differences were found between Deff and the other methods, but there were no significant differences between all the methods for the other scanning protocols. The results show that the correction of both dimensions, LAT and AP, did not improve the accuracy of the Deffρe method, and, for most protocols, Deff,LAT+APρe gave larger range differences compared to those based on correction of the LAT dimension only.
CONCLUSION: If the Dw cannot be assessed, the Deff,LATρe method may only be considered for the chest protocols as an alternative approach. The Deff method may also be used for all regions taking into account the application of a correction factor for the chest protocols to avoid a significant under or overestimation of the patient dose.
引用
- Almuqbil K, Abuhaimed A, Abanomy A, et al. Estimation of size-specific dose estimate (SSDE) of CT scans using an effective diameter electron density. Eur J Radiol. 2024. PMID: 38266405. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2024.111311
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。