轮班工作量直接影响大型学术医疗中心神经放射学错误率:论工作量限制的必要性
该研究基于美国一家大型学术医疗中心2014—2020年神经放射学质量保证数据库中的CT和MR报告,分析主治医师错误与轮班工作量的关系。共发现643个错误,其中91.7%有临床意义;总体错误率为2.36/1000次检查。轮班工作量越低,错误率显著越低,错误率最低的工作量范围为19—26例。
要点
- 轮班工作量≤26例时错误率为1.59/1000次检查,>26例时为2.58(OR 1.63,P<.001)。
- 工作量67—90例组的错误率较≤19例组高226%。
- 错误率最低的轮班工作量范围为19—26例。
核心结论
- 轮班工作量越低,错误率显著越低;错误率最低的轮班工作量范围为19—26例。
研究设计与样本
- 研究基于美国一家大型学术医疗中心神经放射学质量保证数据库(2014—2020年)的CT和MR报告,检索主治医师错误,收集每1000次解读检查的轮班工作量特异性错误率和RADPEER评分,并计算2、3、4组轮班工作量的最佳截断点及各亚组错误率。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 总体错误率为2.36/1000次检查,共发现643个错误,其中91.7%有临床意义(RADPEER 2b、3b)。
- 最佳单一轮班工作量截断点分为2组:≤26例组错误率1.59,>26例组错误率2.58(OR 1.63,P<.001)。
- 最佳2个截断点分为3组:≤19例组错误率1.34,20—28例组错误率1.88(OR 1.4,P=.1),≥29例组错误率2.6(OR 1.94,P<.001)。
- 最佳3个截断点分为4组:≤24例组错误率1.59,25—66例组错误率2.44(OR 1.54,P<.001),67—90例组错误率3.03(OR 1.91,P<.001),≥91例组错误率2.07(OR 1.30,P=.25)。
- 工作量≥91例组样本量有限。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者指出,美国目前缺乏专科放射学会关于工作流程管理和适应性干预以降低错误率的指南或推荐。
- 作者认为,本研究可能有助于上述讨论,并发现错误率与轮班工作量之间存在直接关系。
局限性
- 工作量≥91例组样本量有限。
- 美国目前缺乏专科放射学会关于工作流程管理和适应性干预以降低错误率的指南或推荐。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Unlike in Europe and Japan, guidelines or recommendations from specialized radiological societies on workflow management and adaptive intervention to reduce error rates are currently lacking in the United States. This study of neuroradiologic reads at a large US academic medical center, which may hopefully contribute to this discussion, found a direct relationship between error rate and shift volume.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: CT and MR imaging reports from our institution's Neuroradiology Quality Assurance database (years 2014-2020) were searched for attending physician errors. Data were collected on shift volume specific error rates per 1000 interpreted studies and RADPEER scores. Optimal cutoff points for 2, 3 and 4 groups of shift volumes were computed along with subgroups' error rates.
RESULTS: A total of 643 errors were found, 91.7% of which were clinically significant (RADPEER 2b, 3b). The overall error rate (errors/1000 examinations) was 2.36. The best single shift volume cutoff point generated 2 groups: ≤ 26 studies (error rate 1.59) and > 26 studies (2.58; OR: 1.63, P < .001). The best 2 shift volume cutoff points generated 3 shift volume groups: ≤ 19 (1.34), 20-28 (1.88; OR: 1.4, P = .1) and ≥ 29 (2.6; OR: 1.94, P < .001). The best 3 shift volume cutoff points generated 4 groups: ≤ 24 (1.59), 25-66 (2.44; OR: 1.54, P < .001), 67-90 (3.03; OR: 1.91, P < .001), and ≥ 91 (2.07; OR: 1.30, P = .25). The group with shift volume ≥ 91 had a limited sample size.
CONCLUSIONS: Lower shift volumes yielded significantly lower error rates. The lowest error rates were observed with shift volumes that were limited to 19-26 studies. Error rates at shift volumes between 67-90 studies were 226% higher, compared with the error rate at shift volumes of ≤ 19 studies.
引用
- Ivanovic V, Broadhead K, Chang YM, et al. Shift Volume Directly Impacts Neuroradiology Error Rate at a Large Academic Medical Center: The Case for Volume Limits. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2024. PMID: 38238099. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A8119
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。