头颈部影像检查附加影像推荐:放射科医生间差异及相关因素
该回顾性研究纳入39200例头颈部CT或MRI检查、61名放射科医生,用自然语言处理识别报告印象中的附加影像推荐(RAI),发现RAI率7.5%,医生间RAI率从0.8%到22.0%不等,模型仅解释10.9%的RAI可能性,其中74.3%可解释部分归因于医生个体行为。
要点
- 头颈部影像报告中RAI总体发生率为7.5%,但不同放射科医生间RAI率差异高达27.5倍。
- RAI可能性与检查类型(CTA高于CT)、报告生成含受训者、患者种族及年龄、医生培训年限相关。
- 可解释的RAI可能性中74.3%归因于医生个体行为,仅25.7%归因于可测量的系统因素。
核心结论
- 头颈部影像的RAI率在放射科医生间差异显著,RAI似乎更多与医生个体行为相关,而非可测量的系统因素。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入2021年6月1日至2022年5月31日期间39200例头颈部CT或MRI检查、39200例患者(中位年龄58岁;21855名女性、17315名男性、30例性别信息缺失),由61名放射科医生解读;采用自然语言处理工具并人工复核识别报告印象中的RAI;使用广义混合效应模型评估RAI与检查、患者及医生因素的关联。
诊断标准与关键数值
- RAI定义为报告印象中推荐的附加影像,由自然语言处理工具识别并经人工复核确认。
- 共2943份(7.5%)报告包含RAI。
- 个体医生RAI率范围为0.8%至22.0%(中位数7.1%;IQR 5.2-10.2%),最小值与最大值间相差27.5倍,第25与第75百分位间相差1.8倍。
- 多变量分析中,CTA较CT检查的RAI可能性更高(OR 1.32),报告生成含受训者的检查RAI可能性更高(OR 1.23),自认种族为Black或African American的患者较White患者RAI可能性更高(OR 1.25);男性患者较女性患者RAI可能性更低(OR 0.90);RAI与患者年龄增加相关(每十年OR 1.09),与医生培训后年限呈负相关(每5年OR 0.90)。
- 模型解释了10.9%的RAI可能性;在可解释的RAI可能性中,25.7%归因于检查、患者和医生因素,74.3%归因于医生个体行为。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论指出,纳入偶发发现管理最佳实践的质量改进举措可能有助于减少放射科医生在发出头颈部影像RAI时的偏好敏感决策及相关诊疗差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. A paucity of relevant guidelines may lead to pronounced variation among radiologists in issuing recommendations for additional imaging (RAI) for head and neck imaging. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this article was to explore associations of RAI for head and neck imaging examinations with examination, patient, and radiologist factors and to assess the role of individual radiologist-specific behavior in issuing such RAI. METHODS. This retrospective study included 39,200 patients (median age, 58 years; 21,855 women, 17,315 men, 30 with missing sex information) who underwent 39,200 head and neck CT or MRI examinations, interpreted by 61 radiologists, from June 1, 2021, through May 31, 2022. A natural language processing (NLP) tool with manual review of NLP results was used to identify RAI in report impressions. Interradiologist variation in RAI rates was assessed. A generalized mixed-effects model was used to assess associations between RAI and examination, patient, and radiologist factors. RESULTS. A total of 2943 (7.5%) reports contained RAI. Individual radiologist RAI rates ranged from 0.8% to 22.0% (median, 7.1%; IQR, 5.2-10.2%), representing a 27.5-fold difference between minimum and a maximum values and 1.8-fold difference between 25th and 75th percentiles. In multivariable analysis, RAI likelihood was higher for CTA than for CT examinations (OR, 1.32), for examinations that included a trainee in report generation (OR, 1.23), and for patients with self-identified race of Black or African American versus White (OR, 1.25); was lower for male than female patients (OR, 0.90); and was associated with increasing patient age (OR, 1.09 per decade) and inversely associated with radiologist years since training (OR, 0.90 per 5 years). The model accounted for 10.9% of the likelihood of RAI. Of explainable likelihood of RAI, 25.7% was attributable to examination, patient, and radiologist factors; 74.3% was attributable to radiologist-specific behavior. CONCLUSION. Interradiologist variation in RAI rates for head and neck imaging was substantial. RAI appear to be more substantially associated with individual radiologist-specific behavior than with measurable systemic factors. CLINICAL IMPACT. Quality improvement initiatives, incorporating best practices for incidental findings management, may help reduce radiologist preference-sensitive decision-making in issuing RAI for head and neck imaging and associated care variation.
引用
- Guenette JP, Lynch E, Abbasi N, et al. Recommendations for Additional Imaging on Head and Neck Imaging Examinations: Interradiologist Variation and Associated Factors. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2024. PMID: 38294159. doi:10.2214/AJR.23.30511
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。