文献速递骨肌MR

MRI识别胫骨远端关节面假性病变:发生频率与诊断标准

MRI identification of pseudolesions in the distal tibia articular surface: Frequency and diagnostic criteria.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2023-11-26

三中心回顾性病例对照研究纳入2428例踝关节MRI,评估胫骨远端关节面软骨不规则,报告一种新假性病变的患病率为3%,多位于后内侧胫骨穹窿,年龄9-30岁多见,常伴骨髓水肿和/或囊肿,但无临床症状且无需手术干预。

要点

  • 胫骨远端关节面新假性病变患病率3%,典型位于后中央和后内侧,多为2-3mm软骨不规则。
  • 该病变可伴骨髓水肿(66%)和/或囊肿(37%),但无临床症状且无需手术或关节镜干预。
  • Harty切迹患病率25%,位于前内侧胫骨关节面,无水肿或囊肿,与新假性病变无共存。

核心结论

  • 新假性病变典型见于后中央和后内侧胫骨关节面,患病率3%,可仅表现为小的软骨不规则。
  • 许多病例伴骨髓水肿和/或邻近骨囊肿,影响与病理性骨软骨病变的鉴别,后者常伴更大软骨缺损和临床症状。
  • 伴与不伴软骨下改变的假性病变年龄分布均衡且无临床症状,作者认为该假性病变不是临床显性骨软骨病变(OCL)的好发因素,至少其缺乏临床相关性增加了其为新真性假性病变的可能性。

研究设计与样本

  • 三中心回顾性病例对照研究,纳入6年间行踝关节MRI检查的2428例患者。
  • 由三名放射科医生共识评估胫骨远端关节面软骨不规则,将胫骨关节面分为9个解剖区域。
  • 采用矢状位和冠状位质子密度加权脂肪抑制序列评估胫骨后内侧关节面。
  • 记录软骨不规则大小和位置、皮质塑形、相关水肿和/或软骨下囊肿等影像特征,以及性别、年龄、体重等人口学数据和疼痛、活动受限、伴随病变等临床数据。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 68例(34男,34女)发现胫骨远端新假性病变,患病率3%,其中50例(74%)位于后内侧胫骨穹窿,9-30岁年龄组更常见(47%)。
  • 68例中13例软骨不规则为唯一病变无软骨下异常,定义为明确假性病变后患病率1%,其中11例(85%)位于后部,尤其后内侧(55%)。
  • 软骨缺损大小范围1-7mm,多数(69%)为2-3mm。
  • 68例中36例除软骨不规则外可见软骨下改变,其中66%(n=45)为水肿、37%(n=25)为囊肿。
  • Harty切迹患病率25%,典型位于前内侧胫骨关节面,无水肿或囊肿,与新假性病变无共存病例。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 新假性病变MRI诊断依据:胫骨远端后中央/后内侧关节面软骨不规则,大小1-7mm(多数2-3mm),可伴软骨下水肿和/或囊肿,无临床症状。
  • 13例随访MRI未见病变形态学改变或临床恶化。
  • 放射学和骨科报告中临床症状(疼痛或不稳定)从未与观察到的病变相关,运动相关疼痛与软骨不规则、软骨下水肿、软骨下囊肿的影像表现之间无显著相关性。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 阅片时注意胫骨远端后中央和后内侧关节面小的软骨不规则(1-7mm),伴或不伴软骨下水肿/囊肿,结合无临床症状可提示假性病变。
  • 需与病理性骨软骨病变鉴别,后者常伴更大软骨缺损和临床症状。
  • 注意与Harty切迹鉴别,后者位于前内侧胫骨关节面,无水肿或囊肿。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: Pseudolesions of joints are known as focal irregularities of chondral or subchondral bone in typical joint areas and occur frequent but without clinical relevance. This study aims to report the prevalence and describe MRI findings of a previously unreported chondral, mostly posterior located pseudolesion of the distal tibia, and to define criteria to distinguish it from pathologic osteochondral lesions, as well as from another known pseudolesion of this area - the so called "Notch of Harty".

MATERIAL AND METHODS: A tri-centric retrospective case-control study included a total of 2,428 patients with ankle MRI examinations performed over a period of 6 years. MRI scans were evaluated by three radiologists in consensus for any cartilage irregularity of the distal tibial articular surface. For this purpose, the tibial articular surface was divided into 9 topographic regions. Proton-density weighted, fat-suppressed sequences in sagittal and coronal acquisition were used to assess the postero-medial articular surface of the tibia. Imaging features such as size and localization of cartilage irregularity and/or a cortical mould as well as presence of associated edema and/or subchondral cysts were reported. Demographic data (sex, age, and weight) was also recorded. Clinical data comprised presence of pain, movement impairment, and concomitant pathologies.

RESULTS: A total of 68 patients (34 male, 34 female) with a lesion of the distal tibia were identified that had a new pseudolesion (prevalence of 3%). These lesions occurred most frequently (50 out of 68, 74%) in the postero-medial distal tibia plafond and were more commonly detected in the age group of 9-30 years (47%). In 13 of these 68 cases, the cartilage irregularity was the sole lesion without subchondral abnormalities. By defining these cases as definite pseudolesions, the prevalence was 1% and their age distribution was similar to that of the 55 other lesions with subchondral changes. Here with 11 of the 13 cases the majority (85%) were seen in the posterior part, especially in the postero-medial part (55%) of the distal tibia. The size of the cartilage defect ranged from 1 to 7 mm, and the majority (69%) sized from 2 to 3 mm. In 36 of 68 patients, we have seen subchondral alterations such as edema and/or cysts in addition to cartilage irregularity. 66% (n = 45) of these changes were edema and 37% (n = 25) were cysts. None of these 68 new pseudolesions with or without subchondral changes needed surgical or arthroscopic intervention. In the radiological and orthopaedic reports, clinical symptoms such as pain or instability were never associated with our observed lesions and there was no significant correlation between the presence of motion-related pain and imaging findings of cartilage irregularity, subchondral edema, and subchondral cysts. Thirteen patients had MRI follow-up examinations. Here the lesions did not show any MR morphological changes or clinical deterioration. Besides the new pseudolesion, which occured mainly in the posterior part of the tibia surface, we observed the "Notch of Harty" with a higher prevalence (25%) in our patient cohort. The typical localization was in the antero-medial tibial articular surface, without any edema or cysts. There were no coincidences of patients with both a new pseudolesion and the "Notch of Harty" CONCLUSION: A new pseudolesion is typically seen in the postero-central and postero-medial tibial articular surface with a prevalence of 3% and may be associated with only a small cartilage irregularity. In many cases, however, additional findings such as bone edema and/or an adjacent bone cysts were found, which impairs differentiation of these lesions from pathologic osteochondral lesions. The latter are obviously often associated with a larger cartilage defect and clinical symptoms. Due to the balanced age distribution between those pseudolesions with and without subchondral changes and the lack of clinical symptoms, we conclude that the here reported pseudolesions are not a predilection for a clinically manifest osteochondral lesion (OCL). At the very least, the apparent lack of clinical relevance increases the likelihood that we are dealing with a new true pseudolesion.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Arndt H, German T, Fischer W, et al. MRI identification of pseudolesions in the distal tibia articular surface: Frequency and diagnostic criteria. Eur J Radiol. 2023. PMID: 38042021. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2023.111234

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。