高危患者局灶性肝脏肿块的概要式报告:算法诊断与CEUS LI-RADS
该研究提出一种整合算法解读与CEUS LI-RADS分类的概要式报告(SR)软件工作表。第一部分20名不同经验参与者对10例未知肝脏肿块判读,初级通过率81.6%、高级83.3%,无差异。第二部分91例SR与56例PR比较,完整性SR 98.4% vs PR 87.0%,平均完成时间SR 11分钟 vs PR 20分钟,多数用户偏好SR。
要点
- SR工作表可自动生成LI-RADS分类,初级与高级医师判读通过率无差异。
- SR报告完整性98.4%高于PR的87.0%,平均完成时间11分钟短于PR的20分钟。
- 超声技师、转诊医师及6/7放射科医师偏好SR,主要因省时、一致性和完整性。
核心结论
- SR是临床实践中报告超声肝脏肿块并赋予适当LI-RADS分类和管理路径的可靠有用工具,最终改善与转诊临床医生的沟通并带来更好的患者结局。
研究设计与样本
- 第一部分为可行性研究,20名不同经验参与者接受SR、算法解读和CEUS LI-RADS分类简短讲座后判读10例代表性未知肝脏肿块;第二部分为前瞻性分析,91例患者用SR、56例用PR,评估完整性、效率和用户满意度;软件为Kailo Medical(墨尔本,澳大利亚)工作表。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 第一部分判读结果以「正确」或「不正确」分类,初级参与者通过率81.6%,高级参与者通过率83.3%,两者表现无差异。
- 第二部分完整性:SR 98.4% vs PR 87.0%。
- 第二部分效率:平均完成总时间SR 11分钟 vs PR 20分钟。
- 第二部分用户满意度:超声技师、所有转诊医师和七名放射科医师中的六名偏好SR而非PR。
临床应用与阅片要点
- SR工作表整合CEUS肝脏解读算法和CEUS LI-RADS分类,结果和LI-RADS分类仅由SR生成。
- 用户 cited 的主要获益为节省总时间、文档一致性和准确性以及报告完整性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Reporting contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) for focal liver masses in at risk patients is a challenging task. Traditionally used prose reporting (PR) is inconsistent and lacks standardization. We propose synoptic reporting (SR), encompassing algorithmic interpretation and liver imaging and reporting data system (LI-RADS) categorization.
METHODS: A software worksheet from Kailo Medical (Melbourne, AU), incorporates the CEUS algorithm for liver interpretation and CEUS LI-RADS categorization. Part 1. Feasibility of SR: twenty participants of varying experience were presented a brief lecture on SR, algorithmic approach to liver mass interpretation, and CEUS LI-RADS categorization. Ten representative liver masses were shown as unknown cases. Participants inputted data into SR worksheets. Results and LI-RADS category were generated solely by SR. Data were categorized as "correct" or "incorrect." Part 2. Prospective Analysis: Ninety-one patients for SR and 56 for PR, all were tested for completeness, efficiency, and user satisfaction.
RESULTS: Part 1: Junior participants, pass rate 81.6%, and senior participants, pass rate 83.3% showed no difference in performance. Part 2: Completeness: SR 98.4% and PR 87.0%. Efficiency: Average total time to completion: SR 11 minutes and PR 20 minutes. User satisfaction: Ultrasound technologists, all referring physicians, and six out of seven radiologists preferred SR over PR. Major benefits cited were total time saved, consistency and accuracy in documentation, and report completeness.
CONCLUSIONS: SR is a reliable and useful tool in clinical practice to report liver masses on ultrasound and assign an appropriate LI-RADS categorization and management pathway. This ultimately improves communication with referring clinicians and leads to better patient outcomes.
引用
- Lu F, Samuel A, Merrill C, et al. Synoptic Reporting of Focal Liver Masses in at Risk Patients: Algorithmic Diagnosis and CEUS LI-RADS. J Ultrasound Med. 2023. PMID: 38088445. doi:10.1002/jum.16389
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。