ChatGPT在放射科患者沟通中的应用:常见影像问题回答的准确性与可读性评估
本研究评估ChatGPT回答患者常见影像相关问题的准确性、相关性和可读性,并检验简单提示语的效果。22个问题经4名放射科医师和2名患者倡导者评估,共264个回答。
要点
- ChatGPT回答影像问题的准确率约83%-87%,仍有错误风险,需医师审核。
- 简单提示可提高回答一致性和完全相关性,但不改善可读性。
- 回答可读性平均在13年级水平,远高于患者材料推荐的八年级。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To assess ChatGPT's accuracy, relevance, and readability in answering patients' common imaging-related questions and examine the effect of a simple prompt.
METHODS: A total of 22 imaging-related questions were developed from categories previously described as important to patients, as follows: safety, the radiology report, the procedure, preparation before imaging, meaning of terms, and medical staff. These questions were posed to ChatGPT with and without a short prompt instructing the model to provide an accurate and easy-to-understand response for the average person. Four board-certified radiologists evaluated the answers for accuracy, consistency, and relevance. Two patient advocates also reviewed responses for their utility for patients. Readability was assessed using the Flesch Kincaid Grade Level. Statistical comparisons were performed using χ2 and paired t tests.
RESULTS: A total of 264 answers were assessed for both unprompted and prompted questions. Unprompted responses were accurate 83% of the time (218 of 264), which did not significantly change for prompted responses (87% [229 of 264]; P = .2). The consistency of the responses increased from 72% (63 of 88) to 86% (76 of 88) when prompts were given (P = .02). Nearly all responses (99% [261 of 264]) were at least partially relevant for both question types. Fewer unprompted responses were considered fully relevant at 67% (176 of 264), although this increased significantly to 80% when prompts were given (210 of 264; P = .001). The average Flesch Kincaid Grade Level was high at 13.6 [CI, 12.9-14.2], unchanged with the prompt (13.0 [CI, 12.41-13.60], P = .2). None of the responses reached the eighth-grade readability level recommended for patient-facing materials.
DISCUSSION: ChatGPT demonstrates the potential to respond accurately, consistently, and relevantly to patients' imaging-related questions. However, imperfect accuracy and high complexity necessitate oversight before implementation. Prompts reduced response variability and yielded more-targeted information, but they did not improve readability. ChatGPT has the potential to increase accessibility to health information and streamline the production of patient-facing educational materials; however, its current limitations require cautious implementation and further research.
引用
- Gordon EB, Towbin AJ, Wingrove P, et al. Enhancing Patient Communication With Chat-GPT in Radiology: Evaluating the Efficacy and Readability of Answers to Common Imaging-Related Questions. J Am Coll Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37863153. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2023.09.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。