医学生为何选择放射科:一项关于动机与放射学争议问题的当前纵向调查
该研究对同一医学院校2011年首届毕业以来所有匹配进入放射科住院医师培训的57名校友进行问卷调查,43人回复(回复率75%)。结果显示放射科选修课是激发兴趣的最主要因素(25/43,58%),2023年或之后完成培训者比之前完成者更易受导师影响(65% vs 25%,p=0.04);受访者对AI负面影响职业的担忧为1.6/5,对疫情期间操作患者的担忧为1.7/5,预测远程阅片对生活方式的积极影响为3.2/5,主治放射科医师工作满意度为4.3/5。
要点
- 放射科选修课是激发学生对放射学兴趣的最主要因素(25/43,58%)。
- 2023年或之后完成放射科培训者比之前完成者更易受导师影响(65% vs 25%,p=0.04)。
- 受访者对AI负面影响职业的担忧为1.6/5,对疫情期间操作患者的担忧为1.7/5。
核心结论
- 放射科选修课对激发学生兴趣影响最大,导师影响日益增加;AI被认为对放射科医生工作的负面威胁相对较小;受访者对疫情期间操作担忧少;远程阅片对生活方式有中等积极影响;放射科医生工作满意度显著高。
研究设计与样本
- 对同一医学院校自2011年首届毕业以来所有匹配进入诊断或介入放射科住院医师培训的校友(n=57)进行问卷调查,使用Wilcoxon秩和检验和Fisher精确检验确定统计学显著性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 放射科选修课是最主要激发兴趣因素:25/43(58%)。
- 2023年或之后完成培训者受导师影响15/23(65%),2023年之前完成者5/20(25%)(p=0.04)。
- 受访者对AI负面影响未来放射科职业的担忧评分1.6/5。
- 受访者对COVID-19疫情期间对患者进行放射科操作的担忧评分1.7/5。
- 受访者预测远程阅片对帮助实现偏好生活方式的积极影响评分3.2/5;主治放射科医师工作满意度评分4.3/5。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Radiology is an increasingly competitive specialty. Various current factors influence medical students' decision to pursue a radiology career, including artificial intelligence (AI), remote reading, and COVID-19. This study seeks to determine the decision-making factors of all alumni from our medical school who matched into a radiology residency, and to gather opinions on emerging radiology topics.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A survey querying decision-making factors and opinions on current radiology topics was distributed to all alumni from our medical school (first graduating class in 2011) who previously matched into a diagnostic or interventional radiology residency program (n = 57). Wilcoxon Rank-Sum and Fisher's Exact tests were used to determine statistical significance.
RESULTS: Forty-three of fifty-seven responses were received (75% response rate). The most influential factor that sparked respondents' interest in radiology was a radiology elective (25/43, 58%). Students who will finish radiology training in 2023 or later were more likely to be influenced by a mentor (15/23, 65%) than those who finished radiology training before 2023 (5/20, 25%) (p = 0.04). Respondents reported a 1.6/5 concern about AI negatively impacting their future career in radiology. There was 1.7/5 concern about performing radiology procedures on patients during the COVID-19 pandemic. Respondents predicted that remote reading would have a 3.2/5 positive impact on helping them achieve their preferred lifestyle. Job satisfaction among attending radiologists is rated at 4.3/5.
CONCLUSION: Radiology electives had the greatest influence in piquing students' interest in radiology, while mentorship is assuming increasing influence. AI is perceived as a relatively minimal threat to negatively impact radiologists' jobs. Respondents had little concern about performing radiology procedures during the COVID-19 pandemic. Remote reading is viewed as having a moderately positive impact on lifestyle. Responding radiologists enjoy notably high job satisfaction.
引用
- Neitzel E, vanSonnenberg E, Lynch K, et al. Why Medical Students Pursue Radiology: A Current Longitudinal Survey on Motivations and Controversial Issues in Radiology. Acad Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37852816. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2023.09.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。