修订1994年世界卫生组织骨质疏松症T值定义以适用于东亚老年女性和男性,使其与终生脆性骨折风险相协调
1994年WHO的T值≤-2.5标准基于白人女性骨折风险制定,东亚人风险较低,直接套用会高估骨质疏松患病率。作者通过统计建模和以影像学椎体骨折为替代终点,初步建议香港华人女性股骨颈、全髋和脊柱T值切点约为-2.7、-2.6和-3.7,男性约为-2.7、-2.6和-3.2,并给出了中日人群的等效切点。
要点
- 东亚人群直接套用WHO T值≤-2.5标准会高估骨质疏松患病率,脊柱尤甚。
- 初步建议香港华人女性股骨颈、全髋、脊柱T值切点约为-2.7、-2.6、-3.7。
- 初步建议香港华人男性股骨颈、全髋、脊柱T值切点约为-2.7、-2.6、-3.2。
核心结论
- 东亚人群需采用本地骨密度参考值修订骨质疏松T值切点,以使患病率与终生脆性骨折风险相匹配,并利于国际间疾病负担比较。
研究设计与样本
- 基于统计建模和以影像学骨质疏松性椎体骨折为替代临床终点的经验性分析,比较华人女性与意大利女性、华人男性与意大利女性的等效T值切点。
关键影像表现/征象
- 以影像学骨质疏松性椎体骨折为替代终点,华人女性股骨颈T值-2.77相当于意大利女性-2.60。
- 华人女性脊柱T值-3.75相当于意大利女性-2.44。
- 华人男性股骨颈T值-2.77对应脊柱T值-3.37。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 采用本地骨密度参考时,初步建议香港华人女性股骨颈、全髋、脊柱T值切点约为-2.7、-2.6、-3.7。
- 初步建议香港华人男性股骨颈、全髋、脊柱T值切点约为-2.7、-2.6、-3.2。
- 应用IKi等发表的骨密度参考值时,日本女性股骨颈、全髋、脊柱T值-2.75、-3.0、-3.9更符合WHO骨质疏松定义。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对东亚老年人群判读骨密度T值时,应考虑采用本地参考值对应的修订切点,而非直接套用-2.5。
- 脊柱T值切点低于股骨颈和全髋,提示脊柱部位尤其容易因传统标准而高估骨质疏松。
- 作者初步建议的切点值可供阅片和报告时参考,但属暂定推荐。
局限性
- 原文称切点值为tentatively recommend(初步建议)。
- 原文称修订定义将使疾病负担的国际比较更有意义,但未报告前瞻性验证。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
The 1994 WHO criterion of a T-score ≤ -2.5 for densitometric osteoporosis was chosen because it results in a prevalence commensurate with the observed lifetime risk of fragility fractures in Caucasian women aged ≥ 50 years. Due to the much lower risk of fragility fracture among East Asians, the application of the conventional WHO criterion to East Asians leads to an over inflated prevalence of osteoporosis, particularly for spine osteoporosis. According to statistical modeling and when a local BMD reference is used, we tentatively recommend the cutpoint values for T-score of femoral neck, total hip, and spine to be approximately -2.7, -2.6, and -3.7 for Hong Kong Chinese women. Using radiographic osteoporotic vertebral fracture as a surrogate clinical endpoint, we empirically demonstrated that a femoral neck T-score of -2.77 for Chinese women was equivalent to -2.60 for Italian women, a spine T-score of -3.75 for Chinese women was equivalent to -2.44 for Italian women, and for Chinese men a femoral neck T-score of -2.77 corresponded to spine T-score of -3.37. For older Chinese men, we tentatively recommend the cutpoint values for T-score of femoral neck, total hip, and spine to be approximately -2.7, -2.6, and -3.2. With the BMD reference published by IKi et al. applied, T-score of femoral neck, total hip, and spine of -2.75, -3.0, and -3.9 for Japanese women will be more in line with the WHO osteoporosis definition. The revised definition of osteoporosis cutpoint T-scores for East Asians will allow a more meaningful international comparison of disease burden.
引用
- Wáng YXJ, Griffith JF, Blake GM, et al. Revision of the 1994 World Health Organization T-score definition of osteoporosis for use in older East Asian women and men to reconcile it with their lifetime risk of fragility fracture. Skeletal Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37889317. doi:10.1007/s00256-023-04481-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。