优化双读筛查乳腺X线摄影的放射科医师配对
本研究基于瑞典(2008-2015)、英格兰(2012-2014)和挪威(2004-2018)乳腺筛查项目的阅读结果,回顾性分析放射科医师按召回率与癌症检出率特征配对是否能提高双读筛查的准确性。结果显示,基于不同配对策略的特定配对与随机配对相比,筛查性能无显著差异。
要点
- 基于放射科医师召回率与癌症检出率特征的特定配对策略与随机配对相比,筛查性能无显著差异。
- 研究纳入3 592 414次检查,三个国家筛查项目的总体召回率与癌症检出率范围与随机配对接近。
- 日常双读筛查中,按医师表现特征优化配对似乎并未显著改变筛查准确性。
核心结论
- 基于不同配对策略的放射科医师配对与随机配对相比,筛查性能无显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,分析瑞典(2008-2015)、英格兰(2012-2014)和挪威(2004-2018)乳腺筛查项目的阅读结果,最终样本3 592 414次检查(瑞典965 263次、英格兰837 048次、挪威1 790 103次),以癌症检出率和异常解读率为指标,将个体阅读者按高/低癌症检出率和异常解读率分为表现类别,比较随机配对与特定配对策略(召回率和/或癌症检出率相反或相似的配对)的性能。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 异常解读率定义为任一阅读者将检查标记为异常;特定配对策略的异常解读率与癌症检出率范围:瑞典异常解读率45.5-56.9/1000次检查、癌症检出率3.1-3.6/1000,英格兰异常解读率68.2-70.5/1000、癌症检出率8.9-9.4/1000,挪威异常解读率81.6-88.1/1000、癌症检出率6.1-6.8/1000;随机配对:瑞典异常解读率54.1/1000、癌症检出率3.3/1000,英格兰异常解读率69.3/1000、癌症检出率9.1/1000,挪威异常解读率84.1/1000、癌症检出率6.3/1000。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background Despite variation in performance characteristics among radiologists, the pairing of radiologists for the double reading of screening mammograms is performed randomly. It is unknown how to optimize pairing to improve screening performance. Purpose To investigate whether radiologist performance characteristics can be used to determine the optimal set of pairs of radiologists to double read screening mammograms for improved accuracy. Materials and Methods This retrospective study was performed with reading outcomes from breast cancer screening programs in Sweden (2008-2015), England (2012-2014), and Norway (2004-2018). Cancer detection rates (CDRs) and abnormal interpretation rates (AIRs) were calculated, with AIR defined as either reader flagging an examination as abnormal. Individual readers were divided into performance categories based on their high and low CDR and AIR. The performance of individuals determined the classification of pairs. Random pair performance, for which any type of pair was equally represented, was compared with the performance of specific pairing strategies, which consisted of pairs of readers who were either opposite or similar in AIR and/or CDR. Results Based on a minimum number of examinations per reader and per pair, the final study sample consisted of 3 592 414 examinations (Sweden, n = 965 263; England, n = 837 048; Norway, n = 1 790 103). The overall AIRs and CDRs for all specific pairing strategies (Sweden AIR range, 45.5-56.9 per 1000 examinations and CDR range, 3.1-3.6 per 1000; England AIR range, 68.2-70.5 per 1000 and CDR range, 8.9-9.4 per 1000; Norway AIR range, 81.6-88.1 per 1000 and CDR range, 6.1-6.8 per 1000) were not significantly different from the random pairing strategy (Sweden AIR, 54.1 per 1000 examinations and CDR, 3.3 per 1000; England AIR, 69.3 per 1000 and CDR, 9.1 per 1000; Norway AIR, 84.1 per 1000 and CDR, 6.3 per 1000). Conclusion Pairing a set of readers based on different pairing strategies did not show a significant difference in screening performance when compared with random pairing. © RSNA, 2023.
引用
- Gommers JJJ, Abbey CK, Strand F, et al. Optimizing the Pairs of Radiologists That Double Read Screening Mammograms. Radiology. 2023. PMID: 37874241. doi:10.1148/radiol.222691
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。