基于物理信息的离散化方法用于定量MRI可重复且稳健的影像组学特征提取
研究提出物理信息离散化(PID)方法用于定量MRI影像组学特征提取,并在5名健康受试者的多扫描仪扫描-重扫描数据集中评估。结果显示PID较传统固定箱数(FBN)离散化使MRF T1和T2的GLCM纹理特征可重复性显著更高,且对分割误差更稳健;定量MRI序列的纹理特征优秀可重复性比例总体高于加权MRI。
要点
- PID离散化使MRF T1和T2的GLCM纹理特征可重复性显著高于FBN离散化。
- 全部定量MRI序列中PID获得最多ICC>0.9的优秀可重复纹理特征。
- MRF T1纹理特征61%达ICC>0.9,高于T1w MPRAGE的40%、ADC的32%、T2w SPACE的27%和FLAIR的28%。
核心结论
- PID方法从定量MRI序列提取的影像组学特征较传统FBN离散化从加权MRI提取的特征更可重复、更稳健;定量MRI序列的扫描-重扫描稳健性和一阶特征可重复性也高于加权MRI。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性多扫描仪扫描-重扫描研究,纳入5名健康受试者,每人在3台不同3T扫描仪上各重复采集2次,共每人6次扫描(总计30次扫描),获取全脑3D定量MRI(MRF T1、MRF T2、ADC)和加权MRI(T1w MPRAGE、T2w SPACE、T2w FLAIR),从56个脑组织感兴趣区提取23个一阶统计特征和74个二阶纹理特征。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 使用组内相关系数(ICC)评估扫描仪间可重复性,ICC>0.75判定为对模拟分割稳健,ICC>0.9判定为优秀可重复性;PID用于定量MRI,FBN用于定量MRI和加权MRI;采用重复测量方差分析评估图像序列和离散化方法对可重复性的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Given the limited repeatability and reproducibility of radiomic features derived from weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), there may be significant advantages to using radiomics in conjunction with quantitative MRI. This study introduces a novel physics-informed discretization (PID) method for reproducible radiomic feature extraction and evaluates its performance using quantitative MRI sequences including magnetic resonance fingerprinting (MRF) and apparent diffusion coefficient (ADC) mapping.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A multiscanner, scan-rescan dataset comprising whole-brain 3D quantitative (MRF T1, MRF T2, and ADC) and weighted MRI (T1w MPRAGE, T2w SPACE, and T2w FLAIR) from 5 healthy subjects was prospectively acquired. Subjects underwent 2 repeated acquisitions on 3 distinct 3 T scanners each, for a total of 6 scans per subject (30 total scans). First-order statistical (n = 23) and second-order texture (n = 74) radiomic features were extracted from 56 brain tissue regions of interest using the proposed PID method (for quantitative MRI) and conventional fixed bin number (FBN) discretization (for quantitative MRI and weighted MRI). Interscanner radiomic feature reproducibility was measured using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), and the effect of image sequence (eg, MRF T1 vs T1w MPRAGE), as well as image discretization method (ie, PID vs FBN), on radiomic feature reproducibility was assessed using repeated measures analysis of variance. The robustness of PID and FBN discretization to segmentation error was evaluated by simulating segmentation differences in brainstem regions of interest. Radiomic features with ICCs greater than 0.75 following simulated segmentation were determined to be robust to segmentation.
RESULTS: First-order features demonstrated higher reproducibility in quantitative MRI than weighted MRI sequences, with 30% (n = 7/23) features being more reproducible in MRF T1 and MRF T2 than weighted MRI. Gray level co-occurrence matrix (GLCM) texture features extracted from MRF T1 and MRF T2 were significantly more reproducible using PID compared with FBN discretization; for all quantitative MRI sequences, PID yielded the highest number of texture features with excellent reproducibility (ICC > 0.9). Comparing texture reproducibility of quantitative and weighted MRI, a greater proportion of MRF T1 (n = 225/370, 61%) and MRF T2 (n = 150/370, 41%) texture features had excellent reproducibility (ICC > 0.9) compared with T1w MPRAGE (n = 148/370, 40%), ADC (n = 115/370, 32%), T2w SPACE (n = 98/370, 27%), and FLAIR (n = 102/370, 28%). Physics-informed discretization was also more robust than FBN discretization to segmentation error, as 46% (n = 103/222, 46%) of texture features extracted from quantitative MRI using PID were robust to simulated 6 mm segmentation shift compared with 19% (n = 42/222, 19%) of weighted MRI texture features extracted using FBN discretization.
CONCLUSIONS: The proposed PID method yields radiomic features extracted from quantitative MRI sequences that are more reproducible and robust than radiomic features extracted from weighted MRI using conventional (FBN) discretization approaches. Quantitative MRI sequences also demonstrated greater scan-rescan robustness and first-order feature reproducibility than weighted MRI.
引用
- Zhao W, Hu Z, Kazerooni AF, et al. Physics-Informed Discretization for Reproducible and Robust Radiomic Feature Extraction Using Quantitative MRI. Invest Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37812483. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000001026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。