英国乳腺癌筛查中是否应告知乳腺密度信息:一项整合性综述
该整合性综述检索PubMed、Cochrane图书馆和灰色文献,纳入19项研究(含3项随机对照试验、3项队列研究、9项横断面研究等),按五个研究问题叙述性综合。总体GRADE证据质量评级为极低至低。参与者普遍希望获得乳腺密度信息,与医疗专业人员的对话比信件更受重视和有效;告知后乳腺密度认知在各研究间差异很大;乳腺密度信息未影响乳腺X线摄影筛查频率,或增加了参与者回院进行常规筛查以及获取和接受补充筛查的意愿;少数族裔或社会经济地位较低者告知后更困惑,且与无医疗保险者一样更不可能接受补充筛查。作者结论为英国在考虑筛查时分享乳腺密度信息前需开展涵盖不同社区的英国本土研究。
要点
- 参与者普遍希望获得乳腺密度信息,与医疗专业人员的对话比信件更受重视和有效。
- 告知后乳腺密度认知在各研究间差异很大。
- 少数族裔或社会经济地位较低者告知后更困惑,且与无医疗保险者一样更不可能接受补充筛查。
核心结论
- 英国在考虑于筛查时分享乳腺密度信息前,需开展涵盖不同社区的英国本土研究;目前分享该信息可能对参与者无益,并可能扩大不平等。
研究设计与样本
- 整合性综述,检索PubMed、Cochrane图书馆和灰色文献(2022年10月),两名评价者提取数据并评估偏倚风险;纳入19项研究:3项随机对照试验、3项队列研究、9项横断面研究、1项定性访谈研究、1项混合方法研究和2项2021年系统综述;总体GRADE证据质量评级为极低至低。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 参与者普遍希望获得乳腺密度信息,与医疗专业人员的对话比信件更受重视和有效。
- 乳腺密度信息未影响乳腺X线摄影筛查频率,或增加了参与者回院进行常规筛查以及获取和接受补充筛查的意愿。
- 少数族裔或社会经济地位较低者告知后更困惑,且与无医疗保险者一样更不可能接受补充筛查。
局限性
- 总体GRADE证据质量评级为极低至低。
- 乳腺密度认知在各研究间差异很大。
- 英国本土研究有限:19项研究中仅2项基于英国,另有1项系统综述纳入1项澳大利亚和1项加拿大研究。
- 作者结论指出英国在考虑分享乳腺密度信息前需开展涵盖不同社区的英国本土研究,实施和记录方面的实际问题也需解决。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Dense breasts are an established risk factor for breast cancer and also reduce the sensitivity of mammograms. There is increasing public concern around breast density in the UK, with calls for this information to be shared at breast cancer screening.
METHODS: We searched the PubMed database, Cochrane Library and grey literature, using broad search terms in October 2022. Two reviewers extracted data and assessed the risk of bias of each included study. The results were narratively synthesised by five research questions: desire for information, communication formats, psychological impact, knowledge impact and behaviour change.
RESULTS: We identified 19 studies: three Randomised Controlled Trials (RCTs), three cohort studies, nine cross-sectional studies, one qualitative interview study, one mixed methods study and two 2021 systematic reviews. Nine studies were based in the United States of America (USA), five in Australia, two in the UK and one in Croatia. One systematic review included 14 USA studies, and the other 27 USA studies, 1 Australian and 1 Canadian. The overall GRADE evidence quality rating for each research question was very low to low.Generally, participants wanted to receive breast density information. Conversations with healthcare professionals were more valued and effective than letters. Breast density awareness after notification varied greatly between studies.Breast density information either did not impact frequency of mammography screening or increased the intentions of participants to return for routine screening as well as intention to access, and uptake of, supplementary screening. People from ethnic minority groups or of lower socioeconomic status (SES) had greater confusion following notification, and, along with those without healthcare insurance, were less likely to access supplementary screening.
CONCLUSION: Breast density specific research in the UK, including different communities, is needed before the UK considers sharing breast density information at screening. There are also practical considerations around implementation and recording, which need to be addressed.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: Currently, sharing breast density information at breast cancer screening in the UK may not be beneficial to participants and could widen inequalities. UK specific research is needed, and measurement, communication and future testing implications need to be carefully considered.
引用
- Best R, Wilkinson LS, Oliver-Williams C, et al. Should we share breast density information during breast cancer screening in the United Kingdom? an integrative review. Br J Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37751169. doi:10.1259/bjr.20230122
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。