文献速递泌尿生殖MR

多中心环境下PI-QUAL评分的阅片者间变异性和可重复性

Inter-reader variability and reproducibility of the PI-QUAL score in a multicentre setting.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2023-09-09

本研究评估不同临床经验阅片者对前列腺MRI的PI-QUAL评分阅片者间可重复性及不同机构间图像质量评估的可重复性。三位阅片者对60例连续前列腺MRI独立评分,单条PI-QUAL评分一致性为中等,聚为PI-QUAL 1-3与4-5两组时一致性良好至很好,学术医院扫描的平均PI-QUAL评分显著高于社区医院。

要点

  • PI-QUAL单条评分阅片者间一致性为中等,聚为1-3与4-5两组时一致性良好至很好。
  • 经验丰富的放射科医生与经验丰富的MRI技术员之间一致性高于经验较少的受训放射科医生与其他两位阅片者。
  • 学术医院扫描的平均PI-QUAL评分显著高于社区医院扫描。

核心结论

  • 不同临床经验阅片者对每条MRI序列及将扫描聚为PI-QUAL 1-3与4-5两组时评估的可重复性为良好至很好,但每条单一PI-QUAL评分的阅片者间可重复性为中等;三位阅片者对学术教学医院扫描给出的平均PI-QUAL评分显著高于社区医院扫描。

研究设计与样本

  • 经IRB批准,评估上传至本机构PACS用于二次意见或病例讨论的60例连续前列腺MRI扫描,扫描来自不同的学术教学医院和非学术医院;由三位阅片者(分别有1年和12年前列腺MRI报告经验的两位放射科医生,以及一位对图像采集和质量有兴趣的经验丰富的MRI技术员)使用PI-QUAL评分表独立盲法阅片,阅片者对扫描采集地点设盲。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 将扫描按排除或确认临床显著前列腺癌的能力聚为两组(PI-QUAL评分1-3 vs PI-QUAL评分4-5)时,三位阅片者两两比较的Gwet AC1系数分别为0.77、0.67、0.836,一致率分别为88.3%、83.3%和91.7%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者认为,对每条PI-QUAL评分标准给出更好的定义可能进一步提高阅片者间的可重复性。

局限性

  • 作者认为,对每条PI-QUAL评分标准给出更好的定义可能进一步提高阅片者间的可重复性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: To assess the inter-reader reproducibility of the Prostate Imaging Quality (PI-QUAL) score between readers with varying clinical experience and its reproducibility at assessing imaging quality between different institutions.

METHODS: Following IRB approval, we assessed 60 consecutive prostate MRI scans performed at different academic teaching and non-academic hospitals uploaded to our institutes' PACS for second opinion or discussion in case conferences. Anonymized scans were independently reviewed using the PI-QUAL scoring sheet by three readers - two radiologists (with 1 and 12 years Prostate MRI reporting experience), and an experienced MRI technician with interest in image acquisition and quality. All readers were blinded to the site where scans were acquired.

RESULTS: Agreement coefficients between the 3 readers in paired comparison for each individual PI-QUAL score was moderate. When the scans were clustered into 2 groups according to their ability to rule in or rule out clinically significant prostate cancer [i.e., PI-QUAL score 1-3 vs PI-QUAL score 4-5], the Gwet AC1 coefficients between the three readers in paired comparison was good to very good [Gwet AC 1:0.77, 0.67, 0.836 respectively] with agreement percentage of 88.3%, 83.3% and 91.7% respectively. Agreement coefficient was higher between the experienced radiologist and the experienced MRI technician than between the less experienced trainee radiologist and the other two readers. The mean PI-QUAL score provided by each reader for the scans was significantly higher in the academic hospitals (n = 32) compared to the community hospital (n = 28) [experienced radiologist 4.6 vs 2.9; trainee radiologist 4.5 vs 2.4; experienced technologist 4.4 vs 2.4; p value < 0.001].

CONCLUSION: We observed good to very good reproducibility in the assessment of each MRI sequence and when scans were clustered into two groups [PI-QUAL 1-3 vs PI-QUAL 4-5] between readers with varying clinical experience. However, the reproducibility for each single PI-QUAL score between readers was moderate. Better definitions for each PI-QUAL score criteria may further improve reproducibility between readers. Additionally, the mean PI-QUAL score provided by all three readers was significantly higher for scans performed at academic teaching hospitals compared to community hospital.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fleming H, Dias AB, Talbot N, et al. Inter-reader variability and reproducibility of the PI-QUAL score in a multicentre setting. Eur J Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37717419. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2023.111091

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。