用于放疗治疗计划的能量无关CT重建算法评估
本研究在体模和四个解剖部位回顾性患者CT数据上评估DirectDensity算法,覆盖70至140 kVp全部管电压,与常规120 kVp标准重建比较。体模最大放疗剂量差异为0.73%,患者计划平均PTV剂量差异在-0.2%至-0.4%之间,但发现110 kVp下DD重建图像骨性插入物HU异常降低约34 HU,作者认为需进一步研究。
要点
- DD算法在全部kVp下与常规120 kVp标准重建的放疗剂量差异很小,体模最大差异0.73%。
- 患者计划平均PTV剂量差异为D99% -0.2%、D50% -0.4%、D2% -0.3%。
- 110 kVp下DD重建图像骨性插入物HU较预期降低约34 HU,标准Qr40重建未见此现象。
核心结论
- DD对放疗剂量计算影响极小,可整合入现有临床工作流程;但110 kVp下DD图像的HU值需关注,作者认为需进一步研究。
研究设计与样本
- 在SOMATOM go.Open Pro CT上使用CIRS Model 002LFC IMRT Thorax Phantom于全部可用kVp下成像,比较DD与常规120 kVp标准重建;并对四个解剖部位(骨盆、胸部、脑、头颈)各5例回顾性患者CT数据行VMAT计划剂量学比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 体模放疗剂量最大差异为0.73%(Qr40 120 kVp vs DD全部kVp);患者计划平均PTV剂量差异为D99% -0.2%(s.d. 0.7)、D50% -0.4%(s.d. 0.4%)、D2% -0.3%(s.d. 0.4%);DD重建图像在110 kVp下骨性插入物HU降低约34 HU(皮质骨),标准Qr40重建未见此现象。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者结论认为DD对放疗剂量计算影响极小,可整合入现有临床工作流程;作者同时指出应关注110 kVp下DD图像的HU值,并认为需进一步研究。
局限性
- 作者指出110 kVp下DD算法图像的HU值异常 warrants further investigation(需进一步研究)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Radiotherapy treatment planning relies upon density information provided by CT for accurate dose calculations. Hounsfield units (HUs) are converted to electron/physical density via an energy dependant calibration curve. Multiple curves are required to make full use of the available accelerating potentials (kVp). The curves are bi-linear with a discontinuity occurring at soft-tissue densities. The commercial algorithm, DirectDensityTM (Siemens Healthcare GmbH), constructs a single calibration curve covering all available kVp. This enables the optimisation of the CT image quality, e.g. in terms of contrast, or the reduction of the imaging dose, whilst rendering the radiotherapy treatment dose calculation robust to the energy used to acquire the CT image. We report our investigations on the clinical utilisation of the DirectDensityTM algorithm for radiotherapy treatments, by using all accelerating potentials, i.e. from 70 kVp up to 140 kVp, available at our CT treatment simulator, in contrast to previous studies that were limited to accelerating potentials spanning a subset of the available kVp.
METHODS: The DirectDensityTM (DD) reconstruction algorithm available on a SOMATOM go.Open Pro CT scanner (Siemens Healthineers) was evaluated using the RayStation v. 9 treatment planning system (RaySearch Laboratories, Stockholm, Sweden) and a CIRS Model 002LFC IMRT Thorax Phantom (SunNuclear, Melbourne, FL), which was imaged at all available kVp with clinical protocols corresponding to various anatomical sites. The DD images were compared to those with the standard reconstruction algorithm acquired only at 120 kVp, as per our routine clinical practice. The effect of increasing kVp on HU is investigated for relevant tissue substitutes. In addition, a dosimetric comparison is performed for a VMAT plan technique with 6 MV X-rays using retrospective patient CT data sets representing four anatomical sites (pelvis, thorax, brain and "head and neck") with five patients for each site. The original dose distributions were calculated on images acquired at 120 kVp using the standard clinical iterative reconstruction (Qr40) and compared with dose distributions recalculated on images reconstructed with the new DD (Sm40) algorithm.
RESULTS: The maximum difference for radiotherapy doses calculated using images of the phantom reconstructed with Qr40 (120 kVp) or DD (all available kVp) was 0.73%. The patient plans on the anatomically representative sites studied here showed a mean PTV dose difference of -0.2% (s.d. 0.7) for D99%, -0.4% (s.d. 0.4%) for D50% and -0.3% (s.d. 0.4%) for D2%. Incidentally, we found a previously unreported decrease in HU, mostly notable for bone type inserts (~34 HU (cortical bone)), at 110 kVp for the DD reconstructed images. The effect was not noted for the standard Qr40 reconstructions.
CONCLUSION: DD has a minimal dosimetric impact in the dose calculations for radiotherapy treatments and could be implemented with existing clinical workflows. Attention should be paid to the HU values for images acquired at 110 kVp (DD algorithm), which warrants further investigation.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: This is the first paper where DD was evaluated at all available kVp, leading to the incidental discovery of abnormal HU values at 110 kVp for this algorithm.
引用
- Tulip R, Manolopoulos S, Richmond N, et al. An evaluation of an energy independent CT reconstruction algorithm for use in radiotherapy treatment planning. Br J Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37751165. doi:10.1259/bjr.20230004
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。