针对性培训减少对比增强CT肝转移瘤检测中的搜索错误但未减少分类错误
单组前瞻性前后测试研究纳入31名放射科读者,在眼动追踪下判读40例含91个肝转移瘤的对比增强腹部CT。搜索培训后搜索错误从11%降至8%(差值3%,95%CI 0.3%-5.1%,P=0.01),但分类错误无差异(差值0%,P=0.97),JAFROC品质因数无差异(差值-0.01,P=0.36)。
要点
- 搜索培训可减少肝转移瘤搜索错误(11%降至8%,P=0.01),但分类错误无改善。
- 整体诊断效能JAFROC品质因数无显著变化(差值-0.01,P=0.36)。
- 腹部亚专科医师亚组分析未显示变化证据,改善并非见于所有亚组。
核心结论
- 针对性培训减少了对比增强腹部CT肝转移瘤检测中的搜索错误,但未减少分类错误,且改善并非见于所有亚组。
研究设计与样本
- 单组前瞻性前后测试研究,经机构审查委员会批准,31名放射科读者(8名腹部亚专科医师、8名非腹部亚专科医师、15名高年资住院医师/ fellows)参与。
关键影像表现/征象
- 判读40例含91个肝转移瘤的对比增强腹部CT,采用眼动追踪区分搜索错误(注视<2秒)与分类错误(注视>2秒)。
- 搜索培训包括眼动追踪反馈和辅导,以增加判读时间、使用肝窗和冠状位重建。
- 分类培训包括部分任务练习,将病灶评为良性或恶性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 搜索错误定义为眼动追踪下注视时间<2秒的漏诊转移瘤;分类错误定义为注视时间>2秒。
- 搜索错误:前测11% vs 后测8%,差值3%(95%CI 0.3%-5.1%),P=0.01。
- 分类错误:差值0%,P=0.97;JAFROC品质因数:差值-0.01,P=0.36。
局限性
- 单组前瞻性前后测试研究,未设对照组。
- 腹部亚专科医师亚组分析未显示变化证据,改善并非见于所有亚组。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Methods are needed to improve the detection of hepatic metastases. Errors occur in both lesion detection (search) and decisions of benign versus malignant (classification). Our purpose was to evaluate a training program to reduce search errors and classification errors in the detection of hepatic metastases in contrast-enhanced abdominal computed tomography (CT).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: After Institutional Review Board approval, we conducted a single-group prospective pretest-posttest study. Pretest and posttest were identical and consisted of interpreting 40 contrast-enhanced abdominal CT exams containing 91 liver metastases under eye tracking. Between pretest and posttest, readers completed search training with eye-tracker feedback and coaching to increase interpretation time, use liver windows, and use coronal reformations. They also completed classification training with part-task practice, rating lesions as benign or malignant. The primary outcome was metastases missed due to search errors (<2 seconds gaze under eye tracker) and classification errors (>2 seconds). Jackknife free-response receiver operator characteristic (JAFROC) analysis was also conducted.
RESULTS: A total of 31 radiologist readers (8 abdominal subspecialists, 8 nonabdominal subspecialists, 15 senior residents/fellows) participated. Search errors were reduced (pretest 11%, posttest 8%, difference 3% [95% confidence interval, 0.3%-5.1%], P = .01), but there was no difference in classification errors (difference 0%, P = .97) or in JAFROC figure of merit (difference -0.01, P = .36). In subgroup analysis, abdominal subspecialists demonstrated no evidence of change.
CONCLUSION: Targeted training reduced search errors but not classification errors for the detection of hepatic metastases at contrast-enhanced abdominal CT. Improvements were not seen in all subgroups.
引用
- Hsieh SS, Inoue A, Yalon M, et al. Targeted Training Reduces Search Errors but Not Classification Errors for Hepatic Metastasis Detection at Contrast-Enhanced CT. Acad Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37567818. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2023.06.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。