产前超声联合死后胎儿MRI能否替代常规尸检诊断胎儿躯体异常
回顾性纳入50例胎儿,比较产前超声(US)与死后MRI(PMMRI)单独及联合诊断非神经性躯体异常与常规尸检(CA)的差异。CA、US、PMMRI评分分别为53、37、46分;US联合PMMRI诊断主要躯体异常的敏感度90%、特异度94%,CA仅额外发现2例(4%)主要异常和7例(14%)次要异常,但2例(2/6)心脏畸形仅由CA描述。结论:联合检查后CA额外发现少,但胎儿心脏尸检仍为必需。
要点
- 产前US联合PMMRI诊断主要胎儿躯体异常的敏感度为90%、特异度为94%。
- CA在US-PMMRI基础上仅额外发现2例(4%)主要异常和7例(14%)次要异常。
- 2例(2/6)心脏畸形仅由CA描述,胎儿心脏尸检仍为必需。
核心结论
- 产前US联合PMMRI后,CA仅额外发现少量胎儿躯体畸形,但胎儿心脏尸检仍为必需。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性IRB批准研究,纳入6年期间所有接受PMMRI、产前US和全身CA的胎儿50例,以CA为参考标准。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 异常按主要(2分)或次要(1分)分级,各技术评分为所有分级分值之和,CA、US、PMMRI分别为53、37、46分。
- 单独US与PMMRI检测主要躯体畸形的敏感度分别为80%与80%,特异度分别为100%与94%。
- US联合PMMRI检测主要躯体畸形的敏感度为90%、特异度为94%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,在充分产前US和PMMRI后,限于胎儿心脏的CA可能替代全身CA。
- 作者指出胎儿心脏尸检仍为必需。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The acceptance of conventional autopsy (CA), the gold standard method for investigating fetal death, often remains problematic. Post-mortem magnetic resonance imaging (PMMRI) is increasingly advocated, particularly for neurologic malformations. However, PMMRI performances to diagnose non-neurologic malformations remain unclear. We aim to clarify whether a full body CA remains needed after prenatal ultrasound (US) and PMMRI in assessing non-neurologic fetal malformations.
METHODS: In this retrospective IRB-approved study, during a 6-year period, all fetuses who underwent PMMRI, prenatal US, and full body CA were included. Body abnormalities were identified in US, PMMRI, and CA reports. US and PMMRI images were all reviewed. All abnormalities were graded as major (2 points) or minor (1 point). Each technique (US, PMMRI, CA) was given a score by adding all grading points. In each fetus, results were compared for both separate and combined US and PMMRI to CA. Sensitivity and specificity were calculated for detecting major abnormalities.
RESULTS: Fifty fetuses were included. The score of CA, US, and PMMRI was respectively 53, 37, and 46. Compared with US-PMMRI, CA added information in 2 cases (4%) with major abnormalities and 7 cases (14%) with minor abnormalities. PMMRI and US were concordant in 36/50 (72%) fetuses. Separate US/PMMRI sensitivities and specificities for detecting major body malformations respectively were 80%/80% and 100%/94%. Combined US-PMMRI had a sensitivity of 90% and a specificity of 94%. Two cardiac malformations (2/6) were only described by CA.
CONCLUSIONS: After prenatal US and PMMRI, few additional fetal body malformations are discovered with CA. Nevertheless, fetal heart autopsy remains mandatory.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: A cardiac conventional autopsy complemented by prenatal ultrasound and post-mortem MRI allows to detect all major fetal body abnormalities. With this efficient and much less invasive approach, a higher acceptance rate of fetal autopsy can be expected.
KEY POINTS: • Excepting cardiac malformations, most major fetal body malformations can reliably be identified by prenatal US combined with post-mortem MRI. • In the post-mortem diagnosis of fetal body malformations, a conventional autopsy limited to the fetal heart might replace a full body autopsy after a well-conducted prenatal US and post-mortem MRI.
引用
- Moeremans M, Avni FE, d'Haene N, et al. Combined prenatal US and post-mortem fetal MRI: can they replace conventional autopsy for fetal body abnormalities? Eur Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37526669. doi:10.1007/s00330-023-09847-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。