光子计数CT超高清肺部成像对感知诊断图像质量的影响
本研究纳入50例患者,对比超高清光子计数CT(UHR-PCCT)与常规高分辨率能量积分探测器CT(HR-EIDCT)的临床图像质量及对诊断解读感知的影响。四位阅片者采用视觉分级分析(VGA)评分,结果显示UHR-PCCT对几乎所有肺结构(除磨玻璃结节外)的可见性显著更优,但感知到的诊断解读差异未能证实。
要点
- UHR-PCCT对中央及外周气道、肺血管、裂隙、磨玻璃影、大/微结节、小叶间隔及小叶内线、旁间隔及小叶中心型肺气肿、肺大疱/囊肿和空气潴留的可见性显著优于HR-EIDCT(p<0.025)。
- 磨玻璃结节(2/50例患者)的可见性差异无统计学意义(p=0.157)。
- 尽管可见性更优,但中位VGA评分与2(PCCT可见性更好且影响诊断解读)显著不同,未能证实对诊断解读的感知影响。
核心结论
- UHR-PCCT对中央及外周气道、肺血管、裂隙、磨玻璃影、大/微结节、小叶间隔及小叶内线、旁间隔及小叶中心型肺气肿、肺大疱/囊肿和空气潴留的可见性优于HR-EIDCT。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入50例在2021年11月至2022年2月期间接受UHR-PCCT(矩阵512×512、768×768或1024×1024;FOV平均275×376 mm,120×0.2 mm;焦点尺寸0.6×0.7 mm)且有既往HR-EIDCT(14个月内)的患者,四位阅片者采用5分诊断质量评分对PCCT(0.4 mm)和EIDCT(1 mm)进行侧对比参考评分。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 采用5分诊断质量评分进行视觉分级分析(VGA),中位VGA评分与假设中位值0(可见性相同)和2(PCCT可见性更好且影响诊断解读)比较,使用单样本Wilcoxon符号秩检验,显著性水平为2.5%。
局限性
- 尽管可见性更好,但未能证实对诊断解读的感知差异,因中位VGA评分与2显著不同。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare clinical image quality and perceived impact on diagnostic interpretation of chest CT findings between ultra-high-resolution photon-counting CT (UHR-PCCT) and conventional high-resolution energy-integrating-detector CT (HR-EIDCT) using visual grading analysis (VGA) scores.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Fifty patients who underwent a UHR-PCCT (matrix 512 × 512, 768 × 768, or 1024 × 1024; FOV average 275 × 376 mm, 120 × 0.2 mm; focal spot size 0.6 × 0.7 mm) between November 2021 and February 2022 and with a previous HR-EIDCT within the last 14 months were included. Four readers evaluated central and peripheral airways, lung vasculature, nodules, ground glass opacities, inter- and intralobular lines, emphysema, fissures, bullae/cysts, and air trapping on PCCT (0.4 mm) and conventional EIDCT (1 mm) via side-by-side reference scoring using a 5-point diagnostic quality score. The median VGA scores were compared and tested using one-sample Wilcoxon signed rank tests with hypothesized median values of 0 (same visibility) and 2 (better visibility on PCCT with impact on diagnostic interpretation) at a 2.5% significance level.
RESULTS: Almost all lung structures had significantly better visibility on PCCT compared to EIDCT (p < 0.025; exception for ground glass nodules (N = 2/50 patients, p = 0.157)), with the highest scores seen for peripheral airways, micronodules, inter- and intralobular lines, and centrilobular emphysema (mean VGA > 1). Although better visibility, a perceived difference in diagnostic interpretation could not be demonstrated, since the median VGA was significantly different from 2.
CONCLUSION: UHR-PCCT showed superior visibility compared to HR-EIDCT for central and peripheral airways, lung vasculature, fissures, ground glass opacities, macro- and micronodules, inter- and intralobular lines, paraseptal and centrilobular emphysema, bullae/cysts, and air trapping.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: UHR-PCCT has emerged as a promising technique for thoracic imaging, offering improved spatial resolution and lower radiation dose. Implementing PCCT into daily practice may allow better visibility of multiple lung structures and optimization of scan protocols for specific pathology.
KEY POINTS: • The aim of this study was to verify if the higher spatial resolution of UHR-PCCT would improve the visibility and detection of certain lung structures and abnormalities. • UHR-PCCT was judged to have superior clinical image quality compared to conventional HR-EIDCT in the evaluation of the lungs. UHR-PCCT showed better visibility for almost all tested lung structures (except for ground glass nodules). • Despite superior image quality, the readers perceived no significant impact on the diagnostic interpretation of the studied lung structures and abnormalities.
引用
- Van Ballaer V, Dubbeldam A, Muscogiuri E, et al. Impact of ultra-high-resolution imaging of the lungs on perceived diagnostic image quality using photon-counting CT. Eur Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37650968. doi:10.1007/s00330-023-10174-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。