指南与共识泌尿生殖MR

磁共振图像引导放疗前列腺床勾画共识指南的制定及其对观察者间变异性的评估

Development of Prostate Bed Delineation Consensus Guidelines for Magnetic Resonance Image-Guided Radiotherapy and Assessment of Its Effect on Interobserver Variability.
指南 / 共识 · Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys · 2023-08-25

本研究以16名放射肿瘤学家在3例Elekta Unity MR-Linac的MRI上勾画前列腺床CTV,建立基线观察者间变异性,并通过文献回顾和集体讨论制定国际共识指南后复评。指南制定后观察者间变异性下降,最大体积比从4.7降至3.1,体积变异系数从40%降至34%,平均Dice相似系数从0.72升至0.75,平均一致距离从3.63 mm降至2.95 mm,但观察者间变异性仍持续存在。

要点

  • 基线勾画在上界、下界和前界存在显著差异,是观察者间变异的主要来源。
  • 共识指南制定后勾画一致性改善,但观察者间变异性仍持续存在。
  • 作者认为教育项目、勾画图谱和指南进一步细化可能带来额外改善。

核心结论

  • 国际泌尿生殖专家间前列腺床勾画存在观察者间变异性,但低于既往报道。
  • 已制定基于MRI的前列腺床勾画共识指南,该指南改善了勾画一致性。
  • 观察者间变异性仍持续存在,作者认为教育项目、勾画图谱和指南进一步细化可能带来额外改善。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究类型为观察者间变异性评估研究,纳入16名放射肿瘤学家。
  • 勾画对象为3例来自Elekta Unity MR-Linac的MRI扫描上的前列腺床CTV,按各自常规实践勾画。
  • 参考标准为同时真实与性能水平估计(STAPLE)轮廓,采用重叠指标(Dice相似系数和Cohen kappa)、距离指标(平均一致距离和Hausdorff距离)及体积测量进行评估。
  • 进行了根治性前列腺切除术后局部复发模式的文献回顾,并与观察者间变异性结果一起呈现给参与者,集体构建共识指南后重复评估。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 基线观察者间变异性评估中重叠指标提示中等一致性,体积和距离指标显示更大变异性。
  • 指南制定后最大体积比从4.7降至3.1,体积变异系数从40%降至34%。
  • 指南制定后平均Dice相似系数从0.72升至0.75,平均一致距离从3.63 mm降至2.95 mm。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 在MRI上勾画前列腺床CTV时,上界、下界和前界是观察者间差异显著的区域。
  • 使用该共识指南可改善前列腺床CTV勾画的一致性。
  • 作者认为教育项目、勾画图谱和指南进一步细化可能带来额外改善。

局限性

  • 观察者间变异性仍持续存在。
  • 作者认为教育项目、勾画图谱和指南进一步细化可能带来额外改善。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: The use of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in radiotherapy planning is becoming more widespread, particularly with the emergence of MRI-guided radiotherapy systems. Existing guidelines for defining the prostate bed clinical target volume (CTV) show considerable heterogeneity. This study aimed to establish baseline interobserver variability (IOV) for prostate bed CTV contouring on MRI, develop international consensus guidelines, and evaluate its effect on IOV.

METHODS AND MATERIALS: Participants delineated the CTV on 3 MRI scans, obtained from the Elekta Unity MR-Linac, as per their normal practice. Radiation oncologist contours were visually examined for discrepancies, and interobserver comparisons were evaluated against simultaneous truth and performance level estimation (STAPLE) contours using overlap metrics (Dice similarity coefficient and Cohen's kappa), distance metrics (mean distance to agreement and Hausdorff distance), and volume measurements. A literature review of postradical prostatectomy local recurrence patterns was performed and presented alongside IOV results to the participants. Consensus guidelines were collectively constructed, and IOV assessment was repeated using these guidelines.

RESULTS: Sixteen radiation oncologists' contours were included in the final analysis. Visual evaluation demonstrated significant differences in the superior, inferior, and anterior borders. Baseline IOV assessment indicated moderate agreement for the overlap metrics while volume and distance metrics demonstrated greater variability. Consensus for optimal prostate bed CTV boundaries was established during a virtual meeting. After guideline development, a decrease in IOV was observed. The maximum volume ratio decreased from 4.7 to 3.1 and volume coefficient of variation reduced from 40% to 34%. The mean Dice similarity coefficient rose from 0.72 to 0.75 and the mean distance to agreement decreased from 3.63 to 2.95 mm.

CONCLUSIONS: Interobserver variability in prostate bed contouring exists among international genitourinary experts, although this is lower than previously reported. Consensus guidelines for MRI-based prostate bed contouring have been developed, and this has resulted in an improvement in contouring concordance. However, IOV persists and strategies such as an education program, development of a contouring atlas, and further refinement of the guidelines may lead to additional improvements.

来源:Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Sritharan K, Akhiat H, Cahill D, et al. Development of Prostate Bed Delineation Consensus Guidelines for Magnetic Resonance Image-Guided Radiotherapy and Assessment of Its Effect on Interobserver Variability. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2023. PMID: 37633499. doi:10.1016/j.ijrobp.2023.08.051

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。