对比剂不良反应管理的模拟训练:一项系统综述
该系统综述纳入15篇文章共17项研究(3项随机试验、14项前后测研究),评估模拟训练在对比剂不良反应管理中的效果。所有16项评估知识的研究显示模拟后笔试成绩改善,多数研究舒适度或信心提升;但3项与讲授式教学对照的研究中,模拟组后测成绩未达统计学显著优于讲授组。
要点
- 模拟训练可改善放射科住院医师对比剂不良反应管理的笔试成绩与主观信心。
- 与讲授式教学对照的3项研究中,模拟组后测成绩未显著优于讲授组。
- 常见局限包括单组设计、未验证工具测学习结果、样本量有限及长期保留评估不足。
核心结论
- 模拟训练可产生与对比剂不良反应管理相关的主观改善和知识增益,但需进一步研究证明其优于传统讲授式教学。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索筛选146条结果后纳入15篇文章共17项研究(3项随机试验、14项前后测研究),模拟形式为动手操作或较少见的计算机模拟。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 纳入标准为招募放射科住院医师、提供聚焦对比剂不良反应管理的模拟训练、并与非模拟训练或无训练比较任何效果结局。
- 结局按Kirkpatrick层级和证据强度分类。
- 16项评估干预前后知识的研究中,模拟后笔试成绩均改善。
- 3项以讲授式教学为对照评估模拟后知识的研究中,模拟组后测成绩未达统计学显著优于讲授组。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 模拟训练可能改善放射科住院医师对比剂不良反应管理的主观舒适度或信心及知识。
- 作者认为需进一步研究证明模拟训练优于传统讲授式教学。
局限性
- 常见研究局限包括单组设计。
- 仅用未验证工具测量学习结局。
- 样本量有限。
- 长期保留评估有限。
- 需进一步研究证明模拟训练优于传统讲授式教学。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Simulation-based training has become increasingly prominent within medical education, but its utility within radiology remains underexplored.
OBJECTIVE: To appraise the evidence for the effectiveness of simulation on the management of adverse reactions to contrast media.
METHODS: A systematic search of the literature was conducted. Eligible studies recruited radiology residents, provided simulation-based training focused on contrast reaction management, and measured any effectiveness outcome compared with any nonsimulation training or no training. The quality of studies was appraised and outcomes were classified according to Kirkpatrick's hierarchy and the strength of evidence.
RESULTS: Out of 146 screened results, 15 articles were included that described 17 studies-3 randomized trials and 14 pretest-posttest studies of hands-on or, less commonly, computer-based simulation. In all 16 studies that assessed knowledge before and after intervention, written test scores improved after simulation. Most studies noted improvements in comfort or confidence managing contrast reactions as well. In all three studies that assessed knowledge after simulation and after didactic lecture as a control, posttest scores were not statistically significantly better in the simulation groups than the lecture groups. Common study limitations included single-group designs, measuring only learning outcomes using unvalidated instruments, modest sample sizes, and limited assessment of long-term retention.
CONCLUSION: Simulation produces subjective improvements and knowledge gain relevant to contrast reaction management. Further research is required to demonstrate superiority of simulation-based contrast reaction management training over traditional didactic lecture-based instruction.
引用
- Wahl AD, Saini N, Trinh K, et al. Simulation Training in the Management of Adverse Contrast Reactions: A Systematic Review. J Am Coll Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37517774. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2023.07.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。