功能性MRI而非白质纤维束分离可识别语言优势侧
回顾性研究纳入15名健康对照和61例脑肿瘤患者,比较语言fMRI偏侧化指数与扩散张量纤维束成像(单张量ST与球面反卷积SD模型,含HMOA指标)的不对称指数。所有受试者中任何纤维束的LI与AI均无显著相关;仅将利手(对照)或肿瘤体积(患者)作为协变量时才出现显著相关。作者认为目前不推荐用纤维束成像指标替代fMRI评估语言偏侧化。
要点
- 所有受试者中,各纤维束的fMRI偏侧化指数与纤维束不对称指数均无显著相关。
- 仅在校正利手(对照)或肿瘤体积(患者)后出现部分显著相关。
- ST与SD模型的AI结果不一致,作者不推荐用纤维束成像替代fMRI评估语言偏侧化。
核心结论
- 结果不支持用纤维束成像评估语言偏侧化;ST与SD结果不一致提示纤维束的结构偏侧化可能不如功能偏侧化稳健,或纤维束成像方法本身不敏感,应发展其他扩散分析方式。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入15名健康受试者和61例脑肿瘤患者,均行语言fMRI与扩散加权MRI;计算区域fMRI偏侧化指数(LI),并分离弓状束(长直接束与短间接束)、钩束、下纵束、下额枕束和额斜束,用单张量(ST)与球面反卷积(SD)模型分析纤维束体积,SD纤维束另计算HMOA,得到各纤维束不对称指数(AI),用线性回归评估LI与AI的相关性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以区域fMRI偏侧化指数(LI)为功能偏侧化指标,以纤维束体积(ST、SD模型)及SD纤维束的HMOA计算的不对称指数(AI)为结构偏侧化指标。
- 所有受试者中,任何分离纤维束的LI与AI均无显著相关;仅在纳入利手(对照)和肿瘤体积(患者)作为协变量时才发现显著相关。
- 在利手亚组中,部分纤维束的平均AI与LI偏侧方向相同,部分相反;基于ST与SD的AI结果不一致。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,尽管扩散纤维束成像在难以配合的肿瘤患者及需要镇静或麻醉时比fMRI更可行,目前结果不推荐用基于体积或HMOA的纤维束成像替代fMRI评估语言偏侧化。
- 阅读语言偏侧化相关影像时,应注意ST与SD模型及不同纤维束指标所得AI方向可不一致。
局限性
- 原文指出ST与SD结果不一致,提示纤维束的结构偏侧化可能不如功能偏侧化稳健,或纤维束成像方法不敏感,并认为应发展其他扩散分析方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Lateralisation of some language pathways has been reported in the literature using diffusion tractography, which is more feasible than functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) in challenging patients. Our retrospective study investigates whether a correlation exists between threshold-independent fMRI language lateralisation and structural lateralisation using tractography in healthy controls and brain tumour patients.
METHODS: Fifteen healthy subjects and 61 patients underwent language fMRI and diffusion-weighted MRI. A regional fMRI laterality index (LI) was calculated. Tracts dissected were the arcuate fasciculus (long direct and short indirect tracts), uncinate fasciculus, inferior longitudinal fasciculus, inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus and frontal aslant tract. An asymmetry index (AI) for each tract was calculated using tract volume analysed with single tensor (ST) and spherical deconvolution (SD) models, as well as hindrance modulated orientational anisotropy (HMOA) for SD tracts. Linear regression assessed the correlation between LI and AI.
RESULTS: In all subjects, there was no significant correlation between LI and AI for any of the dissected tracts. Significant correlations were only found when handedness for controls and tumour volume for patients were included as covariates. In handedness subgroups, the average AI of some tracts showed the same laterality as LI, and some the opposite. Discordant results were observed for ST- and SD-based AIs.
CONCLUSIONS: Our results do not support using tractography in the assessment of language lateralisation. The discordant results between ST and SD indicate that either the structural lateralisation of dissected tracts is less robust than functional lateralisation, or tractography is not sensitive methodology. Other diffusion analysis approaches should be developed.
CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT: Although diffusion tractography may be more feasible than fMRI in challenging tumour patients and where sedation or anaesthesia is required, our results do not currently recommend replacing fMRI with tractography using volume or HMOA in the assessment of language lateralisation.
KEY POINTS: • No correlation found between fMRI and tractography in language lateralisation. • Discordance between asymmetry indices of different tractography models and metrics. • Tractography not currently recommended in language lateralisation assessment.
引用
- Al Busaidi A, Gangemi E, Wastling S, et al. Functional MRI but not white matter fibre dissection identifies language dominance. Eur Radiol. 2023. PMID: 37410110. doi:10.1007/s00330-023-09838-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。