文献速递胸部

人工智能如何回应常见肺癌问题:ChatGPT与Google Bard的对比

How AI Responds to Common Lung Cancer Questions: ChatGPT vs Google Bard.
PubMed 文献 · Radiology · 2023-01-01

该研究以40个与肺癌预防、筛查及放射学报告术语相关的非专家问题,测试ChatGPT-3.5、Google Bard实验版、Bing和Google搜索引擎各回答120题。ChatGPT-3.5正确85题(70.8%),Google Bard仅回答97题且正确62题(51.7%);ChatGPT-3.5正确或部分正确的可能性约为Google Bard的1.5倍(OR=1.55,P=0.004)。结论认为没有任何工具能全部正确且100%一致地回答所有问题。

要点

  • ChatGPT-3.5正确85/120题(70.8%),Google Bard仅回答97/120题且正确62题(51.7%)。
  • ChatGPT-3.5正确或部分正确的可能性约为Google Bard的1.5倍(OR=1.55,P=0.004)。
  • ChatGPT-3.5与Google搜索引擎的一致性分别约为Google Bard的7倍和29倍(OR=6.65、OR=28.83,P=0.002)。

核心结论

  • ChatGPT-3.5准确率高于其他工具,但ChatGPT、Google Bard、Bing和Google搜索引擎均未做到全部问题正确回答且100%一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究由三位作者向ChatGPT-3.5、Google Bard实验版、Bing和Google搜索引擎提出40个相同问题,共获得120次回答。
  • 问题基于美国放射学会Lung-RADS v2022和Fleischner学会推荐,涉及肺癌预防、筛查及放射学报告常用术语。
  • 每份回答由两位放射科医师审核准确性,评分为正确、部分正确、错误或未回答,并评估三种回答间的一致性。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • ChatGPT-3.5回答120题:正确85题(70.8%)、部分正确14题(11.7%)、错误21题(17.5%)。
  • Google Bard未回答23题(19.1%);在回答的97题中正确62题(51.7%)、部分正确11题(9.2%)、错误24题(20%)。
  • Bing回答120题:正确74题(61.7%)、部分正确13题(10.8%)、错误33题(27.5%)。
  • Google搜索引擎回答120题:正确66题(55%)、部分正确27题(22.5%)、错误27题(22.5%)。
  • ChatGPT-3.5正确或部分正确的可能性约为Google Bard的1.5倍(OR=1.55,P=0.004);ChatGPT-3.5与Google搜索引擎的一致性分别约为Google Bard的7倍和29倍(OR=6.65,P=0.002;OR=28.83,P=0.002)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文结论指出,尽管ChatGPT-3.5准确率较高,但ChatGPT、Google Bard、Bing和Google搜索引擎均未全部正确且100%一致地回答所有问题。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

Background The recent release of large language models (LLMs) for public use, such as ChatGPT and Google Bard, has opened up a multitude of potential benefits as well as challenges. Purpose To evaluate and compare the accuracy and consistency of responses generated by publicly available ChatGPT-3.5 and Google Bard to non-expert questions related to lung cancer prevention, screening, and terminology commonly used in radiology reports based on the recommendation of Lung Imaging Reporting and Data System (Lung-RADS) v2022 from American College of Radiology and Fleischner society. Materials and Methods Forty of the exact same questions were created and presented to ChatGPT-3.5 and Google Bard experimental version as well as Bing and Google search engines by three different authors of this paper. Each answer was reviewed by two radiologists for accuracy. Responses were scored as correct, partially correct, incorrect, or unanswered. Consistency was also evaluated among the answers. Here, consistency was defined as the agreement between the three answers provided by ChatGPT-3.5, Google Bard experimental version, Bing, and Google search engines regardless of whether the concept conveyed was correct or incorrect. The accuracy among different tools were evaluated using Stata. Results ChatGPT-3.5 answered 120 questions with 85 (70.8%) correct, 14 (11.7%) partially correct, and 21 (17.5%) incorrect. Google Bard did not answer 23 (19.1%) questions. Among the 97 questions answered by Google Bard, 62 (51.7%) were correct, 11 (9.2%) were partially correct, and 24 (20%) were incorrect. Bing answered 120 questions with 74 (61.7%) correct, 13 (10.8%) partially correct, and 33 (27.5%) incorrect. Google search engine answered 120 questions with 66 (55%) correct, 27 (22.5%) partially correct, and 27 (22.5%) incorrect. The ChatGPT-3.5 is more likely to provide correct or partially answer than Google Bard, approximately by 1.5 folds (OR = 1.55, P = 0.004). ChatGPT-3.5 and Google search engine were more likely to be consistent than Google Bard by approximately 7 and 29 folds (OR = 6.65, P = 0.002 for ChatGPT and OR = 28.83, P = 0.002 for Google search engine, respectively). Conclusion Although ChatGPT-3.5 had a higher accuracy in comparison with the other tools, neither ChatGPT nor Google Bard, Bing and Google search engines answered all questions correctly and with 100% consistency.

来源:Radiology,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Rahsepar AA, Tavakoli N, Kim GHJ, et al. How AI Responds to Common Lung Cancer Questions: ChatGPT vs Google Bard. Radiology. 2023. PMID: 37310252. doi:10.1148/radiol.230922

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。