改良德尔菲法研究:与胎盘植入谱系疾病相关的超声征象
通过改良德尔菲法专家共识,明确标准化及新超声征象在胎盘植入谱系疾病(PAS)产前评估中的作用。系统综述纳入15篇文献描述8种新征象;31名外部专家参与首轮,30名外部专家(97%)和7名指导组专家完成全部三轮,共识定义为参与者间 agreement ≥70%。专家组共识认为既往至少一次剖宫产、子宫肌瘤剔除术或PAS史应作为详细PAS超声评估的指征,并将7种常规征象纳入高危患者检查及妊娠中期常规扫描报告;对8种新征象均未达成共识。
要点
- 既往至少一次剖宫产、子宫肌瘤剔除术或PAS史应作为详细PAS超声评估的指征。
- 7种常规征象应纳入高危患者检查及妊娠中期常规扫描报告:清晰区消失、子宫肌层变薄、膀胱壁中断、胎盘膨出、子宫膀胱血管过度增生、胎盘腔隙、桥接血管。
- 对预测分娩时高概率PAS患者的手术结局,共识仅涉及清晰区消失、膀胱壁中断、胎盘腔隙存在及累及宫颈的前置胎盘。
核心结论
- 研究确认了7种已建立的标准化PAS超声征象的持续重要性,强调了经阴道超声在评估胎盘位置和宫颈解剖中的作用,并识别了未来可能用于PAS高危患者产前评估和管理的新超声征象。
研究设计与样本
- 改良德尔菲法专家共识研究;系统综述纳入15篇描述8种新超声征象的同行评议英文原创研究;三轮德尔菲法由9名专家组成的指导组引导,邀请国际产科超声专家组参与;31名外部专家参与首轮,30名外部专家(97%)和7名指导组专家完成全部三轮;共识定义为参与者间 agreement ≥70%。
关键影像表现/征象
- 共识认为既往至少一次剖宫产、子宫肌瘤剔除术或PAS史应作为详细PAS超声评估的指征。
- 11种常规PAS征象中7种应纳入高危患者检查及妊娠中期常规扫描报告:清晰区消失、子宫肌层变薄、膀胱壁中断、胎盘膨出、子宫膀胱血管过度增生、胎盘腔隙、桥接血管。
- 系统综述识别的8种新超声征象均未达成共识。
- 对非PAS特异性但增加分娩时PAS概率的其他超声特征,专家组对前置胎盘位于前壁或前置胎盘伴宫颈受累达成共识。
- 对预测分娩时高概率PAS患者的手术结局,共识涉及清晰区消失、膀胱壁中断、胎盘腔隙存在及累及宫颈的前置胎盘。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 共识定义为参与者间 agreement ≥70%。
- 专家组共识仅对使用现有评分量化胎盘腔隙达成一致。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对既往至少一次剖宫产、子宫肌瘤剔除术或PAS史的高危患者,应进行详细PAS超声评估。
- 在高危患者检查及妊娠中期常规扫描报告中,应包含7种常规PAS征象:清晰区消失、子宫肌层变薄、膀胱壁中断、胎盘膨出、子宫膀胱血管过度增生、胎盘腔隙、桥接血管。
- 经阴道超声用于评估胎盘位置和宫颈解剖。
- 对前置胎盘位于前壁或前置胎盘伴宫颈受累者,应关注其增加分娩时PAS概率。
- 对预测分娩时高概率PAS患者的手术结局,关注清晰区消失、膀胱壁中断、胎盘腔隙存在及累及宫颈的前置胎盘。
局限性
- 系统综述仅纳入同行评议的英文原创研究。
- 对系统综述识别的8种新超声征象均未达成共识。
- 专家共识中仅对使用现有评分量化胎盘腔隙达成一致,其他PAS征象的量化未达成共识。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To determine, by expert consensus through a modified Delphi process, the role of standardized and new ultrasound signs in the prenatal evaluation of patients at high risk of placenta accreta spectrum (PAS).
METHODS: A systematic review of articles providing information on ultrasound imaging signs or markers associated with PAS was performed before the development of questionnaires for the first round of the Delphi process. Only peer-reviewed original research studies in the English language describing one or more new ultrasound sign(s) for the prenatal evaluation of PAS were included. A three-round consensus-building Delphi method was then conducted under the guidance of a steering group, which included nine experts who invited an international panel of experts in obstetric ultrasound imaging in the evaluation of patients at high risk for PAS. Consensus was defined as agreement of ≥ 70% between participants.
RESULTS: The systematic review identified 15 articles describing eight new ultrasound signs for the prenatal evaluation of PAS. A total of 35 external experts were approached, of whom 31 agreed and participated in the first round. Thirty external experts (97%) and seven experts from the steering group completed all three Delphi rounds. A consensus was reached that a prior history of at least one Cesarean delivery, myomectomy or PAS should be an indication for detailed PAS ultrasound assessment. The panelists also reached a consensus that seven of the 11 conventional signs of PAS should be included in the examination of high-risk patients and the routine mid-gestation scan report: (1) loss of the 'clear zone', (2) myometrial thinning, (3) bladder-wall interruption, (4) placental bulge, (5) uterovesical hypervascularity, (6) placental lacunae and (7) bridging vessels. A consensus was not reached for any of the eight new signs identified by the systematic review. With respect to other ultrasound features that are not specific to PAS but increase the probability of PAS at birth, the panelists reached a consensus for the finding of anterior placenta previa or placenta previa with cervical involvement. The experts were also asked to determine which PAS signs should be quantified and consensus was reached only for the quantification of placental lacunae using an existing score. For predicting surgical outcome in patients with a high probability of PAS at delivery, a consensus was obtained for loss of the clear zone, bladder-wall interruption, presence of placental lacunae and presence of placenta previa involving the cervix.
CONCLUSIONS: We have confirmed the continued importance of seven established standardized ultrasound signs of PAS, highlighted the role of transvaginal ultrasound in evaluating the placental position and anatomy of the cervix, and identified new ultrasound signs that may become useful in the future prenatal evaluation and management of patients at high risk for PAS at birth. © 2023 The Authors. Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Jauniaux E, D'Antonio F, Bhide A, et al. Modified Delphi study of ultrasound signs associated with placenta accreta spectrum. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 36609827. doi:10.1002/uog.26155
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。