直肠癌MRI反应评估方法的比较:一项多中心、多阅片者验证研究
22名放射科医生回顾性阅读10个中心90例直肠癌患者放化疗后MRI,比较四种反应评估方法。含DWI的方法在诊断性能、组间观察者间一致性和阅片者偏好综合上结果最有利;阅片者经验和图像质量明显影响诊断性能。
要点
- 含DWI的DWI-patterns法准确度68%、特异度82%、组间IOA 0.43,73%阅片者首选。
- mrTRG敏感度较高(57%)但特异度(64%)和准确度(62%)低于其他方法(p < 0.001)。
- split-scar法组间IOA较低(0.18 vs 0.39-0.43),阅片者经验对除该法外的诊断性能和IOA有显著正向影响。
核心结论
- 综合诊断性能、组间观察者间一致性和阅片者偏好,含DWI的方法结果最有利;阅片者经验和图像质量明显影响诊断性能,强调需要先进影像和专门的放射科医生培训。
研究设计与样本
- 多中心、多阅片者回顾性验证研究:22名放射科医生(5名直肠MRI专家、17名普通/腹部放射科医生)回顾性阅读10个中心90例患者放化疗后MRI(非标准化扫描方案),应用四种反应评估方法。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 预测完全缓解(对照残留肿瘤)的平均敏感度/特异度/准确度:mrTRG为57%/64%/62%;split-scar为36%/79%/66%;modified-mrTRG为40%/79%/67%;DWI-patterns为37%/82%/68%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 图像质量采用0-6分评分(包括层厚和平面内分辨率、序列角度、DWI b值、信噪比和伪影),评分<4分为低于平均水平;低于平均图像质量对诊断性能有显著负向影响。
局限性
- 原文为回顾性研究。
- 扫描方案为非标准化方案。
- 原文结论强调需要先进影像和专门的放射科医生培训。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare four previously published methods for rectal tumor response evaluation after chemoradiotherapy on MRI.
METHODS: Twenty-two radiologists (5 rectal MRI experts, 17 general/abdominal radiologists) retrospectively reviewed the post-chemoradiotherapy MRIs of 90 patients, scanned at 10 centers (with non-standardized protocols). They applied four response methods; two based on T2W-MRI only (MRI tumor regression grade (mrTRG); split-scar sign), and two based on T2W-MRI+DWI (modified-mrTRG; DWI-patterns). Image quality was graded using a 0-6-point score (including slice thickness and in-plane resolution; sequence angulation; DWI b-values, signal-to-noise, and artefacts); scores < 4 were classified below average. Mixed model linear regression was used to calculate average sensitivity/specificity/accuracy to predict a complete response (versus residual tumor) and assess the impact of reader experience and image quality. Group interobserver agreement (IOA) was calculated using Krippendorff's alpha. Readers were asked to indicate their preferred scoring method(s).
RESULTS: Average sensitivity/specificity/accuracy was 57%/64%/62% (mrTRG), 36%/79%/66% (split-scar), 40%/79%/67% (modified-mrTRG), and 37%/82%/68% (DWI-patterns); mrTRG showed higher sensitivity but lower specificity and accuracy (p < 0.001) compared to the other methods. IOA was lower for the split scar method (0.18 vs. 0.39-0.43). Higher reader experience had a significant positive effect on diagnostic performance and IOA (except for the split scar sign); below-average imaging quality had a significant negative effect on diagnostic performance. DWI pattern was selected as the preferred method by 73% of readers.
CONCLUSIONS: Methods incorporating DWI showed the most favorable results when combining diagnostic performance, IOA, and reader preference. Reader experience and image quality clearly impacted diagnostic performance emphasizing the need for state-of-the-art imaging and dedicated radiologist training.
KEY POINTS: • In a multireader study comparing 4 MRI methods for rectal tumor response evaluation, those incorporating DWI showed the best results when combining diagnostic performance, IOA, and reader preference. • The most preferred method (by 73% of readers) was the "DWI patterns" approach with an accuracy of 68%, high specificity of 82%, and group IOA of 0.43. • Reader experience level and MRI quality had an evident effect on diagnostic performance and IOA.
引用
- El Khababi N, Beets-Tan RGH, Tissier R, et al. Comparison of MRI response evaluation methods in rectal cancer: a multicentre and multireader validation study. Eur Radiol. 2022. PMID: 36576549. doi:10.1007/s00330-022-09342-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。