脑血管病理的诊断错误:大型三级学术医疗中心神经放射学数据库的回顾性分析
该回顾性分析检索了2015—2020年单中心连续245,762例次CT与MR神经影像报告,发现165份报告存在脑血管诊断错误,其中93.3%为感知性错误、93.9%有临床意义;错误多发生于急诊/住院场景且与更高读片量班次相关。
要点
- 急性/亚急性梗死(25.1%)、动脉瘤(13.7%)和硬膜下血肿(9.7%)是最常见漏诊病变。
- 93.3%的脑血管诊断错误为感知性错误,93.9%(n=155)具有临床意义(RADPEER 2B或3B)。
- 错误班次平均读片量49.6±23.3例,无错误班次34.9±19.2例(P<.0001)。
核心结论
- 多数脑血管诊断错误为感知性且具有临床意义,发生于急诊/住院场景,并与更高读片量班次相关;作者认为可通过调整搜索模式以确保对常漏诊病变部位的警觉来减少诊断错误。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心三级学术机构连续数据库的回顾性分析,检索2015—2020年245,762例次CT与MR神经影像报告,收集主治医师脑血管病理漏诊发现、检查类型与解读场景,错误分为缺血性、动脉性、静脉性、出血性和「其他」。
关键影像表现/征象
- 急性/亚急性梗死占漏诊的25.1%,动脉瘤占13.7%,硬膜下血肿占9.7%。
- 错误分布为动脉性与缺血性各占33.3%,出血性占21.8%,静脉性占7.5%。
- 多数错误涉及脑MR(30.3%),其次为头部CTA(27.9%)和平扫头部CT(26.1%)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 165份报告存在血管诊断错误,其中93.3%为感知性错误、6.7%为解读性错误。
- 93.9%(n=155)的错误具有临床意义(RADPEER 2B或3B)。
- 错误班次平均读片量49.6(SD,23.3)例,无错误班次34.9(SD,19.2)例(P<.0001)。
- 70%的检查发生于住院场景。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为可通过调整搜索模式以确保对常漏诊病变部位(急性/亚急性梗死、动脉瘤、硬膜下血肿)的警觉来减少诊断错误。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Diagnostic errors affect 2%-8% of neuroradiology studies, resulting in significant potential morbidity and mortality. This retrospective analysis of a large database at a single tertiary academic institution focuses on diagnostic misses in cerebrovascular pathology and suggests error-reduction strategies.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: CT and MR imaging reports from a consecutive database spanning 2015-2020 were searched for errors of attending physicians in cerebrovascular pathology. Data were collected on missed findings, study types, and interpretation settings. Errors were categorized as ischemic, arterial, venous, hemorrhagic, and "other."
RESULTS: A total of 245,762 CT and MR imaging neuroradiology examinations were interpreted during the study period. Vascular diagnostic errors were present in 165 reports, with a mean of 49.6 (SD, 23.3) studies on the shifts when an error was made, compared with 34.9 (SD, 19.2) on shifts without detected errors (P < .0001). Seventy percent of examinations occurred in the hospital setting; 93.3% of errors were perceptual; 6.7% were interpretive; and 93.9% (n = 155) were clinically significant (RADPEER 2B or 3B). The distribution of errors was arterial and ischemic each with 33.3%, hemorrhagic with 21.8%, and venous with 7.5%. Most errors involved brain MR imaging (30.3%) followed by head CTA (27.9%) and noncontrast head CT (26.1%). The most common misses were acute/subacute infarcts (25.1%), followed by aneurysms (13.7%) and subdural hematomas (9.7%).
CONCLUSIONS: Most cerebrovascular diagnostic errors were perceptual and clinically significant, occurred in the emergency/inpatient setting, and were associated with higher-volume shifts. Diagnostic errors could be minimized by adjusting search patterns to ensure vigilance on the sites of the frequently missed pathologies.
引用
- Biddle G, Assadsangabi R, Broadhead K, et al. Diagnostic Errors in Cerebrovascular Pathology: Retrospective Analysis of a Neuroradiology Database at a Large Tertiary Academic Medical Center. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2022. PMID: 35926887. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A7596
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。