超声医师进行胎儿畸形筛查的临床工作流程:基于深度学习的分析
该研究前瞻性采集496例孕中期常规畸形筛查的完整视频,用深度学习自动标注解剖结构事件,分析超声医师的扫查顺序。结果显示各标准切面检出率较高(头/脑97.2%、脊柱95.0%、腹部93.1%、股骨92.3%、冠状面鼻唇86.1%),但起始结构与结构间转换顺序因人而异,无两例扫描序列完全相同,提示超声医师多根据胎儿体位和结构可见性灵活获取标准切面,而非遵循固定顺序。
要点
- 孕中期畸形筛查中头/脑、脊柱、腹部、股骨、冠状面鼻唇的存储检出率分别为97.2%、95.0%、93.1%、92.3%、86.1%。
- 超声医师最常以头/脑(24.4%)、脊柱(23.2%)或胸/心脏(22.8%)作为起始结构开始扫查。
- 各例畸形筛查的扫查序列均不相同,连续三个及以上结构的顺序转换较少见(最高13%的扫描)。
核心结论
- 孕中期常规畸形筛查中获取结构的数量和顺序存在广泛变异,每例扫描序列均独特,提示超声医师根据胎儿体位和结构可见性灵活获取标准切面,而非遵循严格固定的采集顺序。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,采集496例由14名超声医师完成的孕中期常规畸形筛查全程视频,自动检测图像冻结和图像/片段保存事件,用专门训练和测试的深度学习标注模型将事件前后视频标注为11种常见解剖结构之一。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 英国指南规定必须存储五个不同解剖区域的图像或视频片段;头/脑检出率97.2%、冠状面鼻唇86.1%、腹部93.1%、脊柱95.0%、股骨92.3%;起始结构为头/脑24.4%、脊柱23.2%、胸/心脏22.8%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为超声医师利用胎儿体位、根据结构可见性获取标准切面,而非遵循严格采集顺序;最常见两结构转换为胎盘/羊水至母体解剖(44.5%)、头/脑至冠状面鼻唇(42.7%)、腹部至胸/心脏(26.1%)、三维/四维面部至矢状面轮廓(23.7%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Despite decades of obstetric scanning, the field of sonographer workflow remains largely unexplored. In the second trimester, sonographers use scan guidelines to guide their acquisition of standard planes and structures; however, the scan-acquisition order is not prescribed. Using deep-learning-based video analysis, the aim of this study was to develop a deeper understanding of the clinical workflow undertaken by sonographers during second-trimester anomaly scans.
METHODS: We collected prospectively full-length video recordings of routine second-trimester anomaly scans. Important scan events in the videos were identified by detecting automatically image freeze and image/clip save. The video immediately preceding and following the important event was extracted and labeled as one of 11 commonly acquired anatomical structures. We developed and used a purposely trained and tested deep-learning annotation model to label automatically the large number of scan events. Thus, anomaly scans were partitioned as a sequence of anatomical planes or fetal structures obtained over time.
RESULTS: A total of 496 anomaly scans performed by 14 sonographers were available for analysis. UK guidelines specify that an image or videoclip of five different anatomical regions must be stored and these were detected in the majority of scans: head/brain was detected in 97.2% of scans, coronal face view (nose/lips) in 86.1%, abdomen in 93.1%, spine in 95.0% and femur in 92.3%. Analyzing the clinical workflow, we observed that sonographers were most likely to begin their scan by capturing the head/brain (in 24.4% of scans), spine (in 23.2%) or thorax/heart (in 22.8%). The most commonly identified two-structure transitions were: placenta/amniotic fluid to maternal anatomy, occurring in 44.5% of scans; head/brain to coronal face (nose/lips) in 42.7%; abdomen to thorax/heart in 26.1%; and three-dimensional/four-dimensional face to sagittal face (profile) in 23.7%. Transitions between three or more consecutive structures in sequence were uncommon (up to 13% of scans). None of the captured anomaly scans shared an entirely identical sequence.
CONCLUSIONS: We present a novel evaluation of the anomaly scan acquisition process using a deep-learning-based analysis of ultrasound video. We note wide variation in the number and sequence of structures obtained during routine second-trimester anomaly scans. Overall, each anomaly scan was found to be unique in its scanning sequence, suggesting that sonographers take advantage of the fetal position and acquire the standard planes according to their visibility rather than following a strict acquisition order. © 2022 The Authors. Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Drukker L, Sharma H, Karim JN, et al. Clinical workflow of sonographers performing fetal anomaly ultrasound scans: deep-learning-based analysis. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2022. PMID: 35726505. doi:10.1002/uog.24975
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。