使用两种公开软件包比较CT与MRI获得的全局脑容量测量值
在69例(35名男性)12个月内接受MR与CT脑扫描的患者中,用SPM和FSL两种公开软件分割WM、GM和CSF,CT与MR体积相关系数分别为0.93和0.98,但各分割流程内全局体积差异显著(P<.05),CT高估WM、低估GM,重复性良好(变异系数<10%)。
要点
- CT与MR全局脑体积相关系数:SPM为0.93,FSL为0.98。
- CT较MR高估WM(SPM偏差36%,FSL偏差18%),低估GM(SPM偏差10%,FSL偏差6%)。
- 各分割的重复性良好,所有体积变异系数<10%。
核心结论
- 使用公开软件的CT分割重复性良好,与MR相关性好;在仔细设计研究并承认测量偏差的前提下,CT在某些情况下可能成为MR的可行替代方案。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入69例(35名男性)12个月内同时接受MR和CT脑扫描的患者,使用统计参数映射(SPM)和FMRIB软件库(FSL)两种公开软件分割WM、GM和CSF;部分有重复扫描的患者用于评估各分割的重复性;采用回归分析和Bland-Altman一致性界限确定分割体积间的一致性水平。
诊断标准与关键数值
- MR与CT体积相关系数:SPM为0.93,FSL为0.98。
- 各分割流程内所有全局体积差异均显著(P<.05)。
- WM偏差:SPM为36%(标准差38%),FSL为18%(标准差18%);GM偏差:SPM为10%(标准差30%),FSL为6%(标准差20%),CT较MR高估WM、低估GM。
- 所有分割重复性良好,所有体积变异系数<10%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 使用公开软件对CT进行脑组织分割时,需注意CT较MR高估WM、低估GM的系统偏差。
- 在仔细设计研究并承认测量偏差的前提下,CT在某些情况下可能成为MR的可行替代方案。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Brain volumetrics have historically been obtained from MR imaging data. However, advances in CT, along with refined publicly available software packages, may support tissue-level segmentations of clinical CT images. Here, brain volumetrics obtained by applying two publicly available software packages to paired CT-MR data are compared.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a group of patients (n = 69; 35 men) who underwent both MR imaging and CT brain scans within 12 months of one another, brain tissue was segmented into WM, GM, and CSF compartments using 2 publicly available software packages: Statistical Parametric Mapping and FMRIB Software Library. A subset of patients with repeat imaging sessions was used to assess the repeatability of each segmentation. Regression analysis and Bland-Altman limits of agreement were used to determine the level of agreement between segmented volumes.
RESULTS: Regression analysis showed good agreement between volumes derived from MR images versus those from CT. The correlation coefficients between the 2 methods were 0.93 and 0.98 for Statistical Parametric Mapping and FMRIB Software Library, respectively. Differences between global volumes were significant (P < .05) for all volumes compared within a given segmentation pipeline. WM bias was 36% (SD, 38%) and 18% (SD, 18%) for Statistical Parametric Mapping and FMRIB Software Library, respectively, and 10% (SD, 30%) and 6% (SD, 20%) for GM (bias ± limits of agreement), with CT overestimating WM and underestimating GM compared with MR imaging. Repeatability was good for all segmentations, with coefficients of variation of <10% for all volumes.
CONCLUSIONS: The repeatability of CT segmentations using publicly available software is good, with good correlation with MR imaging. With careful study design and acknowledgment of measurement biases, CT may be a viable alternative to MR imaging in certain settings.
引用
- Fielden SW, Beiler D, Cauley KA, et al. A Comparison of Global Brain Volumetrics Obtained from CT versus MRI Using 2 Publicly Available Software Packages. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2022. PMID: 35121586. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A7403
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。